The Water Dancer by Ta-Nehisi Coates review – a slave’s story

This ambitious debut novel from the leading American thinker is set on a Virginia plantation

Ta-Nehisi Coates’s eagerly awaited and ambitious debut novel is set in pre-civil war Virginia, on a slave plantation called Lockless in Starfall, Elm County. The stars of Lockless and other neighbouring plantations are indeed beginning to fade and fall: the slave owners, through a mixture of ineptitude and greed, have worked their lands to exhaustion and are now reduced to selling off their slaves to maintain their lives of idle luxury. Virginia is a hierarchy; at the top are the Quality, white slave owners with the power of life and death over their chief possession, their slaves. Next are the Low – poor whites, mostly uneducated, employed by the Quality to supervise the plantations and keep the enslaved in check. After them are the Freed, former slaves who were able to buy their own freedom. At the very bottom are the Tasked, the enslaved.

The main character and narrator, Hiram, is no ordinary slave. He is gifted with, among other things, a photographic memory; he is also son to Mr Howell Walker, the plantation owner. Howell acknowledges Hiram as his son; he takes him out of the fields and makes him a house slave, sometimes letting him entertain dinner guests with memory tricks, and even assigning to him the same teacher as his other son – and heir – the foolish, bumbling Maynard. This open recognition by his father encourages Hiram to believe in a special destiny for himself, and “in my quiet moments, to imagine myself in their ranks” – this despite constant warnings from Thena, an older slave and Hiram’s adoptive mother, that to the Quality he will always remain a slave.

Sure enough, as soon as Hiram comes of age, Howell cuts his private lessons and assigns him to be a manservant to his own half-brother, Maynard. But, just as Howell overturned Hiram’s dreams, fate also overturns Howell’s dream when Maynard and Hiram are involved in a freak accident, their carriage tumbling into the turbulent river Goose. A mysterious power transports Hiram out of the water and deposits him elsewhere on his father’s plantation. He has been Conducted.

Ta-Nehisi Coates.
Ta-Nehisi Coates. Photograph: The Washington Post via Getty Images

The revelation of Hiram’s gift of Conduction is one of the most important outcomes of the accident. Conduction, we discover, is the ability to magically transport oneself, and others if necessary, from one place to another. It will take Hiram a while to master and control it, but because of his potential, he is recruited by the local Underground Railroad cell, run by the outwardly prim and proper southern belle Corinne, Maynard’s fiancee, who is herself a rich plantation owner. The Underground Railroad refers to a series of safe houses and routes running from the slave-owning south to the free north, used by slaves trying to escape their bondage. In his 2016 novel The Underground Railroad, Colson Whitehead brilliantly pushes the metaphor of the railroad into the literal sphere by making the escaping slaves catch real trains in real underground stations as they make their way north.

In The Water Dancer, Coates uses a similar trope: he takes the secret wish of every enslaved person – the ability to magically escape bondage by teleportation – and makes it a reality. The myth of slaves escaping from plantations by swimming or flying back to Africa is a popular one in African American folklore; it populates songs and folktales, from where it makes its way into the writings of authors such as Toni Morrison. In The Water Dancer Coates hands Hiram, and a few others, this power. Coates also honours the achievement of the slaves by pointing out how indispensable they are to the masters, and to the whole American economy: “The masters could not bring water to boil, harness a horse, nor strap their own drawers without us. We were better than them – we had to be. Sloth was literal death for us, while for them it was the whole ambition for their lives.” In comparison the “gentleman” plantation owner is shown as weak, greedy, ineffectual, keeping control of the enslaved not by any inherent superiority but by terror and systemic white privilege.

Most of the novel follows Hiram in his efforts to master his powers of Conduction. To Conduct successfully, he has to tap into his past and unlock his childhood memories, because Conduction is powered by such recollections. For the enslaved, memory, both individual and collective, kept alive in stories and songs and dances, is a way of survival by connecting to a past that was free and dignified, going back all the way to Africa. The book, in this sense, is the story of Hiram’s apprenticeship as a Conductor. He has many mentors, both white and black, most of them agents of the Underground, but his most significant mentor, herself gifted with Conduction powers, is the abolitionist Harriet Tubman, presented here as a rather idealised figure – Moses and Jesus all wrapped in one.

The Water Dancer is partially fashioned after the popular slave narratives of the late 19th century, and like most slave narratives it is a coming-of-age story, a movement from “boyhood” to adulthood, from servitude to freedom, mirrored in the movement of the enslaved from the southern plantation to the free territories of the north. When he eventually arrives in Pennsylvania, a free man, Hiram is amazed to see other blacks living freely and in charge of their lives, and this makes him more determined to master his powers of Conduction. He yearns to go back to Lockless and free his beloved Sophia, and his adoptive mother, Thena.

A cemetery designated for slaves in the Middleton Place plantation, South Carolina.
A cemetery designated for slaves in the Middleton Place plantation, South Carolina. Photograph: Epics/Getty Images

Surprisingly, he also finds himself missing the plantation, and the paradox of home is another central theme in the novel. During his earlier episodes of Conduction, Hiram will find himself transported back to Lockless – because it is home and, logically, home is where he should be safest. And yet, in reality, he is never safe there; he is a slave, a prisoner. Such are the psychological disorientations the institution of slavery exact on the enslaved. Hiram does eventually go back to Lockless, setting up the novel’s climactic ending.

In his wildly successful book of nonfiction, Between the World and Me, and in his opinion pieces for the Atlantic, Coates has proved himself a keen and insightful observer of racial and cultural politics in America, and has been described by many critics as the natural successor to James Baldwin. Some of the themes in his nonfiction writing, especially his criticism of America’s unbridled capitalism, are raised in The Water Dancer. In Pennsylvania Hiram attends a progressive convention, where speakers compare child labour and the subjugation of women to slavery: “Slavery was the root of all struggle … factories enslaved the hands of children … child bearing enslaved the bodies of women … and rum enslaved the souls of men. In that moment I understood … that this secret war was waged against something more than the Taskmaster of Virginia, that we sought not merely to improve the world but to remake it.” Slavery, Coates seems to be pointing out, isn’t just about the past, it is about the present as well; not only about America, but about everywhere such inequalities exist.

Perhaps the most powerful and lasting image in this beautifully executed novel is that of the enslaved – or the Tasked, as Coates prefers to call them – who take their destiny into their own hands. They refuse to suffer in dignified silence, or sing hymns and hope for divine intervention; in fact, Coates’s vision here is a very secular one. Sometimes he seems to be making a subtle dig at faith-based abolitionist organisations; for if the church was helpful in freeing the slaves, it had also been complicit in justifying slavery.

Helon Habila’s Travellers is published by Hamish Hamilton. The Water Dancer is published by Hamish Hamilton (RRP £16.99). To order a copy go to guardianbookshop.com. Free UK p&p over £15.

Contributor

Helon Habila

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
We Were Eight Years in Power by Ta-Nehisi Coates review – on white supremacy
Trump’s election was a case of erasing a black president with extreme prejudice, argues the hugely influential writer in this essay collection on race in the US

Annette Gordon-Reed

18, Nov, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Beautiful Struggle by Ta-Nehisi Coates review – subverting white expectations
Coates, whose Between the World and Me has shot him to literary fame, earlier wrote this powerful memoir of his father and coming of age in Baltimore, says Rich Benjamin

Rich Benjamin

01, Sep, 2016 @3:00 PM

Article image
The Lying Life of Adults by Elena Ferrante review – a girl's own story
The confusions and clarity of female adolescence are explored in an astonishing novel set in Ferrante’s familiar Naples

Lara Feigel

19, Aug, 2020 @6:30 AM

Article image
Girl by Edna O’Brien review – a masterclass of storytelling
The Irish author lays bare the trauma of Nigeria’s abducted schoolgirls in this remarkable novel

Alex Clark

06, Sep, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
Barkskins by Annie Proulx review – an environmental epic
This ambitious saga about the destruction of the world’s forests follows two colonial dynasties across continents and centuries

Alex Clark

10, Jun, 2016 @6:30 AM

Article image
The Overstory by Richard Powers review – the wisdom of trees
This tangled epic about diverse lives is rooted in environmental principles

Benjamin Markovits

23, Mar, 2018 @7:30 AM

Article image
Phone by Will Self review – a hotline to humour and humanity
Dementia, the Iraq war and the effects of modern communications on human consciousness collide in the last of a disorienting trilogy

Alex Clark

08, Jun, 2017 @6:30 AM

Article image
Transit by Rachel Cusk review – a triumphant follow-up to Outline
Divorced and making a new start in London, a creative writing teacher is immersed in the lives of others in this radically inventive novel

Tessa Hadley

17, Sep, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Reservoir 13 by Jon McGregor review – a chilling meditation on loss and time
The rural village, the missing girl, the search for a body … then life goes on, as an archetypal story is rekindled with explosive results

Tessa Hadley

15, Apr, 2017 @6:30 AM

Article image
Red Birds by Mohammed Hanif review – a thrilling satire of US foreign policy
The ugliness of war is brilliantly captured in this wildly original novel narrated by a teenage refugee and a philosopher-dog

Dina Nayeri

10, Oct, 2018 @6:30 AM