PwC chief misled us over Luxembourg tax avoidance schemes, claim MPs

MPs conclude tax arrangements promoted by PricewaterhouseCoopers bear all the characteristics of a mass-marketed tax avoidance scheme

The top tax partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers, Kevin Nicholson, misled parliament over complex Luxembourg financing structures the accountancy firm helped to set up for scores of multinationals to avoid tax, according to MPs.

In a report published on Friday, the public accounts committee dismisses Nicholson’s repeated claims that PwC was not in the business of selling tax avoidance. MPs pointed to evidence unearthed in investigations published in November in the Guardian and more than 20 news outlets around the world, under the auspices of the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ).

Committee chair Margaret Hodge said: “Contrary to its denials, the tax arrangements PwC promotes, based on artificially diverting profits to Luxembourg through intra-company loans, bear all the characteristics of a mass-marketed tax avoidance scheme.”

Nicholson had been recalled to give further evidence last December after MPs felt his 2013 evidence had been put in question by the Guardian’s investigations. Fearghas Carruthers, the head of tax at drug firm Shire, a PwC client which also featured in the investigation, gave evidence too.

Two years ago Nicholson told MPs: “We are not in the business of selling schemes. We do not mass-market tax products, we do not produce tax products, we do not promote tax products.”

The MPs’ report comes as political leaders in the European parliament promised their own special committee to examine tax rulings granted not just by Luxembourg, but by all member states.

The special committee’s work will last a year and it has powers to examine a wide range of paperwork at the European level.

The move disappointed many MEPs, however, as more than a quarter had petitioned for leaders to endorse a full committee of inquiry, with powers to review papers from member states as well as internal Brussels documents.

The Guardian’s investigation into PwC’s activities in Luxembourg was made possible by the leak of thousands of pages of confidential tax rulings secured by the accountancy firm, which found their way to the ICIJ.

In a statement responding to MPs’ criticisms of Nicholson, PwC once again said: “We stand by the evidence we gave the committee and disagree with its conclusions about the work we do.”

The statement added: “We recognise we need to do more to explain the positive role we play in the tax system and in helping businesses to operate successfully.”

But PwC Luxembourg remains furious at what it calls the “theft” of its documents. Criminal charges have been brought against two former PwC staff members after it complained to prosecutors.

Of Shire’s Luxembourg structure, the MPs’ report says: “Shire has arranged its affairs so that interest payments on intra-company loans reduce significantly its overall tax liabilities … The ‘substance’ of Shire’s business in Luxembourg, used to justify these arrangements, consists of two people … One of Shire’s Luxembourg based staff holds 41 directorships of other companies.”

The report recommends that British tax authorities should press for tougher international rules that would require multinationals to show real substance in companies where their profits arise.


Simon Bowers

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
MPs summon PwC tax chief to attend Luxembourg tax deal hearing
Public accounts committee will demand intricate details from Kevin Nicholson about tax avoiding schemes in Grand Duchy

Simon Bowers and Ian Traynor in Brussels

27, Nov, 2014 @7:46 PM

Article image
Letters: The 'big four', transparency and tax reform
Letters: The public accounts committee's report highlighting the 'big four' accountancy firms' conflict of interest in advising the government on tax reform while advising clients on tax avoidance is welcome but only scratches the surface of a much bigger problem

28, Apr, 2013 @8:00 PM

Article image
Ernst & Young to pay US regulators $123m over tax avoidance schemes
E&Y's deal with a US district attorney ensures the firm will not face prosecution and brings a long-drawn tax scandal to an end

Simon Bowers

03, Mar, 2013 @8:05 PM

Article image
Proposal to fine tax avoidance enablers lacks teeth, campaigners say
Critics say Treasury plans only target illegal tax avoidance and that HMRC lacks the resources to enforce penalties

Juliette Garside

17, Aug, 2016 @6:55 PM

Article image
Appeal court battle brews over Greene King tax avoidance scheme
Brewer and pub group to take its long-running fight over the legality of the controversial Project Sussex tax plan to a higher court

Simon Bowers

10, Aug, 2014 @3:25 PM

Article image
Letters: Tax avoidance distorts the market
Letters: Good old Amazon, making millions from the UK taxpayer and getting more back from the government than they pay in tax

17, May, 2013 @7:59 PM

Article image
Luxembourg tax files: how tiny state rubber-stamped tax avoidance on an industrial scale
Leaked documents show that one of the EU’s smallest states helped multinationals save millions in tax, to the detriment of its neighbours and allies

Simon Bowers

05, Nov, 2014 @9:01 PM

Article image
'Big four' accountants 'use knowledge of Treasury to help rich avoid tax'

Experts offering advice on legislation they helped to create is 'ridiculous conflict of interest', says select committee chair Margaret Hodge

Rajeev Syal, Simon Bowers and Patrick Wintour

26, Apr, 2013 @8:10 AM

Article image
Firms giving advice on aggressive tax avoidance could face large fines
Government plans in consultation document suggest that tax advisers whose schemes are defeated in courts could have to repay lost money to taxpayer

Rajeev Syal and Juliette Garside

16, Aug, 2016 @11:01 PM

Article image
Jean-Claude Juncker faces censure vote over Luxembourg tax schemes
Eureopean Union chief’s actions as prime minister of Luxembourg attacked over alleged role in creation of tax haven

Ian Traynor in Brussels

18, Nov, 2014 @6:39 PM