The Fortune Men by Nadifa Mohamed review – injustice exposed

The real-life story of the Somali seaman who was wrongfully executed for murder in Wales is powerfully reimagined

Discussions of racial inequity often focus on the US as opposed to scrutinising the entrenched racism on our own shores. With The Fortune Men, Nadifa Mohamed takes her place among the growing crop of British artists and writers of colour – including Reni Eddo-Lodge, Steve McQueen and Jay Bernard – committed to correctively shining a light on recent British history.

Set in 1952 among the “tumbledown” docks, milk bars and lodging houses of Cardiff’s multiracial Tiger Bay, The Fortune Men is Mohamed’s third book. It novelises the real events surrounding the wrongful imprisonment and execution of Mahmood Mattan, a Somali seaman and father of three young boys, who was the last man to be hanged in Cardiff prison. Fabricated evidence, false witness testimonies and institutionally racist policing led to him being found guilty of the murder of a shopkeeper, Lily Volpert, here renamed Violet Volacki.

Mohamed’s refashioning of this story takes time to develop its momentum. Largely, this is because of an understandable attempt at even-handedness: several of the opening chapters take on the perspectives of Violet and her family, and capture their grief after Violet’s murder. The novel becomes most powerfully compelling when attention is squarely focused on spiky, maverick Mattan and the fight to clear his name. Mattan is a shape-shifting character, variously positioned as a rakish antihero, plucky picaro, petty thief, charismatic dreamer, prideful gambler, doting father, anti-colonial firebrand and speaker of truth to power. It is predominately through her depiction of Mattan’s imprisonment that Mohamed achieves this layered complexity. She animates his incarceration with evocative flashbacks to Mattan’s wandering childhood in fractious British Somaliland and recollections of his risky life in the merchant navy. Mattan’s tender aspirations and vulnerabilities are brought to the fore, humanising a figure often dismissed by those around him as reckless and troublesome.

The most searing element of Mattan’s incarceration as imagined by Mohamed is his spiritual contemplation when behind bars. While awaiting trial, Mattan’s belief in the “famous British justice [system]” wavers and he finds renewed religious faith that encourages him to assess his life afresh. This new understanding is expressed in delicate and perspicacious prose:

“God reminds you through […] night skies of how small and insignificant you are, and he speaks to you clearly, his anger and solace tangible in the rain he sends or withholds, the births or deaths he orders, the long, waxy grass he gives or the dead, broken earth he carves. The miasma above the prison, above Cardiff [had] separated him from God. He began to strut and blush his days away and completely forget that his life meant nothing and was as fragile as a twig underfoot. He had needed to be humbled […] he can see God’s wisdom so clearly now.”

In her determined, nuanced and compassionate exposure of injustice, Mohamed gives the terrible story of Mattan’s life and death meaning and dignity.

• The Fortune Men by Nadifa Mohamed is published by Viking (£14.99). To support the Guardian order your copy at Delivery charges may apply.


Michael Donkor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Orchard of Lost Souls by Nadifa Mohamed – review
The Betty Trask award winner takes on a complex history of Somalian civil unrest with a focus on women, says Maya Jaggi

Maya Jaggi

14, Sep, 2013 @7:00 AM

Article image
Fortune by Amanda Smyth review – passion and greed in the Caribbean
The search for oil in 1920s Trinidad leads to ruin in a magnificently absorbing novel based on real events

Amanda Craig

14, Jul, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
We, the Survivors by Tash Aw review – murder in a world of injustice
A fearful young man carries out a seemingly random crime in this gripping and strangely moving novel

John Burnside

27, Apr, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
Guardian first book award shortlist: Nadifa Mohamed

In the second of a series of Q&As with the shortlisted authors, Nadifa Mohamed discusses her novel Black Mamba Boy

Nadifa Mohamed

06, Nov, 2010 @12:06 AM

Article image
The President’s Gardens review by Muhsin al-Ramli – love, death and injustice in Iraq
An affirmation of the importance of friendship amid oppression, this vivid epic of life in a war zone is woven from the true stories of those who live there

Robin Yassin-Kassab

22, Apr, 2017 @6:30 AM

Article image
Eimear McBride: ‘Women are really angry. I feel a deep, burning sense of injustice at the way women are treated’
Her modernist debut explored the trauma of a young woman, while her latest novel examines the loneliness of middle age. The novelist talks about powering fiction with fury

Lisa Allardice

24, Jan, 2020 @11:58 AM

First novels from Simon Lelic, Nadifa Mohamed, Alan Monaghan and Ru Freeman

Catherine Taylor's choice of first novels

Catherine Taylor

02, Jan, 2010 @12:05 AM

Article image
The best recent thrillers – review roundup
This Is How It Ends by Eva Dolan; Damned Serious Business by Gerald Seymour; Fear by Dirk Kurbjuweit; The Woman in the Window by AJ Finn; and If I Die Before I Wake by Emily Koch

Barry Forshaw

05, Jan, 2018 @11:59 AM

Article image
The best recent thrillers – review roundup
Robicheaux by James Lee Burke; The Wife by Alafair Burke; The Girl in the Woods by Camilla Läckberg; Seventeen by Hideo Yokoyama; Gravesend by William Boyle; Hellbent by Gregg Hurwitz; Saturday, Bloody Saturday by Alastair Campbell and Paul Fletcher

Barry Forshaw

02, Feb, 2018 @12:00 PM

Article image
The best recent thrillers – review roundup
Firefly by Henry Porter; Darling by Rachel Edwards; Smoke and Ashes by Abir Mukherjee; The Man Between by Charles Cumming; Incorruptible by Barbara Nadel; The Wanted by Robert Crais

Barry Forshaw

01, Jun, 2018 @8:00 AM