Richard Dawkins loses ‘humanist of the year’ title over trans comments

American Humanist Association criticises academic for comments about identity using ‘the guise of scientific discourse’, and withdraws its 1996 honour

The American Humanist Association has withdrawn its humanist of the year award from Richard Dawkins, 25 years after he received the honour, criticising the academic and author for “demean[ing] marginalised groups” using “the guise of scientific discourse”.

The AHA honoured Dawkins, whose books include The Selfish Gene and The God Delusion, in 1996 for his “significant contributions” in communicating scientific concepts to the public. On Monday, it announced that it was withdrawing the award, referring to a tweet sent by Dawkins earlier this month, in which he compared trans people to Rachel Dolezal, the civil rights activist who posed as a black woman for years.

“In 2015, Rachel Dolezal, a white chapter president of NAACP, was vilified for identifying as Black,” wrote Dawkins on Twitter. “Some men choose to identify as women, and some women choose to identify as men. You will be vilified if you deny that they literally are what they identify as. Discuss.”

I do not intend to disparage trans people. I see that my academic “Discuss” question has been misconstrued as such and I deplore this. It was also not my intent to ally in any way with Republican bigots in US now exploiting this issue .

— Richard Dawkins (@RichardDawkins) April 12, 2021

Dawkins later responded to criticism, writing: “I do not intend to disparage trans people. I see that my academic ‘Discuss’ question has been misconstrued as such and I deplore this. It was also not my intent to ally in any way with Republican bigots in US now exploiting this issue.”

Among his critics was Alison Gill, vice president for legal and policy at American Atheists and a trans woman. She said Dawkins’ comments reinforce dangerous and harmful narratives. She said: “Given the repercussions for the millions of trans people in this country, in this one life we have to live, as an atheist and as a trans woman, I hope that Professor Dawkins treats this issue with greater understanding and respect in the future.”

In 2015, Dawkins also wrote: “Is trans woman a woman? Purely semantic. If you define by chromosomes, no. If by self-identification, yes. I call her “she” out of courtesy.”

In a statement from its board, the AHA said that Dawkins had “over the past several years accumulated a history of making statements that use the guise of scientific discourse to demean marginalised groups, an approach antithetical to humanist values”.

The evolutionary biologist’s latest comment, the board said, “implies that the identities of transgender individuals are fraudulent, while also simultaneously attacking Black identity as one that can be assumed when convenient”, while his “subsequent attempts at clarification are inadequate and convey neither sensitivity nor sincerity”.

“Consequently, the AHA Board has concluded that Richard Dawkins is no longer deserving of being honored by the AHA, and has voted to withdraw, effective immediately, the 1996 Humanist of the Year award,” said the organisation.

The Guardian has reached out to Dawkins for comment.

Last year, the author JK Rowling returned an award given to her by the Robert F Kennedy Human Rights organisation, after its president, Kennedy’s daughter Kerry Kennedy, criticised her views on transgender issues. “I am deeply saddened that RFKHR has felt compelled to adopt this stance, but no award or honour, no matter my admiration for the person for whom it was named, means so much to me that I would forfeit the right to follow the dictates of my own conscience,” said Rowling in a statement at the time.

Contributor

Alison Flood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'Science will never know it all': Richard Dawkins, Margaret Atwood and others predict the future
As the 2016 London Literature festival begins, this year exploring the theme ‘living in future times’, science and sci-fi writers share their visions of humanity’s future. Interviews by Lucy Peters

Richard Dawkins, Margaret Atwood, Nikesh Shukla, Marcus du Sautoy and others

04, Oct, 2016 @11:50 AM

Article image
Richard Dawkins event cancelled over his 'abusive speech against Islam'
Berkeley’s KPFA Radio cancels appearance by evolutionary biologist after learning of his ‘hurtful speech’ against the religion – a charge the author contests

Alison Flood

24, Jul, 2017 @11:06 AM

Article image
Richard Dawkins expresses disbelief over slave owner ancestor story
Evolutionary biologist and atheist calls 'surreal' Sunday Telegraph article citing 18th-century forefather

Matthew Taylor

19, Feb, 2012 @1:38 PM

Article image
Science Weekly Extra podcast: Richard Dawkins talks about his new book on evolution

Richard Dawkins tells Richard Lea about some of the science in his new book on evolution, The Greatest Show on Earth

Richard Lea and Richard Dawkins

20, Sep, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
Richard Dawkins: intellectual titan or tiresome self-publicist? – books podcast

John Crace boils Richard Dawkins's memoir, An Appetite for Wonder, down to just 600 words, while Ian Sample and Andrew Brown consider his life and work

Presented by Claire Armitstead and produced by Tim Maby

24, Dec, 2013 @10:00 AM

Article image
An Appetite for Wonder by Richard Dawkins – review
Most geeks cannot write; this one can. Richard Fortey salutes a well-mannered memoir of 'the making of a scientist'

Richard Fortey

11, Sep, 2013 @11:00 AM

Article image
The Greatest Show on Earth by Richard Dawkins | Book review
Richard Dawkins's latest broadside just misses its target, says Richard Fortey

Richard Fortey

04, Sep, 2009 @11:07 PM

Article image
Video: Richard Dawkins on The Greatest Show on Earth

Richard Dawkins talks about why it's time for a book setting out the evidence for evolution, when calling someone ignorant isn't an insult, and how the media have made him into a militant atheist

Richard Lea and Andy Gallagher

21, Sep, 2009 @2:40 PM

Article image
The Magic of Reality by Richard Dawkins – review
Richard Dawkins's child-friendly endorsement of science is both enlightening and controversial, says Jessica Holland

Jessica Holland

23, Jun, 2012 @11:04 PM

Article image
The Magic of Reality by Richard Dawkins - review
Tim Radford admires a brilliant introduction to science for children

Tim Radford

21, Sep, 2011 @8:00 AM