Royal Mail fined record £50m for breaking competition law

Ofcom finds company abused its dominant position in bulk mail delivery

Royal Mail has been fined a record £50m by the UK communications regulator for breaching competition law when it discriminated against its only major rival for delivering letters.

Ofcom said the company had abused its dominant position by penalising wholesale customers that sought to deliver bulk mail such as bank statements and council tax demands door to door.

The penalty followed an investigation into a complaint by Whistl about changes Royal Mail made to wholesale customer contracts in early 2014, including price increases.

At the time, Whistl was expanding its business to compete directly with Royal Mail by employing workers to deliver letters in parts of the UK. Previously the company, known as TNT at the time, had collected and carried out an initial sort of the letters before handing them all to Royal Mail for a final sort and delivery.

Ofcom said Royal Mail increased prices for competitors that did not reach volume targets for the whole of the UK. This in effect meant any competitor employing its own delivery workers in certain parts of the country, as Whistl did, would have to pay higher prices in areas where it used Royal Mail.

Royal Mail makes £1.5bn a year from delivering so-called access mail that is collected by other companies. Ofcom said under the 2014 price changes Whistl had to pay 0.25p more per letter for Royal Mail to make the final delivery than other operators that used it for all of the UK.

Ofcom said Royal Mail had used its dominant position in the mail market to penalise any wholesale customer that tried to compete with it on bulk mail delivery.

As a result, Whistl scrapped plans to extend its delivery services to new areas in 2015. It had intended to expand to cover 40% of the country, but the failed expansion ran up losses of £10m.

Jonathan Oxley, Ofcom’s competition director, said: “Royal Mail broke the law by abusing its dominant position in bulk mail delivery.

“All companies must play by the rules. Royal Mail’s behaviour was unacceptable and it denied postal users the potential benefits that come from effective competition.”

Royal Mail shares closed down 1.6% to 454.9p.

Ofcom said it inspected Royal Mail’s internal documents covering its price changes. They showed the adjustments were part of a deliberate strategy to limit competition in delivery as a direct response to the threat of competition from Whistl, the regulator said.

Royal Mail said it was very disappointed by Ofcom’s decision and strongly rejected any suggestion that it broke competition law, adding that that the decision was “without merit and fundamentally flawed”.It argued that the 2014 price change was never implemented or paid, adding that it had been “robustly stress tested by Royal Mail under competition law and the relevant regulatory framework”. The company said it was designed to protect its service from “cherry picking” letter delivery and the general decline in mail volumes.

Royal Mail said it would lodge an appeal against Ofcom’s fine with the competition appeal tribunal within the next two months.

When Whistl, which was owned by the Dutch delivery company PostNL, launched its delivery service in London, Manchester and Liverpool, Royal Mail criticised the move.

It said if competitors were allowed to take business in densely populated areas Royal Mail’s deliveries to rural districts would be threatened because profitable deliveries in towns and cities subsidised those in remote locations.

Ofcom told Royal Mail to respond to extra competition by becoming more efficient. Under the terms of its privatisation in 2013, Royal Mail is committed to maintaining its universal service at least until 2021.


Julia Kollewe

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ofcom to investigate Royal Mail over delivery target failures
Regulator announces move after fifth of first-class deliveries arrived day or more late in year to April

Jasper Jolly

31, May, 2022 @2:23 PM

Article image
Royal Mail brings forward last posting dates for Christmas
Service faces six days of strikes this month, as Ofcom says it should stop blaming pandemic for delays

Mark Sweney

02, Dec, 2022 @2:20 PM

Article image
Royal Mail loses appeal over £50m fine for breaking competition law
Ofcom fined company for ‘deliberate strategy of pricing discrimination’ against Whistl

Rob Davies

12, Nov, 2019 @4:53 PM

Article image
Royal Mail CEO accused of ‘incompetence or cluelessness’ by MPs
Remarks come as regulator Ofcom asked to investigate if firm broke legal obligation on letter deliveries

Alex Lawson

17, Mar, 2023 @12:01 AM

Article image
Ofcom to investigate Royal Mail dominance
Regulator will examine whether market changes could result in rising prices and the parcels sector becoming less competitive

Terry Macalister and Sean Farrell

17, Jul, 2015 @1:02 PM

Article image
Competition for Royal Mail could threaten universal service, MPs warn
Commons committee urges Ofcom to be vigilant about changes in market that might jeopardise six-day-a-week flat-rate service

Terry Macalister

12, Mar, 2015 @12:01 AM

Article image
Royal Mail fined £1.6m for late deliveries and stamp overcharging
Ofcom issues penalty for failure to meet postal target and second-class stamp error

Rob Davies

10, Jul, 2020 @11:16 AM

Article image
TNT Post fears Royal Mail privatisation will create monopoly
TNT says new rules will drive rivals out of Britain if Royal Mail is given discretion on allowing access to delivery network

Tim Webb

07, Dec, 2010 @5:13 PM

Article image
Royal Mail faces possible fine as regulator looks into late deliveries
Only 73.7% of first-class mail and 90.7% of second class met delivery targets, according to the postal service

Alex Lawson

15, May, 2023 @2:42 PM

Article image
Ofcom offers little hope to Royal Mail | Roy Mayall
Roy Mayall: Royal Mail has a new regulator, but its proposals fail to protect the service from privatisation and unfair competition

Roy Mayall

28, Oct, 2011 @7:00 AM