The Wonder by Emma Donoghue review – a thrilling domestic psychodrama

Miracle, fraud or medical anomaly? A gripping investigation into an Irish girl’s fasting by the writer of Room

Emma Donoghue will probably always be best known for her 2010 bestseller Room, a child’s-eye view of confinement and escape prompted by the horrific Josef Fritzl case in Austria, which she adapted for the screen last year. More commonly, though, she reaches further back into the historical archive for inspiration, breathing imaginative life into biographical footnotes – a 19th-century American murder in Frog Music, a scandalous Victorian British divorce in The Sealed Letter – to create novels and short stories that are refreshingly revisionist about class, gender and sexuality.

Her new book is based on the many cases of “fasting girls” reported across the world from the 16th to the 20th centuries: women and girls, often prepubescent, who claimed to live without food for months or even years. Whether it was anorexia, religious mania or entrepreneurial spirit that was driving them, they drew donations from curious visitors and fascination from doctors, scientists and priests, keen to discover if they could really be living on air, light or the love of God. (The phenomenon divides along gender lines: while women withdrew into bedrooms that became shrines, their male equivalents, the “hunger artists” immortalised in Kafka’s story, presented starvation as a performative feat of endurance in travelling fairs, a trend culminating in illusionist David Blaine’s 44-day fast in a glass box dangled over the Thames.)

Several of the fasting girls were placed under medical surveillance, with predictable results – which is where Donoghue comes in. Lib Wright is an English nurse who has served in the Crimea under the redoubtable “Miss N”, and now takes on a well paid but perplexing commission in an Irish backwater: to watch for a fortnight over 11-year-old Anna O’Donnell, who apparently has not eaten for four months, and thus reveal whether she is a miracle or a fraud. Lib is briskly impatient with the heady mixture of religiosity and folklore permeating the village like peat smoke, and at first with the obliging yet resistant Anna herself. She notes Anna’s symptoms – downy cheeks, scaly skin, blue fingertips, swollen lower limbs – checks over the tumbledown cabin for caches of food, limits Anna’s contact with her parents to a brief embrace morning and evening, and expects that she will have the mystery solved in short order. But as the days pass, no secret feeding is discovered. Anna’s condition worsens and Lib begins to wonder: “Could the Watch be having the perverse effect of turning the O’Donnells’ lie to truth?”

Donoghue draws out the narrative suspense with her customary combination of historical verve and emotional delicacy, as the mystery becomes not so much what is happening beneath Lib’s nose, but why. “Every body was a repository of secrets,” Lib muses, as she starts to look beyond her desire to expose trickery towards a truth that can be expressed only through suffering, not words. Faith, or what Lib calls “religious mumbo-jumbo”, can trump reason. Anna is mourning a dead brother, obsessively totting up how many prayers will get him into heaven, and the dark days of the famine still hang over the village. “A child now 11 must have been born into hunger. Weaned on it, reared on it … every thrifty inch of Anna’s body had learned to make do with less.” Caught at the nexus of family secrets, religious hysteria and medical hypothesis, with one doctor idly wondering if her chilled extremities are a sign that she is changing into “more of a reptilian than a mammalian nature”, Anna has only one power available to her: the anorexic’s power of refusal.

Like Room, this is a thrilling domestic psychodrama that draws its power from quotidian detail as well as gothic horror, as a woman and a child at close quarters must draw on inner resources to survive an impossible situation. But Donoghue also sets Anna and Lib’s relationship in a wider context: of English and Irish antagonism, of the birth of nursing, of the clash between science and faith. By the end of the book, the fiercely atheist Lib has adopted Anna’s religious cadences, presenting herself as both tempter and priest. Should Anna break her fast, it will be a new kind of sacrament, an admission of the body and “such need, such desire, risk and regret, all the unhallowed mess of life”.

• To order The Wonder for £12.29 (Picador, RRP £14.99) go to or call 0330 333 6846. Free UK p&p over £10, online orders only. Phone orders min p&p of £1.99.


Justine Jordan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Akin by Emma Donoghue review – the ties that bind
A boy is thrown together with his great-uncle in this examination of freedom and family by the author of Room

Sarah Crown

12, Oct, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
The Sealed Letter by Emma Donoghue - review

DJ Taylor admires a Victorian divorce drama that will surprise Emma Donoghue fans

DJ Taylor

07, Oct, 2011 @9:54 PM

Article image
The Pull of the Stars by Emma Donoghue review – fighting the 1918 flu pandemic
Fear and female camaraderie combine in this tale of three Dublin medics’ experiences from the author of Room

Sarah Moss

17, Jul, 2020 @6:30 AM

Article image
Emma Donoghue: seven kids and four parents – bigger is better in children’s books
In classics from Eve Garnett to Arthur Ransome, there are always enough kids to form a world without adults – and a hardcore tomboy can have a place in the gang

Emma Donoghue

29, Apr, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Room by Emma Donoghue and Forgetting Zoe by Ray Robinson | Book reviews

Susanna Rustin on contrasting stories of incarceration and escape

Susanna Rustin

06, Aug, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
Astray by Emma Donoghue – review
Justine Jordan on sharp historical fictions

Justine Jordan

09, Nov, 2012 @10:54 PM

Article image
Room by Emma Donoghue | Book review

Inspired by the Josef Fritzl case, Emma Donoghue's much-hyped seventh novel is a gem, says Nicola Barr

Nicola Barr

31, Jul, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
Book Club with Emma Donoghue

Join the author for a discussion of her bestselling novel Room at Kings Place on Monday 24 March

21, Jan, 2014 @10:56 AM

Article image
Emma Donoghue on writing Room: ‘I toned down some of the horror of the Fritzl case’
Donoghue’s bestseller drew on the case of Felix Fritzl, who was held captive in a dungeon by his father, and her observations of her own children

Emma Donoghue

08, May, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Wonder by Emma Donoghue review – Room’s ingredients remixed
Emma Donoghue’s latest, a gothic chiller set in 19th-century Ireland, is, like its predecessor, at its best in confined spaces

Julie Myerson

30, Aug, 2016 @6:00 AM