Whereabouts by Jhumpa Lahiri review – hypnotic disappearing act

An unnamed woman in an unnamed city wavers between solitude and brief encounters in a spare examination of alienation

When Jhumpa Lahiri published her previous novel, 2013’s The Lowland, a wide-angled family saga centred on the Naxalite uprising in 60s Bengal, she was known chiefly as a writer of cross-cultural dislocation. With The Namesake (2003), a novel about a Bengali-American child who rejects his origins, and two story collections, including her Pulitzer-winning debut, 1999’s Interpreter of Maladies, she anticipated a US vogue for fiction that viewed American culture through the eyes of another. Yet Lahiri, born in London and raised in Rhode Island by parents from Kolkata, was sceptical of that brand: asked in an interview about “immigrant novels”, she observed that, in literature, “the tension between alienation and assimilation has always been a basic theme”.

Partly to escape these constraints, she taught herself Italian in her 40s, moving her family to Rome in pursuit of total immersion, an experience recounted in her 2016 memoir, In Other Words, written in Italian and rendered in parallel-text English by Elena Ferrante’s translator, Ann Goldstein. The following year, she published a translation of Domenico Starnone’s novel Ties; in 2018 came her own Italian novel, Dove mi trovo (Where I Am, or Where I Find Myself), which Lahiri has now translated herself under the less ambiguous title, Whereabouts.

Told by an unnamed teacher in an unnamed city in northern Italy, it’s made up of 46 vignettes, rarely more than two or three pages long, many not obviously about very much. The narrator swims and gets her nails done; there’s a lot of eavesdropping and people-watching. She shares a glance with another delegate in a hotel lift en route to a conference. She goes to the beach, where “there’s always some savage element... an element we crave and cower from at the same time”.

Part of the book’s peculiar magnetism lies in its clash of candour and coyness. When the narrator mentions “one of my lovers” or accepts a friend’s invitation to house-sit in the country “given that I’m going through a hard patch right now”, the remarks land like plot twists. Problems arise out of nowhere, whether she’s trying to mend a broken plate and getting Super Glue all over her hands or picking up a lover’s accidental pocket call that will expose a lie about how he spent his day. A flirtation with a friend’s husband – a father of two with whom the narrator goes on holiday, not to mention underwear shopping – loses its charm when he asks her to feed his dog during a family crisis.

The spare style, you would guess, is partly an effect of Lahiri’s consciously restricted vocabulary, the comma-spliced sentences a hangover from Italianate syntax. The tone can be high as well as cool. “There’s no escape from the shadows that mount, inexorably, in this darkening season”, we’re told, when the clocks go back. Spring is no cheerier, a time “of loss, of betrayal, of disappointment”. Buying a theatre ticket is an existential gamble: “But how will I be feeling at 8.30 at night on May 16 next year? There’s no way of knowing.”

It’s hinted that such thoughts are a legacy of the circumstances of the sudden death of the narrator’s father when she was 15. Even so, you can’t help but feel that the doomy solitude also relates to the larger energies driving this project. We surmise that the narrator is an only child who doesn’t get on with her mother, has never left the city in which she lives and has never formed any significant attachment in it; when she finally leaves for a country “across the border” where she can’t speak the language, the question of whether she means French, Slovenian or Swiss German plainly matters less than its wider symbolism as a doubly dislocated escape.

One influence here is Rachel Cusk’s Outline trilogy, narrated by a near-invisible writer who functions as an icily satirical sounding board for her various interlocutors. That vanishing act was Cusk’s complicated riposte to the reception of her self-exposing memoirs of motherhood and divorce; Lahiri’s decision to adopt the point of view of a northern European flâneuse likewise seems to chafe against assumptions about what she should write.

There’s also the imprint of Ferrante – readers of My Brilliant Friend won’t mistake the echo of Lila in the desire of Lahiri’s narrator “to remove every trace of myself”. In 2014, Lahiri said she was inspired by Ferrante’s pseudonymity as a “decision to communicate... solely on the basis of her writing”, a liberty that perhaps holds special appeal if you are a writer continually read through the prism of your heritage.

Still, when the narrator of Whereabouts uninterestedly mentions “protests in the centre... the helicopters have been circling the city all morning”, with nothing further said, it’s a mark of how the novel’s hypnotically surgical gleam can verge on bleached sterility. There has always been a sense that Lahiri’s self-reinvention requires Italy to be a blank canvas, and whatever its strategic usefulness, her version of it doesn’t seem a place any fiction writer can profitably stay long. Watching her plot a return journey ought to be interesting.

• Whereabouts by Jhumpa Lahiri is published by Bloomsbury (£14.99). To order a copy go to guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply


Anthony Cummins

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Lowland by Jhumpa Lahiri – review
The personal and political are beautifully balanced in Jhumpa Lahiri's second novel, finds Stephanie Merritt

Stephanie Merritt

07, Sep, 2013 @1:30 PM

Article image
Whereabouts by Jhumpa Lahiri review – a fascinating shift
Lahiri’s first novel to be composed originally in Italian focuses on a narrator adrift, free from the anxieties of biography and geography

Tanjil Rashid

06, May, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Lowland review – Jhumpa Lahiri's second novel is suffused with sadness

With her intricate second novel, Lahiri draws a powerful picture of brotherly bonds broken by politics, writes Anita Sethi

Anita Sethi

01, Jun, 2014 @12:30 PM

Article image
The Lowland by Jhumpa Lahiri – review
Does Man-Booker-shortlisted novelist Jhumpa Lahiri's real skill lie in short stories, asks James Lasdun

James Lasdun

12, Sep, 2013 @8:00 AM

Article image
Book club with Jhumpa Lahiri

The Pullitzer prize winning author will be in conversation with John Mullan at Kings Place on Tuesday 24 September

19, Aug, 2013 @10:58 AM

Article image
Hystopia by David Means – review
Traumatised Vietnam vets maraud the streets of a reimagined 60s America in this ambitious but problematic contender for this year’s Booker

Anthony Cummins

16, Aug, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Upstate by James Wood – review
The hero of James Wood’s midlife novel spends too much time with his implausibly well-organised thoughts

Rachel Cooke

13, Mar, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Trespasser by Tana French – review
Dublin detective Antoinette Conway returns in French’s absorbing tale of a murder that looks like a lovers’ tiff

Alison Flood

20, Sep, 2016 @5:30 AM

Article image
Different Class by Joanne Harris – review
The author of Chocolat revisits St Oswald’s for a twisting thriller with an unerring eye for school life

Alison Flood

24, May, 2016 @6:30 AM

Article image
Quieter Than Killing review – vivid and eerie
Sarah Hilary’s fourth DI Marnie Rome novel digs deep into the detective’s past, wrapping the story in effortless prose

Alison Flood

21, Mar, 2017 @7:30 AM