Chouette by Claire Oshetsky review – a feminist fairytale explores mother-love

Full of dark humour, this enthralling debut furiously eviscerates society’s need for normality

Tiny is pregnant, but not as we know it: she is expecting an “owl-baby”, the result of a secret tryst with a female “owl-lover”. “This baby will never learn to speak, or love, or look after itself”, Tiny knows. Her husband, an intellectual property lawyer, thinks her panic is just pregnancy jitters, and that she’s carrying his child. Even when he finds a disembowelled possum on the path and his “well fed” wife sitting in the dark (“It didn’t feel dark to me. I see everything”), he doesn’t believe. Then the baby is born.

Chouette, Claire Oshetsky’s first novel, is part feminist fairytale in the vein of Angela Carter, part suburban body horror. Its epigraph is a quote from the David Lynch film Eraserhead: “Mother, they are still not sure it is a baby!” That film, which centres around an alien-like infant, was, according to Lynch’s daughter Jennifer, based on her own “birth defects”. Oshetsky describes the novel as being inspired by her experience of raising “non-conforming children”, and is herself autistic. Her depiction of a baby who misses its developmental milestones, doesn’t speak and lashes out when frightened will be familiar to some families with experience of disability or neurodiversity.

Disability is frequently used as a horror trope, and in the wrong hands it is a metaphor that can become tasteless and offensive. This is not the case here. Really, Chouette is a sublime parable of mother-love which ferociously eviscerates society’s failure to accept nonconformity. It features one of the most detestable son/mother-in-law duos that I have known in fiction; all Tiny’s husband wants to do is find a medical “fix” for Chouette, whom he insists on calling “Charlotte”. He leaves mother and child to sleep above the garage, while his family exclude the new baby from gatherings and never visit. In one memorable scene, Tiny’s husband weeps with grief against her breast while her owl-baby nurses from the other. “That’s the moment when I choose you to be the one I’ll love the most … ” Tiny says to her baby.

Chouette is full of moments of dark humour as the otherworldly elements of the narrative brush up against the mundanity of suburban life and the demands it places on wives and mothers. Like all works of “fantastic” literature, it leaves the reader uncertain: is this a book about the truly supernatural, or the manifestation of a maternal coping mechanism?

It would not surprise me if Chouette finds a place in the feminist literary canon. It has lingered in my mind in a way that only the most original works do. In its exploration of difference – of disability, of queerness – it feels truly modern, but in its themes of love and sacrifice, it is the oldest tale in the world.

Chouette is published by Virago (£14.99). To support the Guardian and the Observer buy a copy at Delivery charges may apply.


Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Burntcoat by Sarah Hall review – love under lockdown
A sculptor considers the meaning of art, sex and disaster, in this masterfully achieved miniature epic set against a deadly virus

Lara Feigel

08, Oct, 2021 @6:30 AM

Article image
Where I End by Sophie White review – intense mother-daughter horror
A grim secret lies at the heart of this brilliantly visceral novel set in a hostile and isolated community

Christobel Kent

22, Oct, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Hourglass by Keiran Goddard review – a universal love story
The poet’s fiction debut vividly explores heartbreak, paranoia and the difficult work of being human

Ella Risbridger

13, Apr, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Every Rising Sun by Jamila Ahmed review – a feminist take on One Thousand and One Nights
Shaherazade is a rebel with an ever-evolving cause in this novelisation of the classic tales

Jenny Bhatt

05, Aug, 2023 @6:30 AM

Article image
Bellies by Nicola Dinan review – the fizz of first love
The complex layers beneath interpersonal relationships are closely observed in this moving debut of friendship, transitioning and first love

Jeremy Atherton Lin

23, Jun, 2023 @6:30 AM

Article image
Learned by Heart by Emma Donoghue review – exquisite imagining of Anne Lister’s first love
The Room author evokes a touching relationship between the lesbian diarist Anne Lister and her boarding school lover Eliza Raine

Clare Clark

24, Aug, 2023 @6:30 AM

Article image
When We Were Birds by Ayanna Lloyd Banwo review – a love letter to Trinidad
A young couple are confronted by life’s duties in a vivid debut about romance and loss in the Caribbean

Leone Ross

04, Mar, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Trespasses by Louise Kennedy review – love amid the Troubles
An affair between a young Catholic woman and a married Protestant barrister drives this brilliant debut set in 1975 Belfast

Kevin Power

16, Apr, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Love Marriage by Monica Ali review – a culture-clash engagement
An entertaining exploration of multicultural British modernity - love, sex, class, politics, faith and family – from the author of Brick Lane

Lucy Atkins

05, Feb, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Free Love by Tessa Hadley review – sexual revolution in 60s suburbia
A woman turns her life upside down and feels the allure of swinging London in this poignant tale of mid-life desire

Michael Donkor

12, Jan, 2022 @7:30 AM