A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever Lived review – popular science at its best

Adam Rutherford’s elegant account of the Human Genome Project brings a note of realism to our dreams of a medical revolution

Sixteen years ago, British researcher Ewan Birney launched an unusual sweepstake. At the time, scientists were completing the Human Genome Project, the international effort to unravel the genetic makeup of human beings. But how many individual human genes would be revealed when the project was completed, Birney wondered? So he asked the world’s top geneticists to each bet a dollar on the outcome.

This might have seemed a rather tardy question, given that the project had already consumed “the best part of a decade, the invention of brand new technologies, unprecedented computing power and $3bn”, as Adam Rutherford notes. Late or not, Birney’s query nevertheless produced a striking answer.

A total of 460 geneticists – including several Nobel winners – stepped up to make their predictions. Some believed the project would show humans have up to 250,000 genes. After all, we are extraordinarily complex creatures, it was argued. Surely we must have a huge number of genes to control the manufacture of the proteins from which our densely connected neural circuits are made. Other researchers stuck at around 150,000 while most plumped for a figure above 70,000. Birney chose 48,000. The lowest guess, by US geneticist Lee Rowen, was 25,947.

Then, in 2003, the Human Genome Project revealed the true figure. We have about 20,000 genes. “The best experts in the world were all mistaken,” writes Rutherford. “And they were not just a little bit out.” Our much-vaunted understanding of how DNA rules our bodies, minds and lives, gleaned in the latter half of the 20th century, was shown to rest on rather shaky intellectual ground.

Humans turn out to have fewer genes than a roundworm. Or a banana. Or a grain of rice. Yet scientists had no inkling our complement of genes was so meagre. As Rutherford notes: “The greatest achievement of the Human Genome Project was working out exactly how little we knew.”

It is a neat phrase and typical of this elegant, informed account of the lessons we are still learning from the project. This is no bombastic view of a world transformed by modern genetics or a health service revolutionised by gene-based therapies. More than anything, this is a book that highlights the limits of what genes can tell about us or do for us. Yes, they have helped us understand the causes of diseases. “But the number of diseases that have been eradicated as a result of our knowing our genome? Zero,” states Rutherford. “And the number of diseases that have been cured as a result of gene therapy? Zero.”

Biology researcher Ewan Birney
Biology researcher Ewan Birney challenged the world’s top geneticists to predict the outcome of the Human Genome Project. Photograph: Antonio Olmos

Such advances will doubtless occur in the long term. However, it is Rutherford’s aim to bring some realism to the subject without losing a sense of wonder about the new biological visions being opened up. We have discovered that modern humans once interbred, albeit briefly, with our Neanderthal predecessors; conclusively pinpointed the corpse of Richard III; and demonstrated that the idea of race is an illusion. Indeed, on this last point, Rutherford is unequivocal. “Genetics has shown that people are different and these differences cluster according to geography and culture but never in a way that aligns with the traditional concepts of human races.”

Nor is Rutherford happy with some of those who seek to commercialise modern genomics, and in particular derides ancestry companies that have claimed their DNA tests reveal the identity of Jack the Ripper; that Prince William harbours Indian blood; and that it is possible to trace living descendants of the Queen of Sheba. This is “PR dressed up as research”, we are told.

For Rutherford, modern genetics has far less to say about us as individuals than we have been led to believe. On the other hand, he is confident it sheds a great deal of light on us as a species. Demonstrating these divergent concepts is not easy. Happily, Rutherford is up to the task. He has produced a polished, thoroughly entertaining history of Homo sapiens and its DNA in a manner that displays popular science writing at its best.

A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever Lived is published by W&N (£20). Click here to buy it for £16


Robin McKie

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Robin McKie’s best science books of 2016
The pick of this year’s science books put our health – and other obsessions – under the microscope

Robin McKie

05, Dec, 2016 @8:59 AM

Article image
'As long as we study life, it will be read': the Selfish Gene turns 40
In 1976 Richard Dawkins’s study of evolutionary theory became the first popular science bestseller. How do its ideas stand up today?

Adam Rutherford

29, May, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
The 100 best nonfiction books: No 15 – The Double Helix by James D Watson (1968)
An astonishingly personal and accessible account of how two Cambridge scientists unlocked the secrets of DNA

Robert McCrum

09, May, 2016 @4:45 AM

Article image
The Better Half: On the Genetic Superiority of Women review – bold study of chromosomal advantage
Sharon Moalem offers an intriguing theory on how two X chromosomes give women the edge in everything from colour vision to coronavirus

Gaia Vince

19, Apr, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Gene by Siddhartha Mukherjee review – intriguing and entertaining
Despite flaws, this lively and accessible history of the gene and its implications for the future is bursting with complex ideas

Robin McKie

06, Jun, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
The 100 best nonfiction books: No 10 – The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins
An intoxicating renewal of evolutionary theory that coined the idea of the meme and paved the way for Professor Dawkins’s later, more polemical works

Robert McCrum

04, Apr, 2016 @4:45 AM

Article image
Life’s Greatest Secret by Matthew Cobb review – a thrilling account of the DNA revolution
The historic race to crack life’s genetic code is revealed as a mixture of experiment, intuition and brilliant guesswork in Cobb’s authoritative study

Robin McKie

30, Jun, 2015 @5:30 AM

Article image
The Vital Question: Why Is Life the Way It Is? review – back to biological basics
Nick Lane’s masterful study of the fundamentals of life is both cutting-edge and accessible

Adam Rutherford

26, Apr, 2015 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Incredible Unlikeliness of Being review – a masterful account of why our bodies are the way they are

Alice Roberts combines embryology, genetics, anatomy, evolution and zoology to tell the incredible story of the human body, writes Adam Rutherford

Adam Rutherford

14, Sep, 2014 @8:00 AM

Article image
Wired for Culture by Mark Pagel; Beyond Human Nature by Jesse J Prinz; Together by Richard Sennett – review
Three studies investigate the origins and development of human culture and co-operation, writes Robin McKie

Robin McKie

11, Mar, 2012 @12:05 AM