Waterstones prize winner Elle McNicoll: ‘I never saw autistic girls in books’

The author was repeatedly told that no one wanted to read fun books with disabled heroes. Now she has won the £5,000 Waterstones children’s book prize for her debut, A Kind of Spark

When Scottish author Elle McNicoll was first trying to enter the publishing world, she was repeatedly told that people didn’t want to read about an autistic heroine. “In job interviews, I was saying that I wanted to see more books with disabled characters in them that were not traumatic, boring or educational, but fun and full of life. A lot of the reactions were, ‘Waterstones don’t like books like that’,” she says.

Now McNicoll’s debut novel A Kind of Spark has won the Waterstones children’s book prize. Published by tiny independent Knights Of, it follows Addie, an 11-year-old autistic girl, as she campaigns for a memorial to the witch trials that took place in her Scottish village. The novel has been praised by Waterstones’ booksellers as “eye opening, heart-wrenching, sad [and] inspiring”.

McNicoll, who is autistic herself, wasn’t looking for a book deal when she first met Knights Of; she was offering her services as a proofreader for books that involved disability. “The meeting started with me venting about job interviews that had been very soul destroying,” she says. “And they said, ‘We don’t have an autistic character, if you would like to write one’.”

By then, McNicoll had already written two thirds of A Kind of Spark, with Addie shaped by her frustrations with publishers. “I’d been working on a draft for a couple of years, but I was missing the main character. As I was going to these interviews and getting more and more disheartened, Addie started to form. She was definitely born out of a kind of defiance – the more that the industry pushed back, the stronger she got,” she says.

She is a character McNicoll would have loved to read as a child: “I was a voracious reader, but I never saw the word autistic written in a book, or autistic girls. We had [Mark Haddon’s] The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time, but we never saw neurodivergent girls.”

Published last summer, A Kind of Spark has already won the Blue Peter prize for best story, and was named as Blackwell’s book of 2020. Now Waterstones booksellers have picked it as the overall winner of their £5,000 children’s books prize, with the chain’s children’s buyer, Florentyna Martin, calling McNicoll “undoubtedly an outstanding new talent in children’s books [who] will inspire readers young and old for generations to come”.

“We have fallen in love with Addie, whose courage and determination are a guiding light, often reminding the world that kindness must prevail wherever we go,” added Martin.

McNicoll called her win “completely staggering”. “I will never say ‘I can’t’ again,” she says.

Previous recipients of the award, which is unique in that it is voted for solely by booksellers, include Angie Thomas, Katherine Rundell and Rob Biddulph.

McNicoll’s A Kind of Spark was up against Bethan Stevens’s “pitch-perfect and extremely entertaining” The Grumpy Fairies, which won the prize’s illustrated books category, and Darren Charlton’s Wranglestone, winner of the prize’s older readers category. A love story about two boys set in a post-apocalyptic America overrun by the undead, Wranglestone was described by booksellers as “epic, eerie and seriously scary”.

Charlton said he hoped his win would prove “there is a readiness in readers for the LGBTQ+ experience to expand into genres still dominated by their heterosexual counterparts.”

“Ultimately, this is a win for LGBTQ+ teenagers by showing you that your story can be for the many and not just the few,” he said. “I am so touched and so very grateful that my two boys ever found such an open-hearted tribe to champion them.”


Alison Flood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Utterly joyful’ Look Up! wins Waterstones children's book of the year
Nathan Bryon and Dapo Adeola’s picture book about a science-mad young black girl trying to distract her brother from his phone takes £5,000 award

Alison Flood

29, Jul, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
Waterstones children's book prize goes to 'mesmerising' debut adventure story
Kiran Millwood Hargrave’s The Girl of Ink and Stars praised for ‘good, old-fashioned storytelling’ that recalls Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials

Danuta Kean

30, Mar, 2017 @7:00 PM

Article image
Waterstones children's prize shortlists reflect readers' search for hope in anxious times
Book awards highlight titles providing optimistic perspectives on tough social problems that experts say are hitting youngsters’ mental health

Danuta Kean

08, Feb, 2017 @2:10 PM

Article image
Julia and the Shark’s writers on their pandemic-driven book lauded by Waterstones
The novel written and illustrated by husband-and-wife duo, Kiran Millwood Hargrave and Tom de Freston, has been named children’s gift of the year by Waterstones, while Paul McCartney’s The Lyrics wins book of 2021

Alison Flood

02, Dec, 2021 @9:35 AM

Article image
Black Lives Matter novel wins Waterstones children's book of the year
The Hate U Give, by US author Angie Thomas, has been praised as an extraordinary achievement

Sian Cain

22, Mar, 2018 @8:00 PM

Article image
Harry and Beatrix Potter face off on eclectic Waterstones book of the year shortlist
Sarah Perry’s The Essex Serpent is the only novel on the six-book shortlist, up against JK Rowling’s play script for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child and a long-lost Beatrix Potter story

Alison Flood

08, Nov, 2016 @11:59 AM

Article image
Waterstones says it can't pay living wage, as 1,300 authors support staff appeal
Managing director says book chain ‘simply not profitable enough’, as Sally Rooney, Val McDermid and other authors write to protest

Alison Flood

26, Mar, 2019 @12:28 PM

Article image
Waterstones chooses books of the year 'for a better, kinder world'
Greta Thunberg’s speeches and surprise hit The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse have together defined 2019, say booksellers

Alison Flood

29, Nov, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
‘No reader is too young to start’: anti-racist books for all children and teens
It’s never too early to learn that racism is wrong and we should be doing something about it. These books will help show our kids how

Aimée Felone

04, Jun, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Elmer author David McKee: 'I've never been a prize winner'
The creator of the patchwork elephant and Mr Benn has won the BookTrust lifetime achievement award. He reflects on his career and explains why his best ideas come to him in the bath

Alison Flood

24, Sep, 2020 @10:52 AM