Hewlett-Packard unveils details of $5bn Autonomy fraud case

US firm claims Mike Lynch inflated revenues by $700m, but Autonomy founder says HP has failed to produce ‘smoking gun’

Hewlett-Packard has unveiled full details of its $5bn (£3.3bn) fraud case against the founder of the UK software company Autonomy, claiming that Mike Lynch inflated the revenues of his business by about $700m over a two-and-a-half-year period.

HP, which bought Autonomy in 2011 for $11bn, has filed a claim against Lynch and his finance director, Sushovan Hussain, in the high court in London, alleging they engaged in improper transactions with software resellers and in questionable accounting practices.

The filing contains new allegations, denied by Lynch, that Autonomy dismissed its US chief financial officer Brent Hogenson after he raised concerns about the company’s transactions to its UK based auditor, Deloitte, and UK regulator the Financial Services Authority (FSA). HP has previously said it is considering taking legal action against Deloitte.

HP claims that Lynch and Hussain breached their fiduciary duties as directors, that Lynch breached his contractual duties as an employee of Autonomy, and that Hussain repeatedly misled the Autonomy audit committee.

The dispute has seen the HP chief executive, Meg Whitman, who joined the company after its disastrous Autonomy deal, lock horns with Britain’s most successful software boss.

Lynch hit back against the claims, saying HP had failed to produce a “smoking gun” to support its accusation of fraud. In a statement on his blog he said: “HP’s claim is finally laid bare for what it is – a desperate search for a scapegoat for its own errors and incompetence. The contents of the claim are a simple rehash of previous leaks and insinuations that add up to one long disagreement over accounting treatments, and have nothing to do with fraud.”

Lynch and Hussain, who also dispute the charges, acknowledged receiving the particulars of the claim on Tuesday, allowing the full details of HP’s forensic trawl through Autonomy’s accounts to become public for the first time.

Between the first quarter of 2009 and the second quarter of 2011, the Cambridge-based company reported revenues totalling more than $2bn. HP claims that a third of that was wrongly reported, misleading Autonomy’s shareholders on the London Stock Exchange and later HP.

“This conduct by Lynch and Hussain was systematic and was sustained for more than two years prior to the acquisition of Autonomy by HP,” the Californian software group said. “Its purpose was to ensure that the Autonomy group’s financial performance … appeared to be that of a rapidly growing pure software company … The reality was that the group was experiencing little or no growth, it was losing market share, and its true financial performance consistently fell far short of market expectations.”

HP’s lawyers have outlined five main sources of allegedly wrongly claimed income:

  • $194m of supposedly hidden hardware sales. HP said it found Autonomy resold hardware such as servers made by other companies, often at a loss, and claims its directors allowed investors to believe this was software revenue.
  • $196m in apparently wrongly reported sales of Autonomy’s core software product, IDOL, to other software companies.
  • $205m in supposedly questionable transactions with software resellers.
  • $80m of claimed incorrectly reported hosting deals, in which Autonomy renegotiated contracts to host other companies’ data on its own servers.
  • $33m in other alleged improper transactions.

After the release of Autonomy’s results for the first half of 2010, US executive Hogenson allegedly blew the whistle. He raised concerns - about reseller deals - with the FSA in an email sent on 26 July of that year. On 28 July 2010, HP claims, he was summarily dismissed by US chief operating officer Joel Scott, “acting at the direction of Lynch”.

Lawyers for Lynch said in a letter to HP’s legal team that Hogenson was actually dismissed by Autonomy’s chairman. His concerns had been investigated by Deloitte and UK accounting body the Financial Reporting Review Panel, they said, but neither organisation had taken issue.

Of particular interest are 37 deals with small IT contractors that bought Autonomy’s software. Deals with these outfits, known in the industry as “value added resellers”, were key to Autonomy’s ability to present itself as a fast-growing software business.

The resellers were presented as acquiring the rights to sell on Autonomy software to end users including UBS bank, General Motors, the Vatican library, accounting firm KPMG and even Hewlett-Packard itself. But HP claims many of these deals were fictional in that no agreement with an end user was ever concluded, and that the resellers were simply warehousing Autonomy’s software.

Other deals were recorded as revenue too early, before the end user had agreed to buy the Autonomy products.

The resellers involved were located in countries including the US, Italy and the UK.

In a point-by-point rebuttal, Lynch and Hussain have dismissed HP’s claims, saying: “Out of 23,000 deals and $2.2bn in revenue that took place at Autonomy during the period, Whitman makes assertions concerning only six specific reseller transactions, which add up to under $40m in revenue, and for which almost all the cash was, in fact, received. Whitman provides scant supporting evidence even for these few assertions.

“She raises questions over fully paid hosted deals, the form of which HP’s own accountants approved, and in a structure HP itself also used. She now admits that hardware sales were correctly recorded as revenue and that HP was fully aware of this when they valued the company at $11bn. Meg Whitman has been playing a delaying game, promising a smoking gun that has never materialised.”


Juliette Garside

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hewlett-Packard wins civil fraud case against Mike Lynch over Autonomy sale
Verdict on same day as deadline to decide whether British businessman can be extradited to US to face proceedings

Rob Davies

28, Jan, 2022 @4:57 PM

Article image
Hewlett-Packard sues Autonomy founder for damages
US firm files claim for $5bn in high court against Mike Lynch, who vows to counter-sue for ‘smear campaign’

Juliette Garside

31, Mar, 2015 @3:37 PM

Article image
Hewlett-Packard launches £6bn takeover bid for Autonomy
UK-based search software company confirms approach from US technology multinational

Juliette Garside

18, Aug, 2011 @7:35 PM

Article image
Autonomy founder Mike Lynch to leave Hewlett-Packard
Entrepreneur is latest executive to leave 'too bureaucratic' HP as tech giant announces 27,000 job cuts and drop in net profits. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur

24, May, 2012 @4:12 PM

Article image
Hewlett-Packard blames Autonomy 'improprieties' for $8.8bn writedown
Former managers at British tech firm deny claims and accuse HP of destroying a 'world leader'

Dominic Rushe in New York, Charles Arthur and Juliette Garside

20, Nov, 2012 @9:59 PM

Article image
Hewlett Packard offloads last Autonomy assets in software deal
British firm Micro Focus will take on remaining software assets from HP’s ill-fated 2011 acquisition

Angela Monaghan

08, Sep, 2016 @4:44 PM

Article image
Hewlett-Packard must clarify Autonomy claims, says ex-SEC adviser
US firm will have to use annual filing this month to explain 'what all the fuss has been about', says Tom Selling

Juliette Garside

04, Dec, 2012 @7:38 PM

Article image
Hewlett-Packard faces $1bn lawsuit from shareholders over Autonomy deal

HP accused of ignoring evidence on 'vastly overvalued' acquisition while Autonomy founder denies financial impropriety

Juliette Garside

07, May, 2013 @10:16 PM

Article image
Hewlett-Packard allegations: Autonomy founder Mike Lynch tries to clear name
As legal arguments from both sides grind on in the US, UK Serious Fraud Office investigation still not concluded

Juliette Garside

14, Aug, 2014 @3:05 PM

Article image
Autonomy made 80% less UK profit than stated, Hewlett-Packard finds
American firm investigated irregularities in accounting at British software company it bought for more than $10bn

Juliette Garside, telecoms correspondent

03, Feb, 2014 @7:45 PM