Pilots confronted Boeing with 737 Max fears after first fatal crash, audio reveals

  • Boeing appeared to play down concerns of a second crash
  • Audio release comes as House committee reviews FAA role

American Airlines (AA) pilots angrily confronted a Boeing official about an anti-stall system suspected in two fatal crashes of the manufacturer’s 737 Max aircraft, according to a new recording.

In audio obtained by CBS News, members of AA’s pilots’ union quizzed Boeing officials about the system – knowns as MCAS – in a tense meeting in November last year, weeks after a Lion Air Max crashed in Indonesia and four months before the loss of an Ethiopian Airlines Max. In total, 346 people died in the two crashes.

Boeing has been criticized for not disclosing how the MCAS anti-stall system worked – a move that allowed the company to avoid costly retraining.

“We flat-out deserve to know what is on our airplanes,” one pilot is heard saying in the recording.

“These guys didn’t even know the damn system was on the airplane – nor did anybody else,” another said.

The official, Boeing vice-president Mike Sinnett, claimed the Lion Air disaster was a once-in-a-lifetime accident.

He said: “I don’t know that understanding this system would’ve changed the outcome on this. In a million miles, you’re going to maybe fly this airplane, maybe once you’re going to see this, ever. So we try not to overload the crews with information that’s unnecessary so they actually know the information we believe is important.”

The pilots countered: “We’re the last line of defence to being in that smoking hole, and we need the knowledge.”

Boeing said it would make software changes but did not want to “rush and do crappy job of fixing the right things”. The fix was still being developed when the Ethiopian Airlines jet went down.

The release of the recording came as the House transportation committee opened a hearing into the role of Boeing’s regulator, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), in certifying the Max.

Democrat Rick Larsen, a member of the committee and the chair of the aviation subcommittee, said: “The FAA has a credibility problem.” He cited a Wall Street Journal story that claimed an internal review had found that senior FAA officials did not participate in or monitor crucial safety assessments of MCAS.

Larsen said: “If that is in fact true, the [designation] process is not working as Congress intended.”

The acting FAA administrator, Daniel Elwell, said he was “not aware of an internal assessment that reaches that conclusion”.

Elwell was criticized for the FAA’s decision to hold off on grounding the US’s Max fleet after the second crash. The FAA was the last major world regulator to ground the plane and did so only after Donald Trump announced that the plane would be grounded.

Democratic congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton said: “Why did it take so long compared to other countries? The public wants to know: why did it take so long?”

Elwell said the FAA was a “data-driven, risk based system” and acted after it had received sufficient data to link the two crashes.


Dominic Rushe in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Man whose family died in 737 Max crash accuses Boeing of ‘utter disrespect’
Paul Njoroge warned at congressional hearing there will be more deaths unless action is taken

Dominic Rushe in New York

17, Jul, 2019 @3:50 PM

Article image
FAA let Boeing 737 Max continue to fly even as review found serious crash risk
Analysis from US regulators found plane could have averaged a fatal crash about every two to three years without design changes

Dominic Rushe in New York

11, Dec, 2019 @4:30 PM

Article image
American Airlines union: blaming pilots for Boeing 737 Max crashes 'inexcusable'
Allied Pilots Association says jetmaker’s anti-stall software forced plane into such an aggressive dive pilots could not recover

Edward Helmore in New York

23, May, 2019 @3:40 PM

Article image
Boeing: internal emails reveal chaos and incompetence at 737 Max factory
Executives mocked their regulator and joked about safety in hundreds of messages given to congressional investigators

Dominic Rushe in New York

10, Jan, 2020 @3:57 PM

Article image
Boeing reports lowest order numbers in 30 years following 737 Max catastrophes
Company reported 87 more cancellations than new purchases in 2019, after two crashes led to worldwide 737 grounding

Edward Helmore in New York

14, Jan, 2020 @5:01 PM

Article image
Boeing dismissed chance of 'bird strike' that may have caused second 737 Max crash
US investigators explore whether bird collision triggered Ethiopian Airlines crash in March, which occurred months after Lion Air disaster

Dominic Rushe in New York

21, May, 2019 @3:25 PM

Article image
Boeing board under pressure as families of 737 Max crash victims push reform at the top
More directors could be pushed off next week as aerospace firm tries to recover its reputation after 737 Max problems and Covid downturn

Edward Helmore in New York

18, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Boeing: global grounding of 737 Max will cost company more than $1bn
Plane-maker says it’s abandoned 2019 financial outlook and halted share buybacks in mid-March as it deals with crisis

Dominic Rushe , Rob Davies and agencies

24, Apr, 2019 @6:27 PM

Article image
Boeing profits fall by more than half as 737 Max scandal swirls
Aircraft company, which saw 737 Max grounded after fatal crashes, says it will also cut production of 787 Dreamliner jet

Edward Helmore in New York

23, Oct, 2019 @4:39 PM

Article image
Boeing says it could halt production of 737 Max after grounding
The company lost $2.9bn in the three months to the end of June, compared to a profit of $2.2bn for the same period last year

Dominic Rushe in New York

24, Jul, 2019 @6:23 PM