Italians defend Dante from claims he was 'light years' behind Shakespeare

Leaders rally in support of ‘father of Italian language’ after withering comments in German newspaper

Italian political and cultural leaders have sprung to the defence of their much-revered poet Dante Alighieri after a German newspaper downplayed his importance to the Italian language and said William Shakespeare was “light years more modern”.

In a comment piece in Frankfurter Rundschau, Arno Widmann wrote that even though Dante “brought the national language to great heights”, Italian schoolchildren struggled to understand the antiquated verse of his Divine Comedy, which was written in 1320.

The epic poem, which is split into three parts and traces a pilgrim’s journey through hell, purgatory and heaven, was written in the vernacular Tuscan dialect to make it accessible to the masses, instead of Latin. His choice had such a great impact on writers at the time that the Tuscan dialect formed the basis for modern Italian, hence why the poet is known as “the father of the Italian language”.

Widmann also maintained that as a lyric poet, Dante was beholden to French medieval troubadours, the poet-musicians who wrote verses on love. “One important difference tends to be overlooked,” Widmann wrote. “The troubadours were pop singers, of whose masterpieces only the lyrics survive; Dante aimed to achieve the same effect – without music. He always felt in competition.”

But perhaps the most damning assessment was his comparison of Dante with Shakespeare. Widmann wrote that “Shakespeare, in his amorality, was light years more modern than Dante’s effort to have an opinion on everything, who dragged everything before the judgment of his own morality”.

Widmann wrote his article to coincide with Italians celebrating Dante Day on 25 March, chosen as it is the date on which most scholars believe he made his fictional descent into hell for the first part of The Divine Comedy. There are also events taking place across Italy this year to mark the 700th anniversary of the poet’s death.

The harshest reaction to Widmann’s piece came from Eike Schmidt, a German art historian and the director of Florence’s Uffizi Gallery, who described the journalist as “ignorant” during a radio interview.

“Widmann maintains that Dante’s importance for the Italian language was not so great, because children at school would have difficulty understanding his texts,” Schmidt said. “But that’s not the case at all. Apart from a few words and some theological concepts, Dante’s language is still perfectly intelligible today, unlike what happened with English or German in the 14th century.”

The Italian culture minister, Dario Franceschini, tweeted a verse from Dante’s Inferno in response: “Non ragioniam di lor, ma guarda e passa (Inf. III, 51)” (“let us not reflect upon them, but watch and move on”).

Luca Serianni, an Italian linguist and vice-president of the Dante Alighieri Society, told the news agency Adnkronos that the article had “a childish approach”.

Dante was born in Florence in 1265 and died and was buried in Ravenna in 1321. Pope Francis and the Italian president, Sergio Mattarella, both paid tribute to the poet to mark Dante Day last week. The pope wrote that Dante remained a “prophet of hope and witness to the human desire for happiness”, especially at this “moment in history”.

Mattarella told Corriere della Sera: “The Divine Comedy still attracts us, fascinates us, makes us wonder today because it talks about us, about the deepest essence of man, made up of weaknesses, failings, nobility and generosity.”


Angela Giuffrida in Rome

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Italy: Infernal row flares over Florence council's plans to pardon Dante

Wine-growing aristocrat to boycott ceremony and city's highest honour on behalf of poet ancestor

John Hooper in Rome

28, Jul, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Italy begins year of Dante anniversary events with virtual Uffizi exhibition
Gallery puts seldom-seen Divine Comedy sketches on display online to mark 700 years since poet’s death

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

01, Jan, 2021 @2:20 PM

Article image
Dante's descendant to take part in 'retrial' of poet's 1302 corruption case
Seven centuries after guilty verdict in Florence, Sperello di Serego Alighieri to help test whether poet’s conviction would stand today

Alison Flood

05, Feb, 2021 @3:26 PM

New face for 'not so ugly' Dante
He may not have been exactly handsome. But, as the Italian daily La Repubblica put it bluntly yesterday, 'he was less ugly than believed'.

John Hooper in Rome

12, Jan, 2007 @2:45 AM

Article image
Poets' unlikely love letters are turned into critically acclaimed film
Die Geträumten consists of readings from the letters of Ingeborg Bachmann and Paul Celan – daughter of a Nazi and son of Jews

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

17, Nov, 2016 @3:04 PM

Article image
'Italians go for the strongman': Montalbano author on fascism and the future
Andrea Camilleri, the novelist behind the much-loved Inspector Montalbano, has become a vocal critic of the Italian government

Lorenzo Tondo in Rome

05, Apr, 2019 @9:37 AM

Article image
Lines of fire: Dante's vision of hell still has an afterlife | Jonathan Jones
Jonathan Jones: The brilliant, terrifying Divine Comedy has always provoked artists to respond to its hardline moral absolutism

Jonathan Jones

05, May, 2011 @1:40 PM

Article image
Dante may have suffered from narcolepsy, says Italian academic

Divine Comedy author's obsession with sleep suggests he had neurological disorder narcolepsy, believes Giuseppe Plazzi

Lizzy Davies in Rome

24, Sep, 2013 @1:52 PM

Article image
Migrant rescue ship barred from Italy seeks help from EU nations
NGO director appeals directly to France, Germany and Spain after Italy and Malta spurn boat

Stephen Burgen in Barcelona

08, Aug, 2019 @10:59 AM

Article image
Number of asylum seekers sent back to Italy triples in five years
EU countries sending increasing numbers of refugees back to country of arrival in bloc

Lorenzo Tondo in Palermo

27, Jun, 2019 @1:55 PM