Brexit could lead to recession, says Bank of England

Central bank issues unprecedented warning over EU vote, claiming exit could depress pound and raise unemployment

The Bank of England has warned for the first time that Britain could slide into recession in the aftermath of a vote to leave the EU in next month’s referendum.

Governor Mark Carney also warned Brexit could knock the pound sharply lower, stoke inflation and raise unemployment. That would leave the Bank with a difficult balancing act as it decides whether to cut, hold or raise interest rates to counter opposing forces, Carney added.

He said there were a range of possible scenarios for the economy in the event of Brexit and these “could possibly include a technical recession” – defined as two consecutive quarters of shrinking GDP.

“A vote to leave the EU could have material economic effects – on the exchange rate, on demand and on the economy’s supply potential – that could affect the appropriate setting of monetary policy,” Carney told a news conference.

He was speaking as the Bank released its latest forecasts for the economy showing a softer outlook for growth and as it announced a decision to hold interest rates at their record low of 0.5%. With the 23 June referendum clouding the economic outlook, all nine of the Bank’s interest rate setting committee agreed borrowing costs should be left on hold.

Against the backdrop of tight opinion polls, the Bank described the referendum on EU membership as “the most immediate and significant risk” for the UK’s economic outlook.

Minutes from the committee’s meeting showed it discussed the implications of both a vote to remain in the EU – seen as the more likely outcome based on current polls – and a vote to leave. It was the Bank’s most detailed assessment yet of potential Brexit effects.

The Bank warned a vote to leave the EU could:

  • Push the pound lower, “perhaps sharply”.
  • Prompt households and businesses to delay spending.
  • Increase unemployment.
  • Hit economic growth.
  • Stoke inflation.

Howard Archer, an economist at IHS Global Insight, said: “The implication is that UK recession would be a very real risk.”

Carney also warned of the risk of a spillover to international markets from the uncertainty around the vote, saying almost everyone he met wanted to talk about Brexit.

“This issue is the No 1 issue that is raised with me and my colleagues every time we meet another central banker, finance minister, the head of a major corporation, and most small business owners.”

The governor’s remarks brought renewed criticism from campaigners for the UK to leave the EU. The former chancellor Lord Lamont accused Carney of carelessness, and said “a prudent governor would simply have said that ‘we are prepared for all eventualities’.”

“The governor should be careful that he doesn’t cause a crisis. If his unwise words become self-fulfilling, the responsibility will be the governor’s and the governor’s alone,” said Lamont.

“There are huge opportunities for the UK outside the EU. We are a strong economy and can stand on our own two feet like all other modern, independent countries.”

But Carney defended his intervention as legitimate and cited the Bank’s responsibility to explain any “major risk” to its forecasts.

The Bank noted the pound had already depreciated 9% since a November peak and that half of that was down to the “risks associated with a vote to leave the European Union”.

Carney further expounded the risks of a leave vote in a letter to George Osborne, one of the leading figures in the campaign to remain in the EU. The letter was the latest in a series, regularly sent to explain why inflation was still far below the Bank’s government-set target of 2%, but this time it contained a lengthy section about the referendum.

The chancellor seized on Carney’s remarks as showing “Britain would be poorer” in the event of Brexit.

On the Bank’s predicted trade-off, Osborne said any outcome would “impose costs on families”, adding: “This is the kind of lose-lose situation that a vote to leave the EU creates.”

Leaving EU would stoke inflation & hit growth, leaving MPC with no-win choice on interest rates. UK would be poorer https://t.co/pfg1rBArlw

— George Osborne (@George_Osborne) May 12, 2016

However, Carney and his colleagues on the monetary policy committee were careful to note that there were factors weighing on the UK economy beyond next month’s referendum. Those included the state of households’ finances against the backdrop of further government cuts, the outlook for the UK’s relatively weak productivity performance, and the prospects for the global economy.

The Bank also warned against expecting a rapid rebound in economic activity in the event of a vote to stay in the EU given some business projects that had been deferred before the vote could take time to restart.

The inflation report’s forecasts were made on the basis the UK remains in the EU, keeping to the usual practice used before general elections of assuming the status quo prevails.

The Bank’s view of the global economy had changed little since the last report in February. But it cut the outlook for the domestic economy to GDP growth of 2% this year, down from 2.2% pencilled in back in February.

David Cameron also capitalised on the Bank’s Brexit warnings. He tweeted:

The Bank of England is right to warn leaving the EU could cause lower growth and unemployment to rise - that would hurt working people.

— David Cameron (@David_Cameron) May 12, 2016

There was more support for the remain campaign from the White House, where the chairman of the council of economic advisers said a vote to leave the EU would hurt Britain and Europe as well as the global economy.

Jason Furman told Germany’s Handelsblatt newspaper: “You can certainly argue about whether the damage a Brexit would cause would be small, medium or big but it would definitely cause damage, especially for the Brits but also for the Europeans and the global economy.”

He added: “We don’t need more uncertainty at the moment.”

Contributor

Katie Allen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Brexit economy: looming rate rise clouds outlook as inflation dips
‘The beast from the east’ blew the UK economy off course, further complicating an already complex picture

Richard Partington

26, Apr, 2018 @12:21 PM

Article image
Bank of England warns of one in three chance of Brexit recession
MPC votes 9-0 to keep interest rates at 0.75% as uncertainty drags down the UK economy

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

01, Aug, 2019 @11:14 AM

Article image
Bank of England warns households to expect sharp rise in inflation next year
Monetary policy committee predicts inflation will rise from 1.3% this year to 2.7% in 2018 and drops plans for further interest rate cut

Katie Allen

03, Nov, 2016 @6:15 PM

Article image
The Brexit economy: the storm clouds are gathering
Guardian analysis of key economic figures paints a picture of deepening gloom, with rising inflation denting consumer spending and investment

Richard Partington

24, Oct, 2017 @11:13 AM

Article image
Bank of England's stimulus package has bought the chancellor some time
There is only so much that monetary policy can do – it’s time to cut VAT and borrow for long-term capital projects and boost infrastructure

Larry Elliott

07, Aug, 2016 @10:03 AM

Article image
No UK interest rate rise but plenty of no-deal Brexit warnings
The Bank of England warning aims to focus politicians on getting a Brexit deal done. Project Fear Mk II might just work

Larry Elliott

01, Nov, 2018 @12:31 PM

Article image
Inflation is only going one way. Let's hope interest rates don't follow | Larry Elliott
The question is not whether inflation will continue rising in 2017 but how high it will go. At least 3%, maybe even higher …

Larry Elliott

11, Apr, 2017 @11:01 AM

Article image
Bank of England interest rate decision: what MPC members have said
As the Bank prepares for its latest move, here’s what monetary policy committee members have said since their last vote

Angela Monaghan

03, Nov, 2016 @8:22 AM

Article image
Bank of England stages Brexit dress rehearsal
In two months’ time the MPC may have to respond to a vote to leave the EU. First off, they would cut interest rates

Larry Elliott

14, Apr, 2016 @1:54 PM

Article image
Bank of England edges closer to first interest rate rise in nine years
Two monetary policy committee members tell MPs increase is needed soon but governor still favours wait until end of year

Phillip Inman Economics correspondent

16, Sep, 2015 @6:47 PM