Alfred Wainwright may have had autism, biographer says

Book discusses famous fell walker’s obsessiveness and need for a ‘compulsive rigidity’ as he compiled intricate Lakeland guidebooks

He was famed for his stubborn nature, insisting his intricate Lakeland guidebooks be printed in his own handwriting and balking at any outing that would involve him missing an episode of his beloved Coronation Street. Now a new biography of the renowned fell walker Alfred Wainwright by one of his closest associates argues that he may have been on the autistic spectrum.

The claim is made by Richard Else, a Bafta-winning film maker who coaxed Wainwright on to television in the 1980s and became so close to him in his later years that they were often mistaken for father and son. The pair made three BBC series and travelled more than 5,000 miles together, exploring the Lake District, Scotland and the Pennine Way, as well as Wainwright’s own creation – the Coast to Coast walk.

Wainwright Revealed, which is published this week, offers an affectionate portrait of an unintentionally awkward man who understood the hills more than other people.

Else admits he has no medical background, but points to his subject’s obsessiveness and need for a “compulsive rigidity” as evidence of possible autism. Wainwright survived on a diet consisting almost exclusively of fish and chips, ideally eaten at a Little Chef. He absolutely had to know the latest Blackburn Rovers score (and latest Coronation Street plot) and had worked his way through every single book about westerns in Kendal library while ignoring every other genre.

Wainwright’s “need for all-enveloping order” can be seen in his seven-volume masterpiece, A Pictorial Guide to the Lakeland Fells, argues Else. The books follow a distinctly idiosyncratic approach, obsessively cataloguing each fell in a range and listing every ascent, rather than just the most rewarding or easiest. He ranked all aspects of the Lake District, listing not only the best fells and summits and finest ridge walks, but also the best square mile: around Castle Crag in Borrowdale.

“I believe AW may have been, in the terminology currently used, ‘on the spectrum’,” writes Else, who has consulted with doctors who admire Wainwright and who, he says, agree that his amateur diagnosis “seems consistent with what we know about him and his work”.

Jane King, one of Wainwright’s two stepdaughters, who deal with the literary estate, has considered Else’s theory. “He certainly did have some traits that nowadays might be considered on the autistic spectrum — the order in his life and the obsession with his work. The fact that he spent 13 years doing these guides, which was an amazing feat, but how many people would spend 13 years doing these guides every evening?”

King was a teenager when she first met Wainwright and says he liked to have his meals at fixed times and had a “very ordered” daily routine: “Every evening he just went up to his study and wrote and drew, apart from coming down to eat and Coronation Street and very special occasions. That’s a fairly unusual pattern, I think.” But, she adds: “If he hadn’t been like that he would never have produced these guides.”

When Else wrote to Wainwright in 1982 as a young programme maker, he held out little hope that the great man would agree to be interviewed on camera. Despite wide acclaim, no radio or TV producer had succeeded in interviewing Wainwright, who appeared to show no interest in the limelight. He had a reputation, Else admits, as “a curmudgeonly, difficult and off-hand man”.

Wainwright’s initial reply was typically blunt: “[Appearing on television] is not my cup of tea at all”, he said. “If you are wanting autobiographical details, you will find all I am prepared to divulge in my book titled Fellwanderer.”

Else had started making the film without its star when he received a message from Andrew Nichol, the printing manager at the Westmorland Gazette, Wainwright’s publishers: “AW would like to see you. He doesn’t like the idea of everyone talking about him and not having a chance to say anything. So I’d bring the film crew with you. 10.00am, Kendal Green. Best of luck...”

So began a long, rewarding and sometimes frustrating relationship which lasted a decade, until Wainwright died in 1991.

Since his death, Else has reflected on why Wainwright behaved as he did. “I have thought about his attitude and psychological makeup, in particular the way he behaved with other people, and I came to the view that this was not deliberate or the action of someone who wished to be awkward,” Else writes in the book. “That Wainwright behaved in the way he did was, I concluded, an involuntary act.”

Jane Harris, the director of external affairs at the National Autistic Society, said: “The suggestion that an influential figure like Alfred Wainwright may have been autistic is certainly interesting and shows that the general public are becoming more aware of autism. This new awareness is encouraging, but it’s impossible to retro-diagnose a person. The diagnosis process is detailed, carried out by an expert team and requires the child or adult to be present to answer a range of questions about how they see and experience the world.

“We do know that many autistic people find the noise, unpredictability and frantic pace of a city overwhelming and prefer tranquil spaces. So although we can’t say for certain that Alfred was autistic, if he had been, this is a reminder that throughout history, autistic people have been sharing their passions and unique skills to the huge benefit of wider society.”

Else said Wainwright would not have taken offence at his armchair autism diagnosis: “I don’t think he’d have challenged it because he had a certain bluntness and wouldn’t have seen any of the connotations that other people might have about it … He would probably have just looked at me, puffed at his pipe and said ‘hmmm’.”

Contributor

Helen Pidd North of England editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Alfred Wainwright’s coast-to-coast walk to be made National Trail
Spectacular country walk through Lake District and Yorkshire Dales will be made more accessible

Mark Brown North of England correspondent

11, Aug, 2022 @11:01 PM

Article image
Beatrix Potter would not have liked Peter Rabbit film - biographer
Sony adaptation in which James Corden is voice of bullying rabbit would have appalled author

Alison Flood

09, Mar, 2018 @10:40 AM

Article image
Amazon pulls books offering dangerous 'cures' for autism
Following reports of dangerous therapies being promoted in titles being sold through the site, a number have been quietly withdrawn

Alison Flood

14, Mar, 2019 @2:35 PM

Article image
TV presenter Melanie Sykes announces ‘life-affirming’ autism diagnosis
Sykes says being diagnosed as autistic at 51 has helped explain struggles during broadcasting career

Nadia Khomami Arts and culture correspondent

16, Nov, 2021 @12:13 PM

Article image
‘We weren’t visible’: growing awareness leads more women to autism diagnosis
Analysis: Melanie Sykes’ diagnosis part of wider trend in women finding out they are autistic in adulthood

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

19, Nov, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Why private genius Alfred Wainwright deserves a public monument

Ben Myers: Highly uncomfortable in any kind of spotlight, the lyric master of the guide book is due a memorial statue

Ben Myers

17, Feb, 2009 @12:48 PM

Article image
Wainwright prize for nature writing goes to 'extraordinary book' on first world war
Where Poppies Blow by John Lewis-Stempel studies how the natural world helped sustain the morale of troops contending with the horror of the trenches

Alison Flood

03, Aug, 2017 @1:30 PM

Article image
DVLA U-turns on autism disclosure policy after uproar
Drivers with autism will only need to disclose diagnosis if their driving is affected, following Guardian report

Amelia Hill

05, Mar, 2019 @3:50 PM

Article image
Santa Claus comes to autism-friendly grottos across UK
Children able to enjoy Christmas magic without crowds, noise or flashing lights that can be distressing

Josh Halliday

19, Dec, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Autism: 'hidden pool' of undiagnosed mothers with condition emerging
Experts report growing phenomenon of women recognising themselves as they research their children’s disorders

Amelia Hill

26, Dec, 2016 @12:01 AM