Don't relax rules on City after Brexit, Mark Carney warns

Bank of England governor predicts financial sector will thrive after Brexit but says there can be no return to the lax pre-2007 regime

The governor of the Bank of England has predicted that the financial sector could double in size to be 20 times as big as GDP within the next 25 years, but warned that the government must hold its nerve and resist pressure to water down regulation after Brexit.

Speaking to the Guardian to mark the 10th anniversary of the start of the global financial crisis in August 2007, Mark Carney said a thriving City meant more jobs, tax revenues and exports. But the governor said the City should not be allowed to expand rapidly if it meant repeating the risky speculation of a decade ago.

Carney dismissed suggestions that London could become a financial centre with only light-touch regulation – often dubbed Singapore-on-Thames – in order to attract business after the UK left the EU.

He said the size of the financial sector would increase relative to the size of the economy if things went according to plan after Brexit and that meant there could be no going back to the lax regime that existed before 2007.

The Bank, he said, was aware that “we have a financial system that is ten times the size of this economy … It brings many strengths, it brings a million jobs, it pays 11% of tax revenue, it is the biggest export industry by some token … All good things. But it’s risky”.

He went on: We have a view… that post-Brexit the level of regulation will be at least as high as it currently is and that’s a level that in many cases substantially exceeds international norms.

“There’s a reason for that, because we’re not going to to go the lowest common denominator in a system that is 10 times size of GDP. If the UK financial system thrives in a post-Brexit world, which is the plan, it will not be 10 times GDP, it will be 15 to 20 times GDP in another quarter of century because we will keep our market share of cross-border capital flows. Well then you really have to hold your nerve and keep the focus.”

The annual output of the UK economy (GDP) is about £1.9tn a year, but that is dwarfed by the assets of the financial sector, which includes banks, pension funds and insurance companies.

Carney has previously insisted the City has an important future role, despite Brexit, warning that European economies need to retain access to the City of London because the UK is the “investment banker for Europe”.

America’s national bank regulator has this week begun a consultation that could lead to a watering down of the Volcker rule - a post-crisis reform intended to restrict banks from using their own money to take bets on financial markets.

The City has been at the centre of much of the Brexit debate in the UK, with many foreign-owned banks threatening to move business out of London. But speculation that the City could become a low-tax financial centre with a bonfire of regulations was firmly stamped on by Carney.

The governor said central banks and financial regulators had to keep up their guard because the passing of time meant people started to forget why the rules had been put in place.

“The problem you have is that the same issues re-emerge under different labels … and the progress that’s been made … is gradually chipped away,” said Carney.

“There will always be innovations, there will be new strains, new vulnerabilities, old wine in new bottles, that will emerge around the periphery of the system. The challenge is for institutions such as the Bank is to anticipate those problems without snuffing out innovation,” he added.

The crisis that gripped the markets from the summer of 2007 took hold on 9 August that year when the French bank BNP Paribas announced it had blocked withdrawals from funds because of a “complete evaporation” of liquidity. Banks stopped lending to each other, the financial system seized up and six weeks later that resulted in the run on Northern Rock.


Larry Elliott and Jill Treanor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'It's hard to remember how fraught it was': Mark Carney on the credit crunch
Speaking to the Guardian 10 years on from the crash, the Bank of England governor recalls how the crisis played out

Larry Elliott and Jill Treanor

03, Aug, 2017 @5:00 PM

Article image
Firms plan to quit UK as City braces for more post-Brexit losses
Chancellor to make morning statement to reassure markets as survey reveals negative business impact of EU vote

Zoe Wood, Jill Treanor and Phillip Inman

26, Jun, 2016 @9:40 PM

Article image
Mark Carney to warn rogue City traders they should face 10 years in jail
Bank of England governor to unveil four-pronged attack against ‘ethical drift’ in global markets including a new standards board and stiffer prison sentences

Jill Treanor

10, Jun, 2015 @4:54 PM

Article image
Central bank action: stunning move highlights sense of desperation
European governments are desperately seeking a lender of last resort as sovereign debt exposure fears grow

Jill Treanor

30, Nov, 2011 @9:17 PM

Article image
UK loses triple-A credit rating after Brexit vote
Standard & Poor’s issues downgrade and pound hits 31-year low despite chancellor’s attempts to soothe markets

Jill Treanor and Katie Allen

27, Jun, 2016 @6:24 PM

Article image
Labour overspending did not trigger financial crash, says senior civil servant
Permanent secretary to Treasury, Sir Nicholas Macpherson, contradicts Tory pre-election claims, saying financial crisis was ‘a banking crisis pure and simple’

Patrick Wintour Political editor

03, May, 2015 @3:41 PM

Article image
Hard Brexit, Donald Trump and Deutsche Bank give markets the jitters
Worries mount over article 50 and the Brexit timetable, the health of European banks and the increasingly bitter US election

Simon Goodley

02, Oct, 2016 @5:19 PM

Article image
Market turmoil fears likely to force Mark Carney to abandon ECB meeting
Bank of England governor may cancel Portugal visit as City expects further stock market battering on Monday over Brexit

Jill Treanor and Phillip Inman

26, Jun, 2016 @3:45 PM

Article image
JP Morgan sets aside $8.3bn to cover Covid-19 losses
Wall Street bank earmarks sum to cover credit cards and oil and gas sector losses

Kalyeena Makortoff

14, Apr, 2020 @3:44 PM

Article image
Global markets rattled over Greece debts as Osborne talks tough on EU in Brussels
British chancellor’s warning about UK referendum on EU membership earns mixed reaction while fears of Greek bankruptcy mount

Ian Traynor in Brussels and Katie Allen

12, May, 2015 @6:03 PM