Moriarty review – Anthony Horowitz steps into Conan Doyle’s shoes

A new super-criminal stalks Victorian London in a clever but contrived hymn to Sherlock Holmes’s nemesis

Professor James Moriarty is to crime fiction what Hamlet is to tragedy. Moriarty heads a roll call of archetypal villains that includes Karla, Goldfinger, Voldemort, Scudder and the Joker. His name commands instant respect as “the Napoleon of crime”. Among Sherlock Holmes addicts, he is the master sleuth’s nemesis, whose fatal intervention at the Reichenbach Falls was supposed to liberate his creator from the intolerable pressures of a mass readership.

Actually, like the devil in the Bible, his presence on the pages of Conan Doyle’s oeuvre is almost fleeting. Moriarty, in fact, features in only two of the Sherlock Holmes stories and was bumped off soon after his first appearance. But he remains irresistible to Conan Doyle’s heirs and imitators as the perfect, villainous counterpoint to the great detective. No surprise, then, that Anthony Horowitz has been lured into the marketplace to grapple with his memory. If Sherlock is box office, why shouldn’t Moriarty be equally lucrative?

There’s no doubt that we are in the company of a seasoned Conan Doyle ventriloquist. Just as Sebastian Faulks has lately revisited Wodehouse’s Jeeves and Wooster, so Horowitz has already paid homage to Conan Doyle’s popular storytelling genius. His The House of Silk (2011) was widely praised as the contemporary equal of its peerless original. But here, in Moriarty, he has set himself an escapist challenge that would stretch the resources of the most accomplished literary Houdini. To revisit Victorian London, in the months after the Reichenbach Falls disaster, with Holmes dead and Dr Watson absent, is to test narrative ingenuity to the limits of credibility.

Horowitz’s solution to the problem of the absent protagonist is threefold. First, he indulges his pleasure in scene-setting. Moriarty is replete, possibly overburdened, with lovingly researched period detail, the suffocating smoke, dust and fog of fin-de-siècle London, and the cigar-scented shadows of clubland, with its baize doors and uniformed servants. Second, he introduces an American dimension to the narrative. Hot from New York, Pinkerton agent Frederick Chase comes to London to join Sherlock Holmes wannabe inspector Athelney Jones of Scotland Yard in the quest for a “fiendish” new criminal mastermind who has filled the vacuum left by the untimely deaths of Holmes and Moriarty. And third, Horowitz comes up with a twist in the tale, “the truth of the matter”, which is clever but contrived, reducing the whole exercise to an elaborate, though highly entertaining, jape.

Suffice to say that the reality that Horowitz has taken such pains to establish is no such thing and that nothing is quite as it seems. The atmosphere of smoke and mirrors in which Moriarty winds up will doubtless enthral Sherlock fans, but runs the risk of leaving the general reader cold.

Moriarty is published by Orion (£19.99). Click here to buy it for £15.99


Robert McCrum

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Magpie Murders by Anthony Horowitz review – fiendish whodunnit
Horowitz channels Agatha Christie, with a rustic English setting, a tricksy book-within-a-book, and red herrings aplenty

Alison Flood

10, Dec, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
Moriarty by Anthony Horowitz – review
A sequel authorised by the Conan Doyle estate has the deduction and the action, but does it scratch the Holmesian itch? By Laura Miller

Laura Miller

22, Oct, 2014 @6:59 AM

Article image
Sherlock Holmes returns in new Anthony Horowitz book, Moriarty
'Does anyone believe what happened at the Reichenbach Falls?' reads the opening of novel sanctioned by Conan Doyle estate

Alison Flood

10, Apr, 2014 @2:07 PM

Article image
The House of Silk by Anthony Horowitz – review
Sherlock Holmes returns in the first new adventure to be officially approved by the Conan Doyle estate. But can Horowitz deliver, asks Ian Sansom

Ian Sansom

27, Oct, 2011 @9:00 AM

Article image
With a Mind to Kill by Anthony Horowitz review – 007 in a polished page-turner
Bond is headhunted by Smersh in a plot to eliminate the moderate Khrushchev in this rollicking Russian spy story

Alexander Larman

05, Jun, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
The 100 best novels: No 26 – The Sign of Four by Arthur Conan Doyle (1890)

Sherlock Holmes's second outing sees Conan Doyle's brilliant sleuth – and his bluff sidekick Watson – come into their own, writes Robert McCrum

Robert McCrum

17, Mar, 2014 @7:05 AM

Article image
Sherlock Holmes returns in official sequel by Anthony Horowitz

Alex Rider author on the case, at request of Conan Doyle estate

Benedicte Page

17, Jan, 2011 @3:35 PM

Article image
Houdini and Conan Doyle: Friends of Genius, Deadly Rivals by Christopher Sandford – review
The unlikely friendship between Houdini and Conan Doyle, and how it turned sour over matters supernatural, makes for a magnificently rich story, writes Olivia Laing

Olivia Laing

29, Oct, 2011 @11:05 PM

Article image
New Sherlock Holmes novel by Anthony Horowitz out in November

The House of Silk, written as tribute to Arthur Conan Doyle 81 years after his death, is narrated in first-person by Watson

Maev Kennedy

11, Apr, 2011 @11:03 PM

Article image
Book clinic: Which thrillers and crime fiction will keep my teenager hooked?
From Agatha Christie to Anthony Horowitz, writer Peter Swanson recommends the best of classic and modern

Peter Swanson

14, Mar, 2020 @6:00 PM