National Grid urged to explain response to rush-hour blackouts

Former infrastructure tsar Lord Adonis says firm has questions to answer over failures that cut supply to one million people

National Grid must urgently explain why it failed to prioritise the supply of electricity to key parts of Britain during Friday’s blackouts, the government’s former infrastructure tsar has said.

The demand by Lord Adonis, former chair of the government’s National Infrastructure Commission, came as it emerged that the company had been concerned for more than a year about how its system responded to power shortages.

Almost one million people in England and Wales lost electricity on Friday after the failure of a gas-fired power station in Bedfordshire and several units at an offshore windfarm in the Humber.

The result was chaos. Traffic lights stopped working, and key hubs including Newcastle airport and Ipswich hospital were hit. There was major disruption to the country’s railways and London underground during the busy Friday night commute.

“Why did this happen now?” Adonis asked. “This is the middle of August, not the end of November. Why were key transport installations affected when they should have been protected from any but the most extreme power breakdowns? National Grid haven’t been able to answer either of those two questions. They need to provide answers and improvements in both respects.”

The failure of the two generators saw a loss of 5% of the grid’s electricity – some 1.4 gigawatts. This was less than the 1.8 gigawatts lost in 2008 when two different generators failed. Then, about 500,000 people lost power, but major infrastructure systems were unaffected.

“This is a big wake-up call for National Grid,” Adonis said. “Their resilience is below par. They need to improve their processes for ensuring the resilience of national transport and medical installations in the event of power shortages.”

The failure of the two generators on Friday caused a frequency drop in the electricity system which, while sizable, should not have troubled it unduly, according to experts.

“The frequency went down to less than 49Hz, so certain parts of the network started to disconnect automatically, causing the power cuts until the system came back into balance and the frequency stabilised,” said Phil Hewitt, a director at energy consultancy EnAppSys. “We would have expected the system to cope with this size of loss of generation but the double hit may have destabilised it.”

National Grid has to maintain the system close to 50Hz to keep it stable. But industry sources said that, the frequency had previously fallen to dangerously low levels three times in the last 12 weeks.

Offshore Wind Farm
The power failure was partially caused by the failure of an offshore windfarm on the Humber. Photograph: Ashley Cooper/Barcroft Images

The company said: “Following the event, the other generators on the network responded to the loss by increasing their output as expected. However, due to the scale of the generation losses this was not sufficient, and to protect the network and ensure that restoration to normal operation could be completed as quickly as possible, a backup protection system was triggered which disconnects selected demand across GB.”

How this backup system functioned is now expected to form part of the investigation into what went wrong on Friday.

The failure of the two power stations in 2008, and the resulting fluctuation in energy frequency on the grid, caused some smaller generators – of which there are around 50,000 across the UK – to detect the disturbance and shut down in a safety operation that the energy industry refers to as “loss of mains protection”.

A National Grid presentation in March suggested the system might be “too sensitive,” causing smaller generators to shut down prematurely when disturbances were detected, leading to blackouts. In a July 2018 presentation, the National Grid claimed such widespread shutdowns were a risk that occurred once every 12 years.

The company’s director of operations, Duncan Burt, said its safety protection systems had worked well to keep the grid safe.

But he conceded that the industry needed to examine whether it was set up correctly to have “minimal impact” on people’s daily lives.

David Hunter, an analyst at Schneider Electric, told the BBC that the UK’s transition to clean energy could also be creating “greater stresses” on the system because energy such as wind power is less effective as a “shock absorber” compared to nuclear or gas turbines when there are shifts in supply and demand on the grid.


Jamie Doward and Jillian Ambrose

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Freezing weather costs UK economy £1bn a day
Financial impact of the ‘beast from the east’ and Storm Emma worst since Christmas 2010

Phillip Inman, Gwyn Topham and Adam Vaughan

03, Mar, 2018 @7:25 PM

Article image
Blackouts? What blackouts? How National Grid keeps the lights on
A visit to the chief control centre in Berkshire reveals how solar and wind are keeping blackouts at bay … for now

Adam Vaughan

06, Feb, 2017 @1:12 PM

Article image
Winter electricity blackouts risk recedes, says National Grid
Extra power will mean lights will not go out this winter, says firm that operates UK’s electricity transmission network

Rob Davies

14, Oct, 2016 @10:47 AM

Article image
National Grid plays down fears of power crunch and blackouts
But chief executive says that energy supplies will be tighter this winter than last

Sean Farrell

10, Nov, 2015 @9:08 AM

Article image
National Grid says new-style stability software will avoid blackouts
Operator is working on series of agreements with companies including General Electric

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

21, Aug, 2019 @7:06 PM

Article image
National Grid to reward businesses for saving electricity to head off blackouts
Energy regulator Ofgem says cost of scheme to avoid winter 2014/15 blackouts will be passed on to consumers

Terry Macalister

19, Dec, 2013 @5:25 PM

Article image
UK may avoid winter blackouts owing to lower demand, says National Grid
‘No threat’ to energy system, as people stay away from offices, pubs and restaurants during pandemic

Jillian Ambrose

15, Oct, 2020 @4:36 PM

Article image
National Grid starts talks over cutting energy supplies to head off blackouts
Grid to begin talks with dozen customers to encourage them to sign multi-year deals to have supplies rationed in return for discounts

Terry Macalister

15, May, 2014 @5:37 PM

Article image
As a dividend freeze sweeps the FTSE, will National Grid power up investors?
The owner of the UK’s high-voltage network may cut returns to shareholders, but don’t bank on it

Jasper Jolly

13, Jun, 2020 @11:05 PM

Article image
National Grid warns on electricity management handover
Utility firm raises concerns as government considers options for increasing competition and preventing blackouts

Terry Macalister

03, Mar, 2016 @1:05 PM