Why the TS Eliot prize shortlist hails a return to the status quo

This year’s lineup may be deserving, but with just one collection by a BAME poet in an exceptionally strong year for poets of colour, it also seems naive

Over the past few years, challenges to British poetry’s lack of diversity have made it impossible to return to the status quo – or so we thought. This year’s TS Eliot prize shortlist, announced on Thursday, features just one collection (out of 10, including Michael Symmons Roberts and Leontia Flynn) by a poet of colour, the much-acclaimed Night Sky with Exit Wounds by Ocean Vuong. For those who have championed crucial interventions in poetry publishing, reviewing and prizes, this nearly all-white shortlist cannot help but seem inexplicably naive and regressive.

This year was an exceptionally strong year for British poets of colour, and you would have reasonably expected to see Kayo Chingonyi, Richard Georges, André Naffis-Sahely, Nick Makoha, Nuar Alsadir, or Elizabeth-Jane Burnett here, among several others.

That is not to say that the books featured on the list are in any way undeserving. As one of five judges for the Forward prize for poetry this year, I know firsthand how hard it can be to reach a balanced consensus in spite of one’s own bloody-mindedness about what constitutes lasting literary value. No doubt this shortlist, whittled down by poets Helen Mort, James Lasdun and Bill Herbert from 154 books, was a struggle, and each judge is entitled to their taste. I believe poetry must rise to the collective challenge of our times, not merely be a curio of intimate experience. But in the absence of rigorous critical debate over what poetry must do in our era, we have come to expect rather more from prize judges than expressions of taste. Would, for instance, an ethnically diverse panel have returned a different list? When the markers of success do not reflect British poetry today – the unique challenges BAME voices bring to this cultural moment, to pressing questions of identity, our being in the world – all of us must speak up.

The 2017 TS Eliot prize shortlist

The Tragic Death of Eleanor Marx by Tara Bergin (Carcanet)

In these Days of Prohibition by Caroline Bird (Carcanet)

The Noise of a Fly by Douglas Dunn (Faber & Faber)

The Radio by Leontia Flynn (Cape Poetry)

So Glad I’m Me by Roddy Lumsden (Bloodaxe)

Mancunia by Michael Symmons Roberts (Cape Poetry)

Diary of the Last Man by Robert Minhinnick (Carcanet)

The Abandoned Settlements by James Sheard (Cape Poetry)

All My Mad Mothers by Jacqueline Saphra (Nine Arches Press)

Night Sky with Exit Wounds by Ocean Vuong (Cape Poetry)

Contributor

Sandeep Parmar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why Vahni Capildeo deserved to win the Forward prize
Forward prize founder, William Sieghart, applauds a fresh new voice in poetry

William Sieghart

22, Sep, 2016 @4:00 PM

Article image
The Noise of a Fly by Douglas Dunn review – shortlisted for the TS Eliot prize
Larkin’s influence is still strong in this collection, which illuminates the natural world and the coming of old age

Aingeal Clare

11, Jan, 2018 @9:59 AM

Article image
TS Eliot prize-winner Roger Robinson: ‘I want these poems to help people to practise empathy’
From a lament for the victims of Grenfell Tower to snapshots of Windrush arrivals … activist, musician and poet Roger Robinson discusses the inspiration behind his prize‑winning collection

Claire Armitstead

16, Jan, 2020 @11:22 AM

Article image
Big cheers for small publishers
The independent publisher Oneworld has won two Man Bookers in a row … and there are small presses in the running for the Baillie Gifford and TS Eliot prizes

Alison Flood

28, Oct, 2016 @8:30 AM

Article image
TS Eliot prize goes to Ocean Vuong's 'compellingly assured' debut collection
Night Sky With Exit Wounds, the debut collection by a poet who is the first literate person in his family, hailed as ‘the definitive arrival of a significant voice’

Sian Cain

15, Jan, 2018 @7:30 PM

Article image
'A star is born': TS Eliot prize goes to Hannah Sullivan's debut
Poet’s ‘absolutely exhilarating’ first collection Three Poems takes £25,000 prize

Sian Cain

14, Jan, 2019 @7:30 PM

Article image
Surprised by the Booker shortlist? Don't judge the books, study the judges
As a former judge, I sometimes joke that the only year I correctly picked the Man Booker winner was when I was on the panel – it’s too unpredictable

Stuart Kelly

14, Sep, 2017 @2:32 PM

Article image
The 2017 Stephen Spender prize – a callout for poetry translators
The Stephen Spender prize for poetry in translation opens for submissions on 27 February. Award judge Margaret Jull Costa reflects on today’s need for translators

Margaret Jull Costa

18, Feb, 2017 @2:00 PM

Article image
Why Amy Liptrot deserved to win the Wainwright prize – a judge’s view
Liptrot’s The Outrun, set in London and Orkney’s wild landscapes, reflects our vital need to connect with and respect nature, writes chair of judges, Fiona Reynolds

Fiona Reynolds

05, Aug, 2016 @1:15 PM

Article image
TS Eliot poetry prize shortlist stretches to Jamaica and beyond
Claudia Rankine joins past prize winners and debut authors on a shortlist that encompasses questions of racial identity, depression, love affairs and librarians

Alison Flood

22, Oct, 2015 @12:15 PM