Poetry book of the month: Loss by David Harsent – review

A firm virtuosity and sense of estrangement drives this challenging new collection

This is a long watch of a poem, a tormented vigil. You want to ask, “Who’s there?” – a question you might, like the guard in Hamlet’s opening scene, call out in the dark. If loss is the subject, who is the loser? And what – or who – has been lost? These questions are not easily answered.

This is the latest volume in an extraordinarily rich period for David Harsent. In 2011, in Night, he made darkness visible. Fire Songs (2014) and Salt (2017) flared into apocalyptic view soon after. The subtitle of Loss is “white nights”, but do not expect any atoning dawns. The form of the new volume is painstaking: stretches of italics describe a figure looking through a window, writing on misty glass. He is a “man in waiting”. Sonnets alternate with trochaics and lead back to the frightening consciousness from which this fragmented narrative poem comes.

It is the permeability of Harsent’s writing that astonishes: global catastrophe, violent incident, mechanical threat – all absorbed into the text. Yet the paradox is that he seems to be on the wrong side of the membrane of what matters to him. “Women of the house – he lay in the dark and listened to their voices… Their talk was a constant, soft, overlapping,/under and over music, soft questions, soft laughter, diminuendo.” It is their music – not his. Repeatedly, women’s hands appear, but their soft caresses do not soothe. Lovers are seen through a glass, darkly. Femininity and domesticity continue like a play on an unreachable stage, as though taking place in another world.

There are several references to “hidden theatre”, as if the stage should be sought (loss can, after all, be about what you never found). The poem is full of sinister commedia dell’arte figures, and we even have a brush with a “dramaturge of mood-swings”. The wakeful man describes himself as a pilgrim – a sinner. But this is no pilgrim’s progress, more a pilgrim’s stasis – written at a febrile standstill. And there is a violence about the way Harsent makes apocalypse telegraphic:

the worst already with us

dogfight politics barrel-bombs

children scorched faceless

deluge and wildfire.

At one point, the man says: “you feel you might/have outlived yourself”. Harsent’s poem pulls off a strange feat, exploring the posthumous while staying painfully alive. It becomes an experiment with absence – an exploration of what happens when you go missing to yourself.

He asks how it would be to be without what makes life worth living. Cityscapes and dreamscapes might release him but the city proves feral – clashing bin lids, bold foxes, toxic streetlights. And his dreams taunt him, too. Art offers perspective, but he tests its limits, and poetry’s too (there is a tension about the unspoken and its relationship to the unspeakable). He notes, “write it down”, a reminder of the small, plucky scale of artistic enterprise. The painters he returns to are Francis Bacon and Pierre Bonnard, as if to consider the distance and, less obviously, closeness between them.

He says “forgiveness is waste” and it is impossible to imagine less forgiving writing. It makes this volume a challenge to read. It is a compliment to its power that I longed to break free. The man in these poems is a figure in a landscape I fear might be ours. And while we might hanker after what Robert Lowell described as “the sanity of self-deception, pricked and kicked by reckless caution”, Harsent detects “a sudden rise/in willing blindness among the best of us”.

It is this blindness that Loss, with steadfast virtuosity, addresses.

• Loss by David Harsent is published by Faber (£14.99). To order a copy go to guardianbookshop.com. Free UK p&p over £15

An extract from Loss

There are forms gathered in the sky that he takes to be angels.
He believes in angels as he once believed in unassailable virtue.
There are voices that can’t be accounted for. There are faces
that come and go. There is a fool let loose in his house
which explains the breakage and wreckage, the faecal smell.
There are rooms in his house that he has never seen.
His heart went like a songbird’s fast and light, morning delayed
nonetheless. He got up and walked about, a man in waiting.
He sat down somewhere, a chill on the place. It seemed clear
there are rules that cannot be broken except by death
there are slums out of which comes greatness that goes to waste
there are things that fall to hand but can never be kept
there are chance meetings that discover a turbulence of love
there are maps that will take you to the edge of things.


Kate Kellaway

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Salt Moon by David Harsent and Simon Harsent review – night visions
Father and son combine poetry with photography to elegant effect, locating our inner turbulence in nocturnal seas

Kate Kellaway

03, Jan, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Night by David Harsent – review
David Harsent's enigmatic poems offer a gateway to a strange and dazzling world, writes Kate Kellaway

Kate Kellaway

13, Feb, 2011 @12:04 AM

Article image
David Harsent: ‘If I can’t hear the music, I don’t think it is a poem’
The recently announced winner of the TS Eliot prize talks to Kate Kellaway about dreams, his awful education and his years as a writer of detective fiction

Kate Kellaway

18, Jan, 2015 @10:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: Insomnia by John Kinsella - review
The relationship between art and our beleaguered ecosystem fires the Australian poet’s new collection

Kate Kellaway

14, Apr, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: Wing by Matthew Francis – review
This shimmering collection dissects the natural world with a wondering, meticulous eye

Kate Kellaway

18, Feb, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: Arias by Sharon Olds – review
Sharon Olds’s brilliant new collection, an exploration of intimacy and estrangement, is her most moving yet

Kate Kellaway

21, Jan, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: Lyonesse by Penelope Shuttle – review
Combining two collections in one, the veteran poet immerses us in a mythical kingdom in this extraordinary flow of work

Kate Kellaway

06, Jul, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: How to Fly by Barbara Kingsolver – review
The novelist teaches lessons in miniature in this deft and entertaining collection

Kate Kellaway

04, Aug, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: Tongues of Fire by Seán Hewitt – review
An inspirational, uplifting and assured debut collection

Kate Kellaway

12, May, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Poetry book of the month: So Many Rooms by Laura Scott – review
A debut collection channels Leo Tolstoy with extraordinary results

Kate Kellaway

06, Aug, 2019 @8:00 AM