Spare us your misery, Orange prize judge tells authors

Daisy Goodwin says reading the 129 entries to this year's competition sometimes drove her to despair

To book lovers, it might appear to be a delicious, if demanding, treat – the opportunity to devour more than 100 novels by women writers and award one of them the prestigious Orange prize.

But the chair of this year's judging panel has launched a stinging criticism of the current "grim" crop of women's fiction – complaining that female authors appear to have suffered a collective sense of humour failure.

"There's not been much wit and not much joy, there's a lot of grimness out there," Daisy Goodwin, the author and TV producer, told the Guardian. "There are a lot of books about Asian sisters. There are a lot of books that start with a rape. Pleasure seems to have become a rather neglected element in publishing."

Reading the 129 entries to this year's competition had sometimes driven Goodwin to despair, she said, as she revealed this year's longlist. "I think the misery memoir has had its day, but there are an awful lot of books out there which had not a shred of redemption in them. I'm more of a light and shade person and there does need to be some joy, not just misery."

"I was surprised at how little I laughed … and the ones where there was humour were much appreciated I can tell you."

She accused publishers of "lagging behind what the public want", of not getting that readers do want pleasure and do want enjoyment when they read. "There comes a point halfway through the process where you think: 'Is it me or them?' You just can't bear it any more. And then you come across this joyful book."

Her frustrations aside, Goodwin said she and her fellow judges were proud of the 20-strong longlist, revealed today. She called it a "muscular" list, full of "pleasurable" and varied books. It includes some familiar books, notably Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall, which won the Man Booker, and Sarah Waters's The Little Stranger, which was shortlisted. Seven are longlisted for their debut novels – among them the film producer Rosie Alison, whose book The Very Thought of You has not had a single national newspaper review.

The other first novels are Eleanor Catton for The Rehearsal; Laila Lalami for Secret Son; Nadifa Mohamed for Black Mamba Boy; Amy Sackville for The Still Point; Kathryn Stockett for The Help and Attica Locke for Black Water Rising which represents a genre rarely seen at literary prizes – it's a thriller.

The former Orange winner Andrea Levy is longlisted for The Long Song and there are former shortlisted novelists in the form of Sadie Jones for Small Wars, Mantel, Waters and Barbara Kingsolver for The Lacuna. The most surprising omissions are probably the 2008 Orange winner Rose Tremain, not there for Trespass, as well as there being no Anne Michaels or Valerie Martin. The longlist is completed by Clare Clark, for Savage Lands; Amanda Craig for Hearts and Minds; Roopa Farooki for The Way Things Look to Me; Rebecca Gowers for The Twisted Heart; MJ Hyland for This is How; Maria McCann for The Wilding; Lorrie Moore for A Gate at the Stairs; and Monique Roffey for The Woman on the Green Bicycle.

The judges, who also include Julia Neuberger, Michele Roberts, Miranda Sawyer and Alexandra Shulman, will announce a shortlist on 20 April.


Mark Brown, arts correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Orange Prize: Women authors can lighten up and still be taken seriously

When Daisy Goodwin complained of too much 'grimness' in this year's list, she was lambasted. She should have been applauded

William Skidelsky

21, Mar, 2010 @12:07 AM

Article image
Barbara Kingsolver's The Lacuna beats Wolf Hall to Orange prize

American novelist's epic novel holds off Man Booker winner Hilary Mantel to take £30,000 Orange prize for fiction

Mark Brown, arts correspondent

09, Jun, 2010 @7:37 PM

Article image
Orange prize longlist tackles difficult subjects – and alligators
The 20 novels on the longlist for this year's Orange prize for fiction deal with challenging issues 'with incredible sensitivity', say judges

Mark Brown

16, Mar, 2011 @12:05 AM

Article image
Orange prize shortlist pits Mantel against debut novelists

Last year's Man Booker winner, Wolf Hall, leads shortlist alongside two first-time authors

Mark Brown, arts correspondent

20, Apr, 2010 @8:49 AM

Article image
I'm an Orange prize convert – for all the wrong reasons
Jean Hannah Edelstein: Women writers are failing as much as ever to win the recognition they deserve, so they need the publicity the award brings

Jean Hannah Edelstein

16, Mar, 2011 @3:38 PM

Article image
Taking the Orange at second bite

• Zadie Smith's On Beauty wins £30,000 fiction prize

• Judges pay tribute to 'a literary tour de force'

John Ezard

07, Jun, 2006 @10:02 AM

Letter: Orange prize trouble
Letter: If fiction written by women is every bit as vital, challenging and, well, good as fiction written by men – and it is – is the cause of female writers not hindered by the existence of an award which every year gives a prize to Best Book By a Girl?

06, Sep, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
Orange prize 'grimness' is not the fault of women novelists

Jean Hannah Edelstein: Daisy Goodwin's complaints about the supposed joylessness of Orange prize contenders might have been better directed at publishers

Jean Hannah Edelstein

18, Mar, 2010 @12:00 PM

New novelists lead Orange prize shortlist

Fiction award features books by five white writers from UK and North America

Charlotte Higgins, arts correspondent

16, Apr, 2008 @7:58 AM

Article image
American authors dominate Orange fiction longlist

Many novels nominated for the Orange prize for fiction deal with themes of exile and migration

Mark Brown, arts correspondent

18, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM