HMRC and MPs clash over appearance of top official

Parliamentary officials said Edward Troup was due to appear before public accounts committee on Wednesday afternoon but HMRC says he was not

HM Revenue and Customs and an influential select committee have clashed over whether MPs were due to question a senior tax official about the authority’s inquiry into the HSBC tax scandal.

Parliamentary officials told the Guardian on Wednesday morning that Edward Troup, the second permanent secretary, was expected to appear before the parliamentary accounts committee on Wednesday afternoon but he pulled out at short notice.

However, Lin Homer, HMRC’s chief executive, has issued a statement saying he was never due to appear before the committee and that she had made this clear to the committee last Friday.

The exchange is evidence of the tensions growing between MPs and HMRC. Margaret Hodge, the committee’s chair, has made it clear that HMRC needs to explain why more action was not taken against a list of 6,000 former clients of HSBC’s Swiss arm, whose details were leaked to HMRC in 2010.

Sources said that Troup was expected to appear with Homer and Jim Harra, the director general of business tax.

Troup told the public accounts committee in 2013 that he knew of “the HSBC Swiss disc”, which has since been leaked to the Guardian and an international consortium of journalists.

He told the same committee of MPs in 2012 that while only one criminal case had so far been brought relating to the disclosures, another dozen were “in train”.

A Whitehall source said Troup’s evidence was crucial to the committee. “Troup was there at the time and obviously had some knowledge of the documents. He knew that a list of British people who had used HSBC’s Swiss arm existed and he knew there were thousands of names on the list.

“What is not known is exactly what HMRC did with it, when and why they did not pursue it with the same vigour as tax authorities in other countries.”

But in a rare press statement, Homer said there have been several discussions with the committee about who should attend on Wednesday and that she had made it clear on Friday that Troup had a long-standing meeting in Manchester.

“Edward Troup was never due to appear at today’s public accounts committee hearing.

“I had considered asking several of my director generals, to ensure the senior officials responsible for the issues being discussed were present. I did not ask Edward Troup, since the topics for discussion were my responsibility as accounting officer,” she said.

Homer added that she had attempted to speak to Hodge on Tuesday night and had spoken to her on Wednesday morning instead.

“I again made it clear in that phone call that Mr Troup was not the relevant official to attend and was not available to attend,” she said.

Committee officials are still in negotiations with HMRC about when Troup may appear.

Senior figures from HSBC and HMRC could be required to attend a further committee meeting on 4 March specifically to discuss the allegations surrounding the Swiss disc, the Guardian understands.

Others who could face being called before the committee include Dave Hartnett, who was a senior figure in HMRC in February 2010.

Stephen Green, the former chairman of HSBC who subsequently became a City minister, could also be asked to attend that meeting.

It is understood the committee is prepared to issue orders for individuals to attend if necessary. It is also within the committee’s powers to force witnesses to give evidence under oath.

Contributor

Rajeev Syal

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
HMRC promoted lenient settlement route to HSBC Suisse clients, MPs told
Lin Homer says HMRC actively persuaded many individuals in HSBC files to take advantage of agreement that in many cases carries 10% penalty

James Ball

11, Feb, 2015 @8:01 PM

Article image
HSBC files: HMRC cleared bank boss for peerage despite misconduct data
The Guardian has established that the UK tax authority failed to tell Downing Street of Swiss arm’s misconduct during vetting of Stephen Green

David Leigh, James Ball, Juliette Garside and David Pegg

10, Feb, 2015 @2:36 PM

Article image
HSBC files: HMRC had data on misconduct before bank boss made trade minister
Leaked Swiss data containing 6,000 British names handed to HMRC in May 2010, months before Stephen Green was made Tory trade minister


David Leigh, James Ball, Juliette Garside and David Pegg

09, Feb, 2015 @8:54 PM

Article image
George Osborne under pressure from Vince Cable over HSBC scandal
Business secretary demands to know whether there has been proper vigilance and why there have been so few prosecutions for tax evasion

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

15, Feb, 2015 @8:43 PM

Article image
Labour quizzes chancellor over knowledge of HSBC's Swiss subsidiary conduct
Ed Balls asks George Osborne whether selective prosecutions by HMRC were approved by the Treasury

Patrick Wintour, political editor

17, Feb, 2015 @4:07 PM

Article image
George Osborne keeps clear of HSBC tax blame-game in the Commons
The chancellor leaves it to junior minister David Gauke to explain that it was all the fault of Labour, not the bank’s former chairman Stephen Green

John Crace

09, Feb, 2015 @6:32 PM

Article image
MPs knew of HSBC Swiss tax evasion claims in 2011
Transcripts show tax chief told committee that Revenue had disc with names of potential tax dodgers, contrary to ministerial denials of knowledge

Patrick Wintour

10, Feb, 2015 @5:50 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on tax dodging: a creative industry that demands an equally creative response | Editorial
Editorial: The US, the French, the Belgians and the Spanish are all pursuing HSBC. Where’s Britain?

Editorial

13, Feb, 2015 @6:56 PM

Article image
HSBC: Time to take the kid gloves off in handling tax evaders and avoiders | Letters
Letters: In addition to criminal prosecutions, people caught fiddling more than the living wage should have their tax returns published in full, with only their most personal details redacted

10, Feb, 2015 @7:48 PM

Article image
UK government should have known about HSBC tax issues, says Falciani
Bank’s former computer specialist, who stole information on 30,000 accounts, says data was in public domain in 2010

Mark Tran

12, Feb, 2015 @1:39 PM