Stories from the Tenants Downstairs by Sidik Fofana review – bold, funny and gloriously flawed voices of New York

Fofana’s bravura debut collection of short stories brings the lives of marginalised city folk to life

The apartment building provides an arresting riposte to the perception that urban living grows ever more atomised, not least in New York City. It also makes an irresistible backdrop for fiction writers and Sidik Fofana’s bravura debut, Stories from the Tenants Downstairs, shows just why that might be.

Comprising eight interconnected tales, it’s set in Banneker Terrace, a low-income, high-rise in Harlem. Fofana draws his narrators from among the residents of its 300-plus homes, and while all may be black, their intensely vernacular voices testify to the rich multiplicity of their roots and backstories, their dreams and disappointments.

There’s Quanneisha in 21J, a sometime gymnast who came this close to making the national squad and whose talent got her a private school education, a college scholarship (until she dropped out) and a way of talking that makes her neighbours look at her oddly now that she’s back in the neighbourhood.

In 6B, meanwhile, Swan is excited to reconnect with his friend, Boons, freshly released from jail, but his outlook has been changed by President Obama’s election and this creates the subtlest of tensions as Boons sets about scamming a free meal from the local Chinese takeaway.

Other residents include aspiring hairdresser Dary, who cannot shake off his family’s views on his sexuality and whose pop star obsession will see him go viral in all the wrong ways, and teenager Kandese, who found her obese father’s dead body and is now making a killing selling candy.

Stoking the tension throughout is Harlem’s rapid gentrification. Banneker itself has recently been sold to a property company intent on turning a profit and it’s only a matter of time before rent rises are followed by eviction notices. The threat couldn’t be more real for fiercely independent Mimi, who’s raising Swan’s son alone. “Days left: 10… money you got: $… money you need: $350”, begins The Rent Manual, the book’s opening story.

Mimi’s voice, like those of her neighbours, reels the reader in with its rhythmic, idiomatic immediacy. There’s huge variety in their diction, from the assertive bustle of Verona, a high school assistant who clashes with a do-gooding teacher fresh from Harvard in Ms Dallas, to elderly Mr Murray, who lives to play chess with passersby and whose colourful metaphors bring a sense of perspective to the collection’s finale.

Fofana, himself a schoolteacher, displays great dramatic range here, too. There are stories that end shockingly, such as the epistolary Lite Feet, whose 12-year-old narrator, Najee, once danced through subway carriages for tips and now conveys, through his misspelled outpourings, a crushingly adult burden of regret. Then there are moments when there is feeling and story enough to fill a novel, yet it is all compressed into the merest of nods as lift doors close.

What unites so many of these characters – and they can seem so real that word jars – is that they feel unseen, unheard. As Najee writes at the start of his letter: “Does anybody wanna read this? i dout it. imma tear this paper up when i’m threw.” The stories that do get told, it’s observed on more than one occasion, aren’t truly representative. To quote Mimi: “Folks with child-support payments, uncles in jail, aunties on crack, cousins in the Bloods, sisters hoein. That’s what everybody wanna concentrate on.”

Fofana’s triumph is in allowing these people to burst from the page as individuals who may perhaps be fated, but who are also gloriously flawed, funny and bold, rather than being mere victims of their social challenges.

• Stories from the Tenants Downstairs by Sidik Fofana is published by John Murray (£16.99). To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at Delivery charges may apply


Hephzibah Anderson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Show Them a Good Time by Nicole Flattery review – darkly funny
The Irish writer’s debut story collection is a highly addictive mix of deadpan drollery and candour

Anthony Cummins

09, Apr, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
You Have a Friend in 10A by Maggie Shipstead review – flawed lives fluently explored
The novelist shows her expertise in the briefer format in tales of sexual power, self-delusion and flawed personality

Stephanie Merritt

08, May, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
We Were Strangers: Stories Inspired By Unknown Pleasures – review
Nearly 40 years since the death of singer Ian Curtis, Joy Division still inspire, as proven by a potent collection of short stories

Carol Morley

27, Aug, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Total by Rebecca Miller review – emotionally complex stories
Wit and wisdom are constant delights in the film-maker and writer’s second short story collection, as she expertly picks apart the confusions of intimacy

Hephzibah Anderson

21, Aug, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
The Burning Ground by Adam O’Riordan review – scorching stories
The poet’s first story collection draws emotional heat from the Californian landscape

Anita Sethi

29, Jan, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Uncommon Type: Some Stories review – Hanks, but no thanks
With one exception, Tom Hanks’s stories could be the work of Forrest Gump himself

Alex Preston

15, Oct, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Evening in Paradise: More Stories by Lucia Berlin – review
A second posthumous selection of stories by the author of A Manual for Cleaning Women shines with compassion and dark wit

Johanna Thomas-Corr

20, Nov, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
The High Places review – beautifully off-kilter short stories
Former Guardian first book award nominee Fiona McFarlane springs some surprises in her impressive first collection

Lucy Scholes

22, May, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
Agatha Christie by Lucy Worsley; Marple: Twelve New Stories – review
With a keen historian’s eye, Lucy Worsley pieces together the queen of crime’s life, work and misunderstood episode of mental illness, while Val McDermid, Natalie Haynes and others put a fresh spin on Miss Marple

Stephanie Merritt

18, Sep, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
What Is Yours Is Not Yours review – spellbinding stories
Helen Oyeyemi’s new collection is rich with magical imagination and lush prose

Lucy Scholes

08, May, 2016 @7:00 AM