BT loses appeal to change method of pensions calculation

Bid to use consumer price index for future payments could have cost members £2bn

BT has lost a legal bid to make changes to its pension scheme that unions claim would have transferred an estimated £2bn of wealth from scheme members to shareholders.

The court of appeal dismissed the company’s request to change the way it calculates increases to pensions – a move that would have affected more than 80,000 members of the scheme.

These members each typically stood to lose an estimated £24,000 in future pension benefits if the appeal had been upheld, according to the union Prospect.

BT sought a ruling on whether it could change the index used to calculate pension increases paid to “section C” members of its defined benefit pension scheme. It currently uses the retail prices index (RPI), but believes the rules allow a switch to another index in certain circumstances. Sections A and B of the scheme are linked to the consumer price index (CPI).

CPI is generally lower than RPI, which is an index no longer widely used in government – prompting BT to argue that it had become inappropriate for increasing pensions.

Prospect said BT was “seeking to cut the future incomes of BT pensioners and current employees by tens of thousands of pounds in order to transfer an estimated £2bn to shareholders”.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

The high court decided in January 2018 that it was not possible to change to another index, and the court of appeal has now upheld that decision.

Other organisations have been allowed to make the switch in order to save money. In October it was announced that from May 2019, the returns for savers from National Savings & Investments index-linked savings certificates would be linked to CPI rather than RPI. NS&I is backed by the Treasury and said the move would result in a saving to the taxpayer of £610m over the next five years.

Commenting on the ruling, BT said: “We are disappointed with the outcome and will now consider the judgment in detail in order to decide next steps.”


Rupert Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
BT considering closing defined-benefit pensions scheme for existing staff
Move by telecoms group follows similar, but more advanced, proposal by Royal Mail Group that has led to strike action threat

Simon Goodley

30, May, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Regulator must chase Philip Green for BHS pension cash
The select committee made a mistake in allowing the former owner of BHS not to give precise details of how he would ‘sort’ the deficit in the schemes

Nils Pratley

25, Jul, 2016 @10:13 PM

Article image
A BT pension fund deficit of £14bn? Bosses need a new 'ology'
The telecoms group is trying to modify the defined benefits it promised staff in the 1980s

Simon Goodley

28, Jan, 2018 @4:05 PM

Article image
Council staff pensions at risk from Woodford investments
Three council pension funds have put in up to £10m in sister fund hit by suspension of flagship scheme

Kalyeena Makortoff and Julia Kollewe

16, Jun, 2019 @10:51 AM

Article image
Post Office faces further strikes over pensions
Unite union says its members plan to take industrial action after pension fund trustees approve proposal to cut benefits

Sarah Butler

12, Oct, 2016 @5:09 PM

Article image
Watchdog hails success of auto-enrolment pensions
Ten million more people now saving with big rises in private sector staff, the young and ethnic minorities

Patrick Collinson

24, Oct, 2019 @3:21 PM

Article image
Lloyds bank faces legal challenge over female staff pensions
Lloyds Trade Union starts court action over guaranteed minimum pensions which discriminate against women

Jill Treanor

08, Aug, 2016 @11:12 AM

Article image
UK pensions lifeboat to block Toys R Us survival plan
About 3,200 jobs at risk at 100-plus UK outlets after Pension Protection Fund says retailer’s insolvency plan fails to address its pension scheme deficit

Sarah Butler

19, Dec, 2017 @3:16 PM

Article image
Brexit adds £100m to potential cost of BHS pensions bailout
Sir Philip Green’s bill could hit £670m, including assumed overheads an insurance firm would seek to recoup

Sarah Butler

22, Jul, 2016 @5:26 PM

Article image
Flybe pensions at risk for 1,350 workers and ex-staff
Pension scheme based in Isle of Man sits outside jurisdiction of UK lifeboat scheme and not protected

Patrick Collinson

05, Mar, 2020 @6:33 PM