'People don't expect women to be funny': Marian Keyes on Comedy women in print shortlist

Revealing the five books in contention for the inaugural prize, Keyes hit out at the internalised sexism leading readers to assume women can’t write comedy

Bestselling novelist Marian Keyes has railed against the sexist attitude that “people don’t expect women to be funny” as she announced the shortlist for the inaugural Comedy women in print prize.

The £2,000 award was founded by the comedian, writer and actor Helen Lederer last year, after Keyes slammed the “sexist imbalance” of the Wodehouse prize for comic fiction. The Wodehouse is the UK’s only prize for funny writing, and has been won by four women in 19 years. Keyes, part of a judging panel for the CWIP that also features comedians Katy Brand and Shazia Mirza, said that “we are all so steeped in internalised sexism that we’re not even aware that it’s there”.

“The thing about internalised sexism,” Keyes added, “is that people don’t realise they are approaching things women create with an expectation that they’re going to be not as good or as important or as meaningful as things that are created by men. It’s something I grew up with and it’s taken a lot of conscious work to make sure that, in my own head at least, the playing field is more level.”

The five-book shortlist for the CWIP prize goes a small way towards evening things out a little further, she said. The nominees are Gill Sim’s Why Mummy Swears, Gail Honeyman’s bestseller Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine, Laura Stevens’s The Exact Opposite of Okay, Asia Mackay’s Killing It, and Balli Kaur Jaswal’s Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows.

Keyes pointed to the change that followed Kate Mosse’s launch of the Orange prize for women’s fiction in the wake of the Booker prize failing to shortlist any female authors in 1991.

“For the last 12 years it’s been incredible, the amount of women who have won. If we need to set up our own prizes to elevate the writing of women, well, it just brings that work more into the public eye, and I suppose by having a prize it engenders respect, and eventually a crossover will happen,” said Keyes. “At the moment people don’t expect women to be funny. That’s nonsense – women know that women are very funny but the official line is that women aren’t funny.”

This is partly down to the subjective nature of humour – and the fact that much of it comes down to identification, believes Keyes. “A man who doesn’t do much of the childcare would not identify with, for example, Why Mummy Swears. Whereas women find it so funny and respond with gratitude. A lot of men genuinely can’t identify, or are told not to identify, with what women write.”

Keyes had the same experience, growing up, with certain books by male writers. “I remember reading Tom Sharpe and thinking, ‘Why is this funny?’ It was the same way with clever books. I’d be told to read Philip Roth or John Irving or David Lodge and so much was about these creepy middle-aged professors having flings with their students and I’d be thinking, ‘Why is this meant to be a good book? I despise everyone in it, I identify with no one and yet I must be the stupid one.’ So absolutely we have always been taught that men are the funny ones, men are the clever ones.

“This isn’t an anti-man rant. There are many talented men writers. But they’re not in the majority. I think across the board it’s pretty much equal but it’s about what we’ve been taught to expect from what we read,” she said.

The winner will be announced on 10 July, alongside the winner of the CWIP prize for an unpublished writer, which comes with a publishing contract and £5,000 advance from HarperFiction. The unpublished runner-up will receive a free place on the University of Hertfordshire’s creative writing MA course.


Alison Flood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Comedy Women in Print prize unveils mythbusting shortlist
Marian Keyes, chairing this year’s judges, says finalists ‘showcase different ways that women are funny’ and challenge belief that women can’t write comic fiction

Alison Flood

08, Jun, 2020 @6:01 AM

Article image
Marian Keyes attacks 'sexist imbalance' of Wodehouse prize
Novelist admits to ‘grudge’ against comic fiction prize that has never shortlisted her work, and only gone to a woman three times in 18 years

Alison Flood

04, Jun, 2018 @10:44 AM

Article image
Jilly Cooper tops inaugural Comedy women in print awards
The Rutshire Chronicles author received the lifetime achievement honour, with prizes for rising stars Laura Steven and Kirsty Eyre

Alison Flood

10, Jul, 2019 @7:30 PM

Article image
Can Marian Keyes' Rachel's Holiday sequel equal her original's brilliance?
By continuing her story of romance and recovery, the novelist risks tainting the first book. Can you think of other authors who have finessed the follow-up?

Alison Flood

06, May, 2020 @3:30 PM

Article image
Helen Lederer launches prize for funny female writers
The Comedy women in print award is a response to how few female authors have won the Wodehouse prize

Alison Flood

10, Aug, 2018 @2:09 PM

Article image
Novelist Marian Keyes to headline Primadonna literary festival
Celebration of female writers will have alternative wedding chapel where women can ‘marry’ themselves

Caroline Davies

28, Feb, 2020 @7:03 PM

Article image
'Men still say women aren't funny': Nina Stibbe wins Comedy women in print prize
Reasons to Be Cheerful wins award set up to correct ‘sexist imbalance’ in Wodehouse prize, having also won that honour in 2019

Alison Flood

14, Sep, 2020 @7:00 PM

Article image
Grown Ups by Marian Keyes – one big happy family?
Marian Keyes shows superb skill at tackling tough themes in this tale of a clan with secrets

Hannah Beckerman

19, Jan, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
Grown Ups by Marian Keyes review – comic, convincing and true
The warmth and empathy of Keyes’s writing shine through this tale of family secrets revealed

Katy Guest

07, Feb, 2020 @7:30 AM

Article image
All-woman shortlist for BBC short story award 2013

Liz Bury: Chair of judges Mariella Frostrup says prize's second all-female shortlist shows it's 'suited to women's innovative brilliance'

Liz Bury

20, Sep, 2013 @6:45 PM