'Greenwash': oil giant under fire over plan to protect tropical forests

Campaigners say move by Norway’s Equinor is an excuse to keep drilling for fossil fuels

One of the world’s biggest oil companies is set to join the fight against deforestation in the tropics as part of its climate change efforts – but the the move has been branded a “greenwash” by campaigners.

State-owned Norwegian firm Equinor has written to the UN’s climate chief to tell her it wants to invest in the protection of tropical forests.

The letter, sent less than a fortnight before the UN climate summit in Poland, is the latest sign that big oil sees a major role in forestry as a way to preserve business models based on drilling for oil and gas for decades when scientists say the world needs drastic emissions cuts.

Ben van Beurden, the Shell chief executive, recently said reforestation on the scale of the Amazon rainforest will be needed to meet a tougher global warming target. The Anglo Dutch firm offers forestry-based carbon offsets to business customers who buy its gas.

This year alone, BP signed a deal with Chinese firm Elion to buy forestry sector carbon offsets, and has invested in US forest carbon offsets company Finite Carbon.

French oil and gas giant Total told investors recently that “investing in [the] preservation of forests, mangrove and humid zones” would be essential as part of “carbon compensation for the long run”.

Eldar Saetre, the Equinor chief executive, said protecting tropical forests was “one of the most important and effective climate actions”.

The firm, formerly known as Statoil, said it was readying forestry investments equivalent to 1m tonnes of CO2, or the size of the footprint of its operations in the US and Brazil, which put no price on carbon.

In the letter to Patricia Espinosa, executive director of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, Saetre said the company wanted to see the creation of an international carbon market based on forests and the carbon locked within. While there are existing forestry-based carbon offsetting schemes, Equinor said it wanted to help develop a robust and international carbon market based on the principles of avoiding deforestation, like the flagship UN scheme, Redd+.

Asked if the interest in forests was simply an excuse to keep pumping oil and gas, an Equinor spokesperson said the work was in addition to its key climate efforts of reducing emissions from operations and growing renewables.

However, Simone Lovera, executive director of the Global Forest Coalition, an alliance of NGOs, said: “It’s absolute greenwash. By definition forest carbon offsets don’t add anything to mitigating climate change.

“The big problem is there is no guarantee when you plant trees that that forest will be there in 20-30 years, the emissions reductions might not be permanent.”

Reforestation was cited as essential in all the four scenarios recently laid out by the UN’s climate science panel if the world is to limit future temperature rises to 1.5C.

Other groups said Equinor’s letter was welcome but investments in forests had to be a complement to companies cutting their own carbon footprints.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

“For it to be meaningful they must commit to hard measurable targets both for cutting emissions in their operations and for investing in renewables,” said Andrew Norton, director of the UK-based International Institute for Environment and Development.

Oil industry watcher Wood Mackenzie said getting involved in tree-planting was useful as part of fossil fuel companies’ climate efforts, but would not be cheap.

Valentina Kretzschmar, the group’s research director, said: “Reforestation is one of the levers that that can be pulled to help mitigate climate change, however it will be expensive. Without regulatory changes, it is simply not commercially viable for any oil and gas company to start investing in reforestation.”

• This article was amended on 27 November 2018 to add more details of Equinor’s stated intentions.


Adam Vaughan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ecuadorean tribe will 'die fighting' to defend rainforest

Kichwa villagers from Sani Isla vow to resist oil prospecting by state-backed company Petroamazonas at all costs

Jonathan Watts, Latin America correspondent

13, Jan, 2013 @5:51 PM

Article image
Petition to halt oil exploration in Ecuadorean Amazon gets 1m signatures
Campaign urges Ecuador to stop exploration threatening indigenous community in area of exceptional biodiversity

Jonathan Watts in Quito

06, Feb, 2013 @2:45 PM

Article image
World pays Ecuador not to extract oil from rainforest

Governments and film stars join alliance that raises £75m to compensate Ecuador for lost revenue from 900m barrels

John Vidal, environment editor

30, Dec, 2011 @3:32 PM

Article image
US drives rainforest destruction by importing Amazon oil, study finds
The report found that California, despite its green reputation, is refining the majority of crude oil – with one facility accounting for 24% of the US total

Oliver Milman

28, Sep, 2016 @12:00 PM

Article image
Sale of oil and gas permits casts shadow over world’s second-largest rainforest
Villagers in the Congo basin rely on the forest for food, medicine and spiritual wellbeing, but an auction of exploration rights could threaten that way of life

Cassie Dummett

01, Nov, 2022 @12:15 PM

Article image
Ecuador pursued China oil deal while pledging to protect Yasuni, papers show

Negotiations took place while the country sought funds to forgo oil exploitation in pristine forest under the Yasuni-ITT scheme

David Hill

19, Feb, 2014 @3:57 PM

Article image
Norway to double carbon tax on oil industry

Extra funding for climate change mitigation and forestry programmes also part of oil-rich nation's radical programme

Severin Carrell, Scotland correspondent

11, Oct, 2012 @12:52 PM

Article image
Norway's $1tn wealth fund to divest from oil and gas exploration
World’s largest sovereign wealth fund was created to invest North Sea oil profits

Rob Davies

08, Mar, 2019 @4:03 PM

Article image
Peru declares environmental state of emergency in its rainforest

Government reports high levels of barium, lead, chrome and petroleum-related compounds in region that is home to oil field

Dan Collyns in Lima

26, Mar, 2013 @6:42 PM

Article image
Oil giant Shell set to appeal against ruling on carbon emissions
Company hopes to get Dutch court ruling overturned which called for it to cut emissions faster

Jillian Ambrose

20, Jul, 2021 @3:42 PM