Energy suppliers' profits 'far too high for what they do'

Head of energy market inquiry says 1.25% margin for British Gas and others would be right as ‘all they do is metering and billing’

Energy suppliers’ profits are as much as five times higher than they should be, the head of an inquiry into the sector has said.

Roger Witcomb, who led the Competition and Markets Authority’s two-year investigation into the UK’s energy industry, has suggested that suppliers’ profits are far too high given their limited role in metering and billing customers.

He told the Sunday Telegraph that it was appropriate for suppliers to make only £12.50 on a £1,000 gas bill – equivalent to a profit margin of 1.25% compared with the 7% enjoyed by British Gas’s household supply business last year.

“All they are actually doing – and I shall get into trouble for this – is metering and billing. They are not making the stuff,” Witcomb said.

British Gas and other major energy suppliers argue that a 5% margin is appropriate but Witcomb said there was room for a further drop in profits if the CMA’s recommendations to improve the market were successful.

Witcomb’s analysis was not included in a report published last month by the CMA in which it argued that 30 new measures, including a database to enable rival suppliers to contact customers, would reduce bills by helping to open up the market to greater competition.

The report argued that energy suppliers were able to exploit customers who did not seek out the best deals to charge prices “materially above” the level necessary.

But the watchdog decided not to impose a limit on the prices suppliers could charge, except a temporary cap on pre-payment meter charges.

Critics said more radical measures should have been considered with even Martin Cave, a CMA panel member, arguing that a wider price cap should have been imposed.


Sarah Butler

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
New energy bill row after British Gas reveals bumper profits
Campaigners describe 31% rise in household energy profits to £574m as ‘absolutely sickening’

Terry Macalister Energy editor

18, Feb, 2016 @8:09 AM

Article image
UK energy watchdog promises tougher stress tests for suppliers
Regulation will need to ‘go much further’ following string of provider collapses, says Ofgem

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

30, Nov, 2021 @2:02 PM

Article image
British Gas worst-value tariffs are not 'evil empire', boss says
Centrica CEO Iain Conn defends much criticised standard variable tariffs as his parent company posts £1.5bn profit

Adam Vaughan

23, Feb, 2017 @1:28 PM

Article image
Centrica chief to step down amid pressure over energy prices
British Gas owner is seeking replacement for chief executive Sam Laidlaw, who will leave company before end of year

Rupert Neate

11, Apr, 2014 @1:56 PM

Article image
Regulators may launch investigation into big six energy companies next week
Political pressure on regulators could trigger a full competition inquiry, which could take 18 months to complete

Terry Macalister, energy editor

21, Mar, 2014 @12:38 PM

Article image
Breakup of big six energy firms not needed, says regulator
Interim report by CMA will deny large firms collude to drive up prices but will recommend new initiatives for switching to cheaper providers

Terry Macalister

05, Jul, 2015 @3:03 PM

Article image
Ofgem puts big six energy suppliers under CMA spotlight
British Gas and other suppliers face probe from Competition and Markets Authority after referral from the energy watchdog

Terry Macalister

26, Jun, 2014 @12:02 PM

Article image
What does energy price cap mean for households and firms?
From whether you should switch suppliers to how it could lead to job cuts

Adam Vaughan

06, Nov, 2018 @3:55 PM

Article image
Energy bills to be cut by around £75 for more than 11m households
Ofgem figure falls short of £100 promised by Theresa May for customers on poor-value tariffs

Adam Vaughan

06, Sep, 2018 @6:39 AM

Article image
Energy companies boost profits despite gas price cuts, warns energy watchdog
Critics brand revelation the final straw for consumers with Ofgem calling on competition watchdog to take widening profit figures into account

Sean Farrell

29, Jan, 2015 @2:27 PM