Economics of streaming are 'threatening future of music', says Elbow's Guy Garvey

Musicians from Radiohead, Gomez and Elbow tell MPs that the industry must reform and be made fairer

The three major music labels are operating “like a cartel” in the streaming era and the current system is threatening the future of music in the UK, according to evidence given on the first day of an inquiry into the impact of streaming on the music industry.

During the digital, culture, media and sport select committee inquiry into the economics of music streaming, MPs heard from musicians including Ed O’Brien of Radiohead, Elbow’s Guy Garvey, and Tom Gray of Gomez, who painted a bleak picture of artists struggling to survive.

Garvey said the “system as it is is threatening the future of music”, while equitable remuneration, increased transparency and user-centric streaming models were put forward as ways in which the industry could be reformed and made fairer for artists.

Gray, who is the founder of #BrokenRecord Campaign, said some artists were still tied to contracts that included antiquated clauses, such as a 10% damage clause, which saw labels work on the assumption that 10% of CDs would be broken in transport.

An artist’s share is then worked out from the remaining 90%, despite the fact in the streaming age barely any CDs are sold. Tom Frederikse, a solicitor and former producer, who also gave evidence, said in some cases the damage clause was as high as 25%.

“What’s very clear is over 70% of consumers think artists are underpaid. As soon as anyone sees this data and learns the terms of the payment deal, everyone comes to the same conclusion: it’s not right,” said Gray.

After hearing the evidence, Julie Elliott MP said it sounded as if the three major labels – Warner Brothers, Sony and Universal – were operating “like a cartel” because of what Gray called “suspiciously similar” artist contracts.

Gray referred to a recent YouGov poll which found that 77% of customers believed artists were not getting a fair deal, and reports that Universal recorded revenues of $1.14bn in the last quarter despite the global pandemic and economic downturn.

MPs heard that the huge profits seen by major labels were not trickling down to artists who, in the case of Nadine Shah who also gave evidence, were struggling to make ends meet in the streaming era. Streaming was worth around £1bn last year, however, artists had been reportedly paid only 13% of the income generated.

The musicians said artists were having to adapt to a streaming model that had rapidly replaced the system that existed when they were first signed.

O’Brien said when Radiohead were signed in 1991 there were huge imbalances but that the streaming era had exacerbated them. “It’s interesting to see your reaction to the testimony this morning because you’re becoming aware of the unfairness and the opaqueness within the business, and then you’re bolting on this digital model. And it’s not working,” he said.

Garvey said Elbow had recently shortened the intro of a track so that it would be more likely to appear on playlists. Gray told the committee that genres such as jazz and classical were struggling because their longer length tracks don’t suit the playlist system, which he said benefits easy listening and muzak.

Gray also told the committee he had heard of cases in which people who ran influential playlists on streaming platforms were being paid to include tracks, calling it a modern form of “payola”.

The inquiry continues and will hear the “perspectives of industry experts, artists and record labels as well as streaming platforms themselves”. The chair, Julian Knight MP, said the goal was to ask whether the business models used by major streaming platforms were “fair to the writers and performers who provide the material”.


Lanre Bakare Arts and culture correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Guy Garvey says music fans should pay more for streaming services
Elbow frontman says system is not sustainable and bands are struggling to sustain careers

Lanre Bakare Arts and culture correspondent

30, Nov, 2020 @2:38 PM

Article image
Spotify, Pandora and the profits problem for streaming music

Artists like Thom Yorke are angry about meagre musician payouts, but concerns remain over long-term business models. By Stuart Dredge

Stuart Dredge

01, Aug, 2013 @4:45 PM

Article image
Slipping discs: music streaming revenues of $6.6bn surpass CD sales
Popularity of services such as Spotify outstrips traditional formats for first time

Mark Sweney

24, Apr, 2018 @12:50 PM

Article image
Music streaming hailed as industry's saviour as labels enjoy profit surge
Some record labels have had their biggest rise in revenue in over a decade thanks to services such as Spotify and Apple Music

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

29, Dec, 2016 @2:09 PM

Article image
Google music streaming would boost industry, says Universal executive
Digital revenues up 9% in 2012 to $5.6bn as search giant rumoured to be planning move into market dominated by iTunes . By Josh Halliday

Josh Halliday

27, Feb, 2013 @11:27 AM

Article image
MPs to examine impact of streaming on future of music industry
Culture committee chair Julian Knight said it would investigate whether the business models used by major streaming platforms are fair to writers and performers

Laura Snapes

15, Oct, 2020 @11:58 AM

Article image
Digital streaming behind biggest rise in UK music sales for two decades
Platforms such as Apple Music and Spotify plus renaissance in vinyl records help fuel fastest annual growth since 1998

Sarah Butler

03, Jan, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
MP says record boss 'in cloud cuckoo land' over music streaming claims
John Nicolson responds to Universal Music UK chair after he says artists ‘very happy’ with payments

Lanre Bakare Arts and culture correspondent

19, Jan, 2021 @3:39 PM

Article image
Jay Z’s music-streaming service Tidal struggles despite celebrity fanfare
It had the backing of artists such as Kanye West and Rihanna and was hailed as the music industry’s salvation, but Tidal is showing early signs of failure

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

22, Apr, 2015 @4:52 PM

Article image
‘Odds are against you’: the problem with the music streaming boom
As dust from the gold rush settles, big record companies and elite artists emerge firmly on top

Mark Sweney

02, Oct, 2021 @6:00 AM