Family mounts legal challenge to Northamptonshire library cuts

Young resident’s application for a judicial review is latest in a series of tests to council’s decision to close 21 libraries

Northamptonshire county council is facing a series of legal challenges over plans to close 21 libraries, after a young resident applied for a judicial review of a decision campaigners say will have a “devastating impact” on families.

The action joins a separate case launched by residents in support of local libraries, as well as a formal complaint submitted to the secretary of state for culture, Matt Hancock, by the libraries body Cilip, which suggests the council has failed to meet its statutory duty to provide a “comprehensive and efficient” library service. The closures, which councillors approved in February, have been branded “monstrous” by the Northampton comics author Alan Moore.

Law firm Irwin Mitchell said on Thursday that it had issued an application for a judicial review and an urgent hearing after being instructed to act for a child and their family.

“Many people using the library services are children, or are elderly, disabled, or from low-income households, and they may struggle to access the library provision in larger towns,” said Irwin Mitchell’s Caroline Barrett. “These cuts are extensive and our client is concerned that this will have a very significant impact upon their ability to access a library service and the impact on local residents, many of whom live in rural areas. Our clients believe that, if implemented, these cuts will have a huge detrimental impact on the local community in Northamptonshire.”

Barrett said her client believes the council “failed to carry out a lawful public consultation into the proposals and has not conducted a full and lawful assessment of how vulnerable people will be affected”, has also “not considered how to promote and safeguard the welfare of local children”, and is failing to provide the statutory requirement of a comprehensive public library service.

The child’s mother said: “These cuts are not fair. They will have a devastating impact on families like ourselves, but also on the most vulnerable people within our community. The libraries offer us so much more than just books. They offer residents access to the relevant district council’s one-stop shop, blue badge and bus pass renewal, children’s services and plenty more services that residents rely on.”

The law firm Watkins and Gunn, which is representing local campaign groups in the second legal challenge, has also applied for a judicial review. Watkins and Gunn’s Michael Imperato said there were “several holes” in the council’s decision.

Hancock is currently considering whether to launch a government inquiry into the situation in Northamptonshire, which declared itself effectively bankrupt earlier this year. The closures would leave Northamptonshire with eight large and seven medium branches – one library for every 60,000 residents, according to the all-party parliamentary group for libraries.


Alison Flood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Government may intervene in Northampton library closures
Secretary of state considers launching a government inquiry, after Northamptonshire council plans to close 21 of county’s 36 libraries

Alison Flood

21, Mar, 2018 @1:37 PM

Article image
Campaigners launch legal challenge to library closures
Claims that cuts proposed by Somerset and Gloucestershire councils violate statutory obligations due to be tested in the high court

Benedicte Page

24, Feb, 2011 @3:42 PM

Article image
Doncaster library cuts are cultural vandalism | Lauren Smith

Lauren Smith: In such a deprived town, libraries are vital to the community. But the council sees them as 'soft targets' in the spending cuts

Lauren Smith

18, Aug, 2010 @11:06 AM

Article image
UK library budgets fall by £25m in a year
Official figures show steep drop in 2015/16 funding, a week after the government announced £4m Libraries Deliver grant

Danuta Kean

08, Dec, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Liverpool plans referendum on 10% council tax rise
Mayor says ‘desperate’ council needs £90m over next three years amid government cuts

Nazia Parveen

10, Nov, 2016 @4:43 PM

Article image
Young people bear brunt as councils reveal cuts to services

Dramatic reductions for libraries and children's services will take effect at start of new financial year

Polly Curtis

31, Mar, 2011 @11:05 PM

Article image
Family claims win in high court challenge to Northants library cuts
Proposed measures by struggling local authority had not considered statutory duties closely enough, judge rules

Alison Flood

14, Aug, 2018 @2:08 PM

Article image
Library closures protest to target houses of parliament
Authors Kate Mosse and Philip Ardagh to join 500-strong Speak Up for Libraries rally due to march on Westminster on Tuesday

Alison Flood

12, Mar, 2012 @4:22 PM

Article image
In Corby, life without local services is set to become a grim reality
As Northamptonshire council weighs up drastic budget cuts, residents are fearing the worst

Nadia Khomami

01, Aug, 2018 @6:19 PM

Article image
Books are the best medicine: how libraries boost our wellbeing
From hosting Comic Cons to Christmas socials, these community hubs can do wonders for mental health

Jane Dudman

10, Oct, 2018 @7:33 AM