Exiles: Three Island Journeys by William Atkins review – banishment and beyond

The stories of three notable dissidents are the springboard for a fascinating study of exile and its effects

When Louise Michel – teacher, anarchist, and revolutionary-in-exile – arrived in London after seven years banishment in the South Pacific, she brought five cats with her. Escorted from the ship under the coats of sympathisers, the oceanian felines, exhausted from their 10,000-mile journey, recovered quickly when presented with “an enormous bowl of milk” under the doting eye of their mistress. Back in Paris a few years later – cats in tow – Michel tried to explain her solicitude for the fragile animals. Taken from New Caledonia, her place of exile, to France, the land of her birth, the cats represented to Michel something elusive, precious, instinctual; hard to find, easy to lose. They reminded her, she said, of home.

And although William Atkins’s Exiles is framed by the pain and self-discovery of exile, it’s home that draws his subjects out; raises them up; and pulls them back, in the end, to where they began. Exile isn’t, as Atkins shrewdly comments on Ovid’s poems on the theme, a place so much as a process, a movement. All three of Atkins’s subjects – Michel; Russian anthropologist Lev Shternberg, and deposed African king Dinuzulu – discover that it’s a movement that can last a whole life. As another of the book’s luminaries, Victor Hugo, notes: once an exile, always an exile. You can go back to the place you started from. But you can never go home.

In a restless, rootless world, the idea of exile has broad purchase. Atkins taps into this, judiciously mixing history with memoir: at the time he’s researching the book, travelling from Siberia to the South Atlantic, his father, back home, is dying. But Atkins’s eye for the personal – Zulu chieftains with collapsing hairstyles, assassins with anxiety, a migrant family’s private grief – is matched by his acute awareness that this both is and isn’t all there is. The point at which personal and political become mutually inescapable: that, Atkins says, is where exile is.

Each of his subjects felt that tension keenly; each suffered a painful collision between their desires and the insensate demands of state and law: the catch and pull of history on the make. Michel saw the streets of Paris run red with blood when the Commune was suppressed in the semaine sanglante, the “bloody week”. Dinuzulu witnessed the end of his kingdom: Zululand was politically and spiritually dismembered by the British empire. Shternberg, a socialist Jew in tsarist Russia, endured brutal political repression alongside the lifelong threat of antisemitic violence.

It got worse. Michel was sent to New Caledonia, a French colony ill-at-ease with itself and with a brutally oppressed native population. Dinuzulu was stranded on Saint Helena – the same bleak South Atlantic islet Napoleon died on. Shternberg was immured on the “last refuge of the unshot”, Sakhalin island, in Siberia’s frozen east. All three could well have died. That was expected. Exile the noun is predicate on exile the verb. It’s always something done; something done to you. The powers that banished Michel, Shternberg and Dinuzulu had several names – Britain, France, Russia – of which only one really matters: empire.

Empire took Michel, Dinuzulu and Shternberg from their homes. Atkins identifies a subtler, more radical dislocation at work, too: empire took home from them. A people uprooted are a people undone; disquieted, doubtful, easy to control. The movement of exile – the movement of empire – carries us away from ourselves. Exile’s strongest moments are worked out in the shadow of this insight: a present-day fete on Saint Helena, lit by the half-life glow of the sun that never set; the crude commercialism and dying machines of post-Soviet Sakhalin; New Caledonia, still a colony, still ill-at-ease. The exiles outlasted their exile. But empire outlasted both.

Atkins’s subjects defied expectations; defied, in a sense, exile itself. Shternberg invents modern anthropology; Dinuzulu reinvents kingship. Michel goes further, dreaming of a time when exile, a tool of oppression, could become the sign and seedbed of liberation. She imagined building a house of exiles, a universal asylum for the dispossessed and the refugee. It would be built in London, where, she said, “my banished friends are always welcome”. We’ve come a long way; we’re still a long way from home.

Exiles: Three Island Journeys by William Atkins is published by Faber (£20). To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply


Madoc Cairns

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Does Terrorism Work? by Richard English – review
There are no easy answers in this study of terror groups from IRA to al-Qaida but the search to find some is valid and interesting

Ian Birrell

24, Jul, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
JFK: Volume One review – a superhero made human
The first instalment of Fredrik Logevall’s definitive biography reveals a man in sharp contrast to the modern Lancelot of legend

Peter Conrad

30, Aug, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Bland Fanatics by Pankaj Mishra review – both obscures and illuminates
Pankaj Mishra’s insights are often valuable, but these essays on the arrogance of the west omit some key arguments

Kenan Malik

04, Aug, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Red Memory review – the Cultural Revolution up close
In gathering histories from one of the country’s darkest, most divisive periods, the former Guardian China correspondent has created a gripping and important document

Rana Mitter

30, Jan, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Border by Diarmaid Ferriter review – the bloody road to the backstop
A timely history shows how confusion and dispute plagued the Irish border long before Brexit

Andrew Anthony

18, Feb, 2019 @9:00 AM

Article image
Last Best Hope by George Packer review – shrewd analysis of America’s ruptures
George Packer finds the US caught in a ‘cold civil war’ between incompatible versions of the country after its ‘near-death experience’ with Donald Trump

Peter Conrad

20, Jun, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Black Wave by Kim Ghattas review – insightful history of Middle Eastern conflict
An essential account of the ideologies that have shaped the region

Ian Black

19, Jan, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Snake Dance: Journeys Beneath a Nuclear Sky by Patrick Marnham – review

Patrick Marnham's meandering exploration of the dawn of the atomic age fascinates and frustrates Lara Feigel

Lara Feigel

16, Nov, 2013 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Age of Anger by Pankaj Mishra – review
A trenchant study of how anger and violence have influenced modern societies will have you fearing the worst

Nick Fraser

23, Jan, 2017 @7:30 AM

Article image
Why Women Have Better Sex Under Socialism – review
Kristen R Ghodsee’s study of the links between female sexual pleasure and politics is a joyous read

Suzanne Moore

03, Dec, 2018 @6:59 AM