Watchdog to investigate Neil Woodford fund suspension

FCA intervention follows questions about oversight despite rush of withdrawals from troubled flagship fund

The City regulator has launched a formal investigation into the suspension of Neil Woodford’s flagship investment fund amid criticism that the regulator was asleep at the wheel.

In a new blow to the one-time star fund manager, the Financial Conduct Authority chief executive, Andrew Bailey, revealed the investigation in a 10-page letter to Nicky Morgan, the Treasury select committee chair and MP.

The MP had asked the regulator to provide details of its contact with the embattled stock picker before his £3.7bn Equity Income Fund was closed to withdrawals on 3 June, and questioned the FCA’s “alertness to the problems”.

The fund’s suspension has trapped thousands of customer investments for at least four weeks.

A Woodford spokesperson said: “We can confirm we have been contacted by the FCA, regarding its investigation relating to the events that led to the suspension … and will be co-operating fully with its investigation.”

Questions have been raised over whether the regulator missed signs that Woodford was in trouble, as the rate of withdrawals from his poorly performing flagship equity income fund gained pace. It was finally gated when Kent county ouncil asked for the return of £263m.

In his letter, Bailey said the watchdog had been in contact with Link – the authorised administrator of the fund – since February 2018. Between April and December last year the FCA had held monthly monitoring discussions.

In February this year, the FCA said, it was told about the sale of a number of unlisted and illiquid investments in the fund to another Woodford fund – his Patient Capital Investment Trust.

At the end of March, Bailey wrote, the watchdog became “aware of press articles” about some investments in the Equity Income Fund being listed on the Guernsey exchange. That move, which is entirely legal, allowed the fund to stay within the 10% EU limit for the proportion of unlisted investments which can be held in such a fund.

The letter also revealed that from 24 April this year Link was providing daily updates about the rate of withdrawals from the underperforming fund.

Bailey said Woodford was allowed to earmark unlisted shares for a listing in Guernsey to avoid falling foul of the rules, but that the rules should be revisited, because a listing on the Guernsey exchange did not necessarily mean the shares could be sold more easily.

Bailey and the FCA chairman, Charles Randell, will be grilled over the Woodford debacle next week when they give evidence to the Treasury select committee.

The news of the formal investigation came as Fidelity banned its customers from putting money into another of Woodford’s funds.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

The investment platform, one of Britain’s biggest said it was halting new investments in the £325m Woodford Income Focus Fund, a sister fund to the Equity Income Fund. The Income Focus Fund is not suspended and investors can still withdraw their cash.

A Fidelity said: “We believe this is in the best interest of our platform clients, unless and until, uncertainties are resolved.” It said the restrictions were “temporary and precautionary.”

A Woodford spokesperson said: “The fund was set up with the aim to deliver an income of 5p per share per annum, which it has achieved. The fund mainly invests in companies that pay a dividend and, ever since its launch, the portfolio has contained a combination of large, mid- and small-sized companies.

“It doesn’t have any exposure to illiquid or unquoted securities and consequently isn’t exposed to the same issues that the Woodford Equity Income Fund is. ”

Shares in Woodford’s FTSE 250-listed vehicle, Patient Capital Trust, slumped to a fresh low of 51.8p on Tuesday. They have fallen almost 33% since Woodford’s flagship fund was suspended.

Fidelity’s move emerged as Bank of England policymaker Anil Kashyap warned that if the Woodford debacle were to undermine confidence in the financial system, it could become a very big problem, and that the central bank was watching closely.

Kashyap told Morgan’s Treasury select committee: “I don’t think Woodford per se creates financial stability risk, but if it undermines confidence in the system it could be a very big problem.”

Kashyap, a member of the Bank’s financial policy committee, added: “It’s a very visible thing, it’s got people worrying about whether or not this is going to be present elsewhere. We are going to keep watching it and if it ever gets to the point where there’s substantial assets in a vehicle like that, that could give rise to widespread spillovers, we’d have to do something about it.”


Contributors

Kalyeena Makortoff , Julia Kollewe and Phillip Inman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Neil Woodford fund was sailing close to the wind, watchdog says
City regulator tells MPs the investment manager broke spirit of rules before crisis

Richard Partington

25, Jun, 2019 @6:14 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford dropped by major backer after suspending fund
St James’s Place terminates stock picker’s contract hours after his YouTube apology to investors

Angela Monaghan and Kalyeena Makortoff

05, Jun, 2019 @4:55 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford loyalists pay dearly for stock-picker's style drift
Winding up of flagship fund should also be a big lesson for Hargreaves Lansdown

Nils Pratley

28, Jan, 2020 @6:35 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford needs permission to set up new firm, says FCA
City regulator still investigating collapse of fund manager’s previous business

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

17, Feb, 2021 @11:20 AM

Article image
Neil Woodford refuses to waive fees despite pressure from MPs and FCA
Regulator said City stock-picker should scrap charges on frozen Equity Income Fund

Kalyeena Makortoff

11, Jun, 2019 @1:01 PM

Article image
Investment manager Neil Woodford to set up new firm
Launch – and public apology – comes two years after implosion of his last venture following bets that went wrong

Jasper Jolly

14, Feb, 2021 @2:46 PM

Article image
Hargreaves Lansdown apologises to clients in Neil Woodford funds
FTSE 100 stockbroker firm had come under fire from investors whose money is trapped

Phillip Inman

09, Jun, 2019 @4:58 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford fund investors to share second £142m payout
Payout, which is due in March, represents a fraction of £2.1bn pot distributed in January

Kalyeena Makortoff

12, Mar, 2020 @7:15 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford: star fund manager mixes arrogance and humility
The top stock-picker manages billions – but admits ‘you will get things wrong’

Rupert Neate

04, Jun, 2019 @1:50 PM

Article image
Hargreaves Lansdown founder attacks Neil Woodford over frozen fund
Peter Hargreaves says fund manager appears not to have been truthful about performance

Simon Goodley

22, Sep, 2019 @3:59 PM