The Playbook by Jennifer Jacquet review – how big business takes on science and wins

A ‘guide’ for companies looking to counter unwelcome research exposes the corporate world’s dark arts

“Playbook” is a term that feels overused at the moment – mostly because of Vladimir Putin’s military adventures. We now know all too well that his playbook, deployed in Chechnya, then Syria, and now Ukraine, involves heavy bombardment of civilian areas with the aim of demoralising and grinding down a population towards eventual defeat. The end goal is the demonstration of Putin’s ruthlessness – one of his key tools for retaining power. Jennifer Jacquet’s The Playbook is about something else entirely – the methods corporations use to “deny science, sell lies, and make a killing”. The specifics couldn’t be more different. And yet, in some fundamental and peculiar ways, the strategies are similar.

Jacquet chooses a slightly unusual means of getting her ideas across, writing in the style of a helpful guide for corporations faced with scientific evidence that could “pose a risk to business operations”. Readers might assume the odd business may have used some of these dubious methods to push back against unwelcome research every so often, but they probably wouldn’t think it was a systemic issue. It doesn’t take long, however, to realise that Jacquet has a point – that the use of these tactics really does amount to a playbook to which almost every sector has had recourse at some point. The sheer weight of evidence that she piles up, chapter by chapter, is unarguable.

Corporations need to build up an arsenal of individuals, institutions and communications networks to put their case, she explains. “Each actor will use a unique approach and leave a different trail of evidence that will make it difficult to reconstruct the larger whole,” she suggests. Examples include the $450m provided by cigarette manufacturers to the Council for Tobacco Research, which led to more than 7,000 sympathetic scientific papers; or a network of professors and thinktanks created by the agro-chemical industry to defend the herbicide glyphosate.

Of course, companies can make use of public relations firms – the obvious move. But why not also set up a trade association? They “can do work on behalf of an entire industry so that no single brand appears to be responsible”, Jacquet writes, pointing out that their names can even suggest a more formal organisation: the National Fisheries Institute in the US, for example, sounds to some like a government body. (Later in the book she also lists some of the trade associations that have changed their names: CropLife America, which represents manufacturers of pesticides, was previously the American Crop Protection Association and before that the National Agricultural Chemicals Association.)

Why not nurture a consumer advocacy group? Jacquet asserts that in the 1990s Monsanto hired PR firm Edelman to create a “grassroots group” to oppose the labelling of GM foods. Other potential allies include law firms, community foundations, private investigators and, best of all, academic experts. This last group is so gold-plated they get a whole chapter to themselves, which draws the deflating conclusion that “university professors are almost never forced to resign over issues of nondisclosure”.

The satirical conceit can become grating. And despite the book’s subtitle, given the deadpan way in which it is written some might be confused about authorial intention. There is no introduction, but Jacquet does include some analysis in a “letter to her publisher” that appears as an appendix: “Each maneuver has some sleight of hand,” she writes, “but the end result of this strategy is not merely a card trick … [it] is more like the casino, with its calculated architecture and design … to keep the people inside comfortable and gambling as long as possible.”

In his thought-provoking 2012 history of power, Merchant, Soldier, Sage, the historian David Priestland argues that the struggles between these three power networks (or “castes” as he prefers to call them) are the main locomotives of history, with the merchants dominant for the past 30 years in much of the developed world. Putin is, of course, from the warrior caste.

Just as Machiavelli taught us the weapons and tactics that a Renaissance prince might use to get ahead, and Putin’s playbook lays out the modern warrior’s grisly possibilities, Jacquet lists the very different weapons that merchants unleash to hold on to their own power. Most of us will never need to use any of these tools, but there is a reason that Machiavelli’s book is a classic: as humble citizens we may have our suspicions about the battle being waged, but it’s rare that the protagonists are completely honest about what they’re doing. Jacquet has provided a useful if depressing glimpse inside the arsenal on hand for use by the corporate world.

The Playbook: How to Deny Science, Sell Lies, and Make a Killing in the Corporate World by Jennifer Jacquet is published by Allen Lane (£16.99). To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at To buy a copy for £14.78 go to Delivery charges may apply.


Bibi van der Zee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Power Failure by William D Cohan review – pulling the plug
General Electric was a 20th-century industrial empire. What caused it to fall apart?

Hettie O'Brien

17, Nov, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Edible Economics by Ha-Joon Chang review – a different set of recipes
The Korean economist takes aim at the neoliberal order of low taxes and deregulation through the unlikely medium of food

Dan Davies

19, Oct, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Escape from Model Land by Erica Thompson review – the power and pitfalls of prediction
From financial forecasts to the climate crisis, a constructive and nuanced critique of mathematical modelling from a data scientist

Felix Martin

30, Dec, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Butler to the World by Oliver Bullough review – oligarch’s paradise
A timely exposé of how the UK helps oligarchs, gangsters and money launderers spend and store their wealth

Robert Verkaik

17, Mar, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Bad Data by Georgina Sturge review – figures of derision
A parliamentary statistician lays bare the use and abuse of numbers in public life

Katy Guest

14, Dec, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
The Unfolding by AM Homes review – jittery tale of Republican conspiracy
Set in the wake of Obama’s election, AM Homes’s satirical prehistory of the Maga movement is caught between two eras

Xan Brooks

31, Aug, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Strength in Numbers by G Elliot Morris review – why polls matter
A valuable history of polling that examines the reasons for recent failures while arguing that it remains a vital tool

Sam Freedman

10, Aug, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Maror by Lavie Tidhar review – violence and corruption in Israel’s underbelly
The pragmatism of power is explored in a detective novel that takes in drugs, guns, politics and religion

Jake Arnott

13, Aug, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Side Effects by David Haslam review – what do we want from healthcare?
The ex-chair of Nice considers the spiralling costs of medical treatment and asks how we might fix a creaking NHS

Helen Ward

24, Aug, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Problem of Democracy by Shadi Hamid review – democracy and its discontents
Should US foreign policy demand liberalism, as well as free elections?

Jonathan Freedland

18, Jan, 2023 @11:00 AM