Lost memoir paints revered philosopher John Locke as ‘vain, lazy and pompous’

Rediscovered papers thought to record the memories of a longstanding friend say the ‘father of liberalism’ plagiarised and lied about never reading Thomas Hobbes

John Locke is regarded today as one of England’s greatest philosophers, an Enlightenment thinker known as the “father of liberalism”. But a previously unknown memoir attributed to one of his close friends paints a different picture – of a vain, lazy and pompous man who “amused himself with trifling works of wit”, and a plagiarist who “took from others whatever he was able to take”.

Dr Felix Waldmann, a history lecturer at Cambridge, found the short memoir at the British Library while looking through the papers of 18th-century historian Thomas Birch, who had acquired a trove of manuscripts from his contemporaries. Among these were drafts of a preface to an edition of Locke’s minor works by Huguenot journalist Pierre des Maizeaux. Sandwiched between Des Maizeaux’s drafts were five pages written in French, in which the journalist had recorded an interview with an anonymised “Mr …” about Locke.

A manuscript discovered in the British Library, of an anonymous friend’s recollections of the English philosopher John Locke. Dr Felix Waldmann has identified the speaker as James Tyrrell
Papers discovered in the British Library, of an anonymous friend’s recollections of the English philosopher John Locke. Photograph: Dr Felix Waldmann/British Library

Waldmann describes the discovery as the “holy grail” of Locke scholarship: not only is the memoir scathing about Locke’s character, it also reveals that he had read Thomas Hobbes’s 1651 masterpiece Leviathan, a work that was hugely controversial at the time, and which Locke had always denied knowing. Other scholars have hailed the find as “extraordinary”.

“This changes scholarship on Locke and I was absolutely stunned to find it,” said Waldmann. “It’s extraordinarily exciting … I don’t think I’ll ever find anything as significant.”

In a peer-reviewed paper published in the Journal of Modern History, Waldmann identifies the anonymous source as James Tyrrell, a close friend of Locke for decades. The pair met in Oxford in 1658 and corresponded for most of their lives. Locke stayed in Tyrrell’s home for several weeks, and Tyrrell took care of many of Locke’s possessions between 1683 and 1689 when the philosopher was exiled to the Netherlands.

The memoir opens with a reminiscence about Locke’s time at Oxford where, according to Tyrrell, Locke “did not study at all; he was lazy and nonchalant, and he amused himself with trifling works of wit”. Locke is remembered as a man who “prided himself on being original, and he scorned that which he was unable to pass off as his own”.

“This inclination often made him reel off, with great ceremony, some very common claims, and recite, pompously, some very trivial maxims,” Tyrrell tells Des Maizeaux. “Being full of the good opinion that he had of himself, he esteemed only his own works, and the people who praised him.”

Waldmann believes Des Maizeaux did not publish Tyrrell’s reminiscences because his edition of Locke’s works set out to celebrate the philosopher. “I imagine he was rather shocked to hear these things about Locke’s personal character and understandably just left it all out,” he said.

Tyrrell also claims that one of Locke’s books was “a copy of another which he claimed never to have read”, even though Locke had been “incited” to buy the book years before. Waldmann described this accusation as “a bit strong”.

“But what’s interesting is the fact that Tyrrell, who we regarded as Locke’s closest friend, is prepared to call him a plagiarist; that he thinks Locke’s success is a product of intellectual laziness,” he said.

But the Cambridge academic says the most significant revelation is Tyrrell’s revelation that Locke had read Hobbes’s Leviathan.

“It’s by far the most notorious work of philosophy published in the 17th century – [it was] absolutely heretical and Hobbes was looked upon with extraordinary suspicion,” said Waldmann. “Locke spends decades denying that he was familiar with Hobbes in any way, shape or form. He never cites Leviathan in any of his published works, never refers to him in his letters, thousands of which survive, so he’s gone out of his way to avoid any association.”

But Tyrrell claims to Des Maizeaux that Locke “almost always had the Leviathan by H on his table, and he recommended the reading of it to his friends”, even though he “later affected to deny, in the future, that he had ever read it”.

“The idea that Locke had no interest in his greatest predecessor has been greatly debated,” said Waldmann. “There are no mysteries comparable to Locke being placed in dialogue with Hobbes, and here is Locke’s closest friend saying he had Leviathan almost always on his table.”

Tyrrell goes on to damn Locke in many ways, both major – “he was avaricious, vain, envious, and reserved to excess”; “he took from others whatever he was able to take, and he profited from them” – and minor: Locke was reportedly so timid that “often, at night, the noise of a mouse made him get up and call out for his host.”

The relationship between the two had deteriorated as time went on, Waldmann said. “Locke becomes increasingly rude about Tyrrell to his face and to others, so that’s one personal animus,” he said. “The second was Locke’s extraordinary success. By the early 18th century, Tyrrell is still alive and he’s watching his dead friend, one who didn’t treat him particularly nicely, become the most celebrated literary figure of the past five decades. I feel he’d been sitting on this and he felt, well, now’s the chance.”


Alison Flood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Unknown text by John Locke reveals roots of 'foundational democratic ideas'
Newly discovered ‘Reasons for tolerateing Papists equally with others’ shows the Enlightenment thinker expressing unexpected social liberalism

Alison Flood

03, Sep, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
UK libraries and museums unite to save ‘astonishing’ lost library from private buyers
Friends of the National Libraries launch ‘once in a generation’ effort to raise £15m to buy the Honresfield library, packed with works by Brontë sisters, Jane Austen and Walter Scott

Alison Flood

17, Jun, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Mary, Queen of Scots ‘locked’ final letter using paper-folding, research finds
On the eve of her execution, Mary wrote a last message to French king, which scholars believe she used elaborate skill to secure

Alison Flood

10, Dec, 2021 @2:35 PM

Article image
Oh what a lovely archive: British Library gets Joan Littlewood treasure trove
Theatre Royal Stratford East’s colourful history is documented in more than 100 boxes of material collected by actor Murray Melvin

Michael Billington

01, Feb, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
Unknown John Donne manuscript discovered in Suffolk
Found in a box, the 400-year-old volume is one of the largest handwritten collections of the poet’s verse and is expected to sell for more than £200,000

Alison Flood

30, Nov, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
John Bercow announces 'candid' memoir, Unspeakable
The former Speaker and MP is set to reveal his thoughts on David Cameron and Boris Johnson in his book, released next February

Alison Flood

12, Nov, 2019 @9:22 AM

Article image
‘Priceless’ Brontë manuscripts could be lost to private buyer, warn experts
Historic holdings including handwritten poems by Emily Brontë are set to be auctioned by Sotheby’s, but MPs are being urged to save them for the public

Alison Flood

28, May, 2021 @2:14 PM

Article image
Gina Miller to write 'rallying cry' memoir, Rise
Brexit legal challenger to write book about struggles in her work and personal life, as well as ‘offering guidance and confidence to women in particular’

Alison Flood

24, Aug, 2017 @11:01 PM

Article image
Tremulous Hand stars in British Library's web showcase of medieval literature
Annotations of 13th-century reader, known for shaky notes that helped explain Old English to later generations, now survive in cyberspace

Alison Flood

31, Jan, 2018 @2:56 PM

Article image
Prince Harry’s ‘unflinching’ memoir, Spare, to be published in January
Publishing simultaneously in 16 different languages, the book is billed as ‘full of insight, revelation, self-examination, and hard-won wisdom’

Sarah Shaffi

27, Oct, 2022 @11:08 AM