Writers step in to defend author accused of plagiarism in New York Times

Jill Bialosky’s Poetry Will Save Your Life was charged with extensive use of others’ writing, but peers say accidental repetitions ‘were not egregious theft’

More than 70 authors, including Pulitzer prize winners Jennifer Egan and Louise Glück, have come to the defence of the editor and poet Jill Bialosky after she was accused of plagiarism, saying that Bialosky’s “inadvertent repetition of biographical boilerplate was not an egregious theft intentionally performed”.

A scathing review of Bialosky’s memoir, Poetry Will Save Your Life, by the poet William Logan in the Tourniquet Review last week accused her of having “plagiarised numerous passages from Wikipedia and the websites of the Academy of American Poets and the Poetry Foundation” when writing biographical details of poets including Robert Louis Stevenson, Emily Dickinson and Robert Lowell.

Logan provided examples of Bialosky’s writing and the passages from Wikipedia, adding that “many of Bialosky’s changes here and elsewhere – ‘barely’ for ‘seldom’, ‘verse’ for ‘poetry’, ‘unleashed’ for ‘gave rise to’, ‘total’ for ‘complete’ – are the slight, guilty revisions of the serial plagiarist”.

His claims were repeated in a New York Times news story, which quoted Logan as saying that “the similarity of language made my heart sink”.

Bialosky, a poet, novelist and editor at WW Norton, was honoured by the Poetry Society of America for her contribution to the art in 2014. In a response to the New York Times article, she said that she would “correct any errors that are found for future editions of the book”.

Her statement added: “William Logan has extracted a few ancillary and limited phrases from my 222-page memoir that inadvertently include fragments of prior common biographical sources and tropes after a multi-year writing process. This should not distract from the thesis of this book, which derives from my own life, my experiences and observations.”

Her publisher Simon & Schuster called Bialosky “a highly regarded editor and author” and the book “a unique and critically acclaimed” memoir. “We stand by the book and are ready to work with the author to make any necessary corrections for future editions,” it said.

Now 72 authors, describing themselves as “writers and friends of literature”, have written to the New York Times to express their concern about the paper’s story. They said that “by giving a large platform to a small offence”, the story had “tainted the reputation of this accomplished editor, poet and memoirist”.

The letter’s authors, Kimiko Hahn and David Baker, identified themselves as writers who have been edited by Bialosky. Of the 70 other signatories, who also include Egan, Claire Messud, Robert Pinsky and Roxanne Robinson, many are also published by WW Norton and edited by Bialosky. Egan and Glück are not.

The letter says that the charges laid against Bialosky “refer to a handful of commonly known biographical facts gleaned from outside sources”.

The authors say: “Given the trust that is assumed between a writer and her readers, this mishandling is not something to shrug off. Yet it bears saying that Ms Bialosky’s inadvertent repetition of biographical boilerplate was not an egregious theft intentionally performed. They say that they “stand with Ms Bialosky and her statement of apology” and that “it would be a terrible disservice to Ms Bialosky and to your readers if the article kept people from appreciating her substantial contributions to American letters”.


Alison Flood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
New York Times pulls YA novel from bestseller list after reports of fake sales
Lani Sarem’s Handbook for Mortals was taken off the No 1 spot after fellow YA authors, sceptical of ‘a book that no one has heard of’, uncovered a pattern of strategic preorders

Alison Flood

25, Aug, 2017 @3:05 PM

Article image
USA Today drops crossword compiler accused of plagiarism
Clues led to discovery of similarities to puzzles in the New York Times

Roy Greenslade

11, May, 2016 @4:04 PM

Article image
New York Times exposé of Harvey Weinstein to be made into movie
The Pulitzer prize-winning work of two female journalists is to become a film in the mould of Spotlight and All the President’s Men

Catherine Shoard

26, Apr, 2018 @9:32 AM

Article image
Will Wordle still be free after the New York Times buyout?
Will the hit game imminently be locked behind a paywall or stay as it is? What about ads? The NYT’s head of games explains the plan

Keith Stuart

02, Feb, 2022 @2:59 PM

Article image
New York Times columnist accused of eugenics over piece on Jewish intelligence
Bret Stephens faces backlash after suggesting that Ashkenazi Jews are smarter than other people

Edward Helmore

28, Dec, 2019 @6:47 PM

New York Times columnist caught in plagiarism row

Maureen Dowd's column features paragraph virtually identical to passage written by Talking Points Memo blogger

Ed Pilkington in New York

18, May, 2009 @5:03 PM

Article image
Male writers continue to dominate literary criticism, Vida study finds
Women buy two-thirds of books sold but magazine coverage is centred on men – though picture is beginning to change

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

07, Apr, 2015 @2:00 AM

Article image
New York Times reports sales rise
Paid-for digital subscriptions reach almost 600,000 but advertising suffers year-on-year declines

Mark Sweney

25, Oct, 2012 @9:20 PM

Article image
‘Incredible’: from Wordle’s Welsh beginnings to the New York Times
The puzzle’s global success has turned Josh Wardle into a megastar in the gaming world and bemused his family

Steven Morris

01, Feb, 2022 @6:52 PM

Article image
Wikileaks cables divided New York Times readers

The paper's executive editor on the response to its WikiLeaks disclosures from the readership and the White House

Bill Keller, executive editor, the New York Times

10, Dec, 2010 @7:00 AM