Bank of England rift as chief economist ponders interest rate rise

Andy Haldane reveals he seriously considered opposing governor Mark Carney in MPC vote earlier this month

Signs of a deepening rift on the Bank of England’s monetary policy committee have emerged after Threadneedle Street’s chief economist revealed he seriously considered opposing the governor, Mark Carney, and voting for an interest rate rise earlier this month.

Just 24 hours after Carney said the state of the economy and the uncertainty caused by Brexit meant borrowing costs should stay on hold, Andy Haldane said it would be prudent to tighten policy before the end of the year.

The June meeting of the MPC resulted in a 5-3 vote in favour of leaving rates on hold, with both the Bank’s governor and its chief economist voting with the majority.

But Haldane, previously one of the most doveish members of the committee, said the balance of risks had shifted so that the dangers of moving too late outweighed those of raising interest rates too soon.

Sterling rose on the foreign exchanges after Haldane spoke, with the City reassessing its view that interest rates would stay unchanged well into 2018. At one point, the pound was up three quarters of a cent against the US dollar to $1.27 before later falling back.

How the pound reacted

“The risks of tightening ‘too early’ have shrunk as growth and, to lesser extent, inflation have shown greater resilience than expected. And if policy tightened ‘too late’, this could result in a much steeper path of rate rises later on, contrary to the MPC’s collective expectation that Bank rate would increase ‘at a gradual pace and to a limited extent’,” Haldane said in a speech in Bradford.

The Bank reduced interest rates to a record low of 0.25% in the wake of last summer’s Brexit vote, but Haldane said that, despite the possibility that the economy could suffer as a result of Britain’s departure from the EU, the time for the first increase in borrowing costs in a decade was fast approaching, and would come much more quickly than the City was expecting.

“As the balance point between these risks has shifted over the past nine months, that has left me judging that a partial withdrawal of the additional policy insurance the MPC put in place last year would be prudent relatively soon, provided the data come in broadly as expected in the period ahead. Certainly, I think such a tightening is likely to be needed well ahead of current market expectations.”

Andy Haldane and Mark Carney give evidence to the Commons Treasury select committee.
Andy Haldane and Mark Carney give evidence to the Commons Treasury select committee. Photograph: PA

The Bank official said he had voted for no change at the MPC’s meeting for two reasons. First, he said there was evidence that deunionisation, rising self-employment, and the “gig economy” had resulted in weaker wage growth than in the past. Second, the election result had thrown up a dust cloud of uncertainty.

“Financial markets-wise, that is manifesting itself in a weaker exchange rate. It is unclear what twists and turns lie ahead, with potentially important implications for asset prices and, at least potentially, confidence among businesses and consumers. I do not think adding a twist or a turn from monetary policy would, in this environment, be especially helpful in building confidence, at least until the dust cloud has started to settle.

“Provided the data are still on track, I do think that beginning the process of withdrawing some of the incremental stimulus provided last August would be prudent moving into the second half of the year.”

Haldane said the first rate rise since before the deep recession of 2008-09 should be welcomed rather than feared. “As and when the MPC begins this process of normalising monetary policy, it will be a sign of the economy itself having begun to normalise. Far from being a cause for concern, starting the process of withdrawing some monetary policy insurance should serve as a signal of the MPC’s confidence in the UK economy’s resilience and in inflation returning sustainably to its 2% target.”

Lena Komileva, of G+Economics said:The growing split on the MPC signals a much higher risk of tightening this year than previously expected in the markets. With two new members joining the MPC in the second half of the year, an active policy debate on the merits of tightening, against the optics of a strong inflation overshoot, overheating consumer credit growth, and a tight labour market, may well tilt the vote in favour of a rate hike by the year-end.”


Larry Elliott Economics editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Bank of England must be wary of interest rate rise, says chief economist
Andy Haldane says UK at risk of sharp slowdown as BoE weighs up conflicting forces of inflation from weak pound and the Brexit vote denting confidence

Katie Allen

02, Dec, 2016 @2:37 PM

Article image
Interest rates may be cut, suggests Bank of England chief economist
Andrew Haldane’s view on tackling deflation risk strikes markedly different tone to governor Mark Carney, who said it would be foolish to cut rates now

Heather Stewart

19, Mar, 2015 @2:32 PM

Article image
UK inflation will fall rapidly, says ex-Bank of England economist
‘Pretty much nailed on’ that the rate will halve in next six months, according to Andy Haldane

Jasper Jolly

23, Apr, 2023 @12:56 PM

Article image
Bank of England's Michael Saunders: 'Prepare for higher interest rates'
The MPC member on why he voted for a rise – and why policymakers should not hold fire during Brexit talks

Katie Allen and Larry Elliott

04, Jul, 2017 @7:34 PM

Article image
Bank of England chief economist calls for big post-Brexit stimulus
Andy Haldane urges quick and decisive response to UK economic uncertainty including rate cut, more QE and cheap loans

Larry Elliott

15, Jul, 2016 @10:40 AM

Article image
Key Bank of England policymaker 'not ready' for interest rate rise
Ben Broadbent says ‘imponderables’ in UK economy include being a year or more away from knowing what Brexit means

Phillip Inman

13, Jul, 2017 @6:16 AM

Article image
Bank of England plays down prospect of interest rate cut
Three members of monetary policy committee give statements suggesting they see no sign of underlying deflationary pressure

Larry Elliott Economics editor

25, Mar, 2015 @8:44 PM

Article image
Bank of England meeting could discuss cutting interest rates
A recent run of bad news on the economy may have chipped away at Mark Carney and other policymakers’ certainty on the path for interest rates

Katie Allen

08, May, 2016 @12:41 PM

Article image
Bank of England decision to keep 0.5% interest rate was unanimous
All members of monetary policy committee rejected rate rise after previously split votes while analysts say likely coalition negotiations will delay changes

Heather Stewart

22, Apr, 2015 @11:32 AM

Article image
Interest rates can stay low for longer, says Bank of England deputy chief
Jon Cunliffe says factors such as weaker growth means current level can be maintained for longer than previously thought

Katie Allen

28, Oct, 2014 @7:47 PM