Booker judges try to have it both ways

Awarding joint prize to Margaret Atwood and Bernardine Evaristo feels like a fudge

With the hindsight of history, the Booker misses plenty of tricks. In 1986, The Handmaid’s Tale, one of the most vital and prescient works of modern fiction, was pipped to the prize by Kingsley Amis’s The Old Devils. With Margaret Atwood now elevated to the status of a contemporary prophet, 2019 may have seemed like an opportunity to redress that mistake. Published with all the fanfare of a new Harry Potter and accounting for 86% of shortlist sales, her sequel has dominated this year’s award, sprinkling some much-needed publishing glitz.

The Testaments is a fascinating follow-up to Atwood’s initial story of Gilead, giving sharp insights into power and collusion through Aunt Lydia’s confession of her role in the theocratic regime. As Atwood has said, with women’s rights increasingly under threat in the US, the world seems to be moving closer to Gilead rather than further away. The book is gripping, pacy and beautifully written, though later sections in which two young women take on the patriarchy devolve into action adventure closer to the spinoff television series than to the austere mood of Atwood’s original.

But another novel called to the judges, too, leading to the shock decision to “break the rules”, as the Booker’s literary director Gaby Wood complained at the press conference, by sharing the prize between Atwood and the British author Bernardine Evaristo, whose Girl, Woman, Other is a landmark in fiction of a different kind.

Margaret Atwood poses with The Testaments, the joint Booker prize winner, at the London ceremony.
Margaret Atwood poses with The Testaments, the joint Booker prize winner, at the London ceremony. Photograph: Tolga Akmen/AFP via Getty Images

To honour Evaristo’s novel, which intertwines 12 narratives about black women in Britain, is to shine a much-deserved spotlight on an author who has blazed a trail in subject matter and style for a quarter of a century. Today, British publishing is at last eager for diverse voices: Evaristo’s whole oeuvre, she says, has been an answer to the question: “What does it mean to not see yourself reflected in your nation’s stories?”

The Testaments is a global bestseller, whereas Girl, Woman, Other is a brilliantly topical but leftfield novel crying out for a publicity push. It unspools in a freewheeling, endlessly flexible free verse patterned as thoughts flickering between past and present rather than as punctuated sentences. This is an ingenious device that beams the reader right into the mind of each of the 12 narrators – from farmer Hattie to theatre director Amma, banker Carole to supermarket supervisor LaTisha. Evaristo has always been ahead of the curve on gender and sexuality as well as race: Amma is a polyamorous lesbian, while Megan/Morgan has explored the trans spectrum and arrived at a “gender-free” position. The politics of the book are passionately upfront, but repeatedly undercut by sly humour.

Evaristo purposefully draws her people in bold brushstrokes, with almost soapy storylines – the prose may be experimental, but the readerly pleasures of character and plot are very traditional. It is a life-enhancing, horizon-expanding novel: funny, inventive and fizzing with vitality.

Two extraordinary books, then: but it has to be said that this feels like a fudge, weighing a huge event novel against a more obscure choice and trying to have it both ways. The danger is that the Booker effect that propelled last year’s “difficult” winner, the brilliant Milkman, to a wider readership will be dissipated. Perhaps it’s best understood as a reminder of how impossible it is, in the end, for the subjective process of weighing one novel against another to come to an objective conclusion.

• Justine Jordan is the Guardian’s fiction editor


Justine Jordan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Another author’: outrage after BBC elides Bernardine Evaristo’s Booker win
News presenter alluded to her joint victory with Margaret Atwood but failed to give the name of Girl, Woman, Other’s author

Alison Flood

04, Dec, 2019 @1:12 PM

Article image
Margaret Atwood and Bernardine Evaristo share Booker prize 2019
Judging panel break rules in choosing The Testaments and Girl, Woman, Other as joint winners

Alison Flood

14, Oct, 2019 @11:23 PM

Article image
The Booker prize shortlist resists easy reading
From the detonation of the domestic in Ducks, Newburyport to Don Quixote’s reincarnation in Quichotte, this year’s finalists challenge our assumptions

Alex Clark

03, Sep, 2019 @4:03 PM

Article image
Bernardine Evaristo doubles lifetime sales in five days after joint Booker win
Almost 6,000 copies of Girl, Woman, Other sold in the week after Evaristo’s win alongside Margaret Atwood

Alison Flood

22, Oct, 2019 @4:25 PM

Article image
Judging the Booker prize: 'I'm proud of our decision'
Picking a winner is an impossible task, says Booker judge Afua Hirsch. Margaret Atwood and Bernardine Evaristo both deserved to win

Afua Hirsch

16, Oct, 2019 @11:00 AM

Article image
Booker prize shortlist 2019: who to put your money on
Who will win the Booker prize this year?

Alex Preston

13, Oct, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
Handmaid's Tale sequel leads 'exacting' 2019 Booker prize longlist
Margaret Atwood’s The Testaments – not published until September – is chosen alongside 12 other ‘credible winners’ including Salman Rushdie and Jeanette Winterson

Alison Flood

23, Jul, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
The Booker prize judges have exposed the doublethink behind our arts awards | Charlotte Higgins
Naming Margaret Atwood and Bernardine Evaristo joint winners has pulled back the curtain on what we’re told is the ‘best’

Charlotte Higgins

15, Oct, 2019 @5:57 PM

Article image
Booker prize: Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale sequel makes shortlist
The Testaments, still under wraps before publication next Tuesday, joins final six alongside Salman Rushdie’s latest and a 1,000-page monologue

Sian Cain

03, Sep, 2019 @9:41 AM

Article image
Backlash after Booker awards prize to two authors
Decision to make first black female winner, Bernardine Evaristo, share £50,000 prize with Margaret Atwood causes controversy

Alison Flood

15, Oct, 2019 @4:25 PM