UK green energy expensive? Not any more. From now on it's cheap

A record low price set for offshore wind power is good for UK jobs, the taxpayer and household bills. It is bad news for Hinkley C and the nuclear industry

The persistent myth that green energy is expensive has been shredded by the revelation that windfarms will be built around Britain’s coast far more cheaply than new nuclear reactors.

New power stations in the UK today are usually only built with the certainty provided by subsidies paid through energy bills, so the record low guaranteed price awarded to the developers of three new mega offshore windfarms today is, first and foremost, welcome news for consumers.

It is also good for the economy post-Brexit, for the foreign-owned developers behind the multibillion-pound projects, and the increasingly UK-based supply chain that supports them, such as Siemens’ £310m wind turbine factory in Hull.

But there is no mistaking the fact that the low prices, labelled “astonishing”, “exceptional” and “astounding”, are terrible news for nuclear proponents.

Ministers last year awarded French state-owned EDF £92.50 per megawatt hour of power generated by two new reactors at Hinkley Point C in Somerset.

The price is nearly twice that of wholesale power and is goldplated by being inflation-linked and written in stone for 35 years. EDF said this week that future nuclear plants, such as the new one it wants to build at Sizewell in Suffolk, would be cheaper than Hinkley.

But even the most vociferous nuclear supporters think that Sizewell C and a Japanese-backed bid to build new reactors at Wylfa in Wales would not come in below £80 per MWh, compared with the £57.50 per MWh over 15 years for new offshore windfarms.

Ironically for the party that champions free market economics, the Conservatives’ commitment to a fleet of new nuclear power plants is being challenged by competition.

Windfarm developers have to compete against one another in a reverse auction, ensuring the government gets the cheapest price for the low carbon power it needs. The price this time crashed so much that only £176m-a-year of the £240m subsidy pot set aside by officials will be needed.

The timescales and monolithic nature of nuclear projects means it would be hard, albeit not impossible, for the government to run a competitive process for them. Playing EDF off against consortiums such as Horizon, which is behind Wylfa, is not really an option.

Of course, wind power is variable, unlike the steady power provided by nuclear, so there are costs to the energy system of integrating all those new turbines. But experts say those costs are relatively negligible, especially if coupled with flexible and smart technologies such as batteries, which the government is backing with hundreds of millions of pounds.

So large-scale renewable power built in the next decade will be inarguably much cheaper than nuclear.

But it’s not just about cost – offshore windfarms can be built quicker, too. Their modular nature means they can be built in stages, and offshore wind generally has a good track record of being built on time in the UK. The projects that won subsidies this week should be operational by 2023.

By comparison, Hinkley Point C is officially slated to be operational by 2025 but EDF admitted earlier this year that it could run 15 months over schedule. And the track record of plants being built with Hinkley’s reactor design is infamous: Olkiluoto in Finland is a decade behind schedule; the other, at Flamanville in France, is six years late.

The price awarded to offshore windfarms is also even lower than new gas power plants, but this week’s auction is unlikely to spell the death of gas, which can be built much more cheaply and quickly than nuclear. Witness the German utility Uniper publicly mulling over the idea of taking apart its gas power stations in Germany and rebuilding them in the UK.

But today could be, as the trade group RenewableUK puts it, a “gamechanger” for ministers in charge of setting energy policy.

With a major government review of the cost of energy due out in October, there are calls for Theresa May to at the very least commit to further support for offshore wind and, more radically, to drop plans for new nuclear. It’s become clear which way the wind is blowing.

Contributor

Adam Vaughan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Drop in wind energy costs adds pressure for government rethink
Tories urged to look at onshore windfarms which can be built as cheaply as gas plants and deliver the same power for half the cost of Hinkley Point, says Arup

Adam Vaughan

23, Jul, 2017 @5:03 PM

Article image
Nuclear plans 'should be rethought after fall in offshore windfarm costs'
Lib Dems and green groups say reduced price of state support should sound death knell for plants such as Hinkley Point C

Adam Vaughan

11, Sep, 2017 @6:02 PM

Article image
New UK nuclear funding model could leave taxpayers liable
Ministers are expected to announce plans to bolster nuclear industry this week

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

14, Jul, 2019 @1:10 PM

Article image
Hinkley Point's first impact will be to add to consumers' bills | Nils Pratley

Nils Pratley: The UK would be agreeing to buy electricity from Hinkley Point at £93 per megawatt hour – roughly twice the current market rate

Nils Pratley

18, Oct, 2013 @9:02 PM

Article image
Energy firm RWE npower axes £4bn UK windfarm amid political uncertainty
UK's green plans dealt blow by shelving of Atlantic Array, which would have powered 1m homes and created thousands of jobs

Terry Macalister, Energy editor

26, Nov, 2013 @12:43 AM

Article image
UK nuclear power plant contract: £80bn deal or no deal?
Political parties and industry groups welcome low-carbon project as academics and campaigners question cost and waste

Fiona Harvey and Patrick Wintour

21, Oct, 2013 @7:53 PM

Article image
Plans to reform electricity market 'unworkable', say green businesses
UK's leading renewable energy companies warn that changes will deter investment and expose consumers to price volatility

Fiona Harvey, environment correspondent

15, May, 2012 @11:57 AM

Article image
Ed Davey urges big six energy firms to come clean on size of their profits

Energy secretary calls for more transparency from electricity and gas suppliers as deal on next-generation nuclear plants nears

Patrick Wintour, political editor

18, Oct, 2013 @7:57 PM

Article image
UK energy cap could have been avoided, lobby group says
Body representing big six suppliers says price cap is not inevitable and could have been avoided if industry had acted more quickly on ‘rip-off’ tariffs

Adam Vaughan

26, Dec, 2017 @2:58 PM

Article image
Hinkley Point C: the government should start planning alternatives | Nils Pratley
EDF has admitted the nuclear project is £1.5bn over budget – we shouldn’t be bullied into paying more

Nils Pratley

03, Jul, 2017 @7:07 PM