Commonwealth rent assistance has no effect on Australia’s housing affordability, Anglicare says

Report finds that not only is CRA inadequate in alleviating rental stress, but that the way it’s calculated neglects those most in need

An increase in commonwealth rent assistance has been mooted as a budget measure to ease the housing crisis for those on lower incomes, but Anglicare Australia has warned the payment is not “fit for purpose” and has no effect on affordability.

As a result of the way the payment is designed, rental assistance payments for nearly 300,000 people may have fallen this year as a direct consequence of the cost of living going up.

“This payment isn’t really fit for purpose,” said Anglicare Australia’s chief executive Kasy Chambers. “Things have changed since it came in. It’s not doing what it’s designed to do. We’re spending more and more on it, but it’s not having any effect on affordability.”

About 1.5 million low-income earners whose rent is above a certain level are entitled to commonwealth rent assistance (CRA). That minimum rent level, known as the “cut-in” rate, is adjusted twice a year to account for changes in the cost of living. The latest increase, in March, took it from $135.40 a fortnight to $140.40 for a single person with no children. CRA pays 75c in the dollar only for the amount of rent paid above that level, up to a maximum now set at $350 a fortnight (up from $337.54 in March).

The people most likely to find their payments reduced by indexation are those who receive a partial CRA payment – those whose rent does not reach the maximum amount. At the end of December 2022, there were 296,470 people in that position.

Before March, someone paying $300 a fortnight in rent was eligible for $123.45 in CRA (75% of the difference between $135.40 and $300), but after the cut-in rate went up that fell to $119.70 (75% of the difference between $140.40 and $300).

In a report on CRA in January, Anglicare found that the way the cut-in rate worked resulted in greatly reduced access to the payment, making it inequitable for people on lower incomes, and “the indexation of the payment and these thresholds means this inequity is maintained year on year”.

Anglicare found a single person on youth allowance would need to spend a third of their income on rent – pushing them into rental stress – before they became eligible for CRA. Someone on the more generous age pension, however, would be able to receive assistance after only spending 14% of their income on rent.

Kristin O’Connell of the Antipoverty Centre also criticised the way the CRA worked.

“When we talk about inequity, there’s a book to be written on rent assistance,” she said.

“If you have the ‘good fortune’ to be paying enough rent that you can qualify for rent assistance, every time the indexation comes around you lose a little bit of that payment. Until you have the ‘good fortune’ to be paying so much rent that you’re above the maximum.”

Services Australia and the Department of Social Services would not say how many CRA recipients had their payments reduced as a consequence of the CPI increase, saying the data was not readily available.

A spokesperson from the Department of Social Services said CRA recipients “generally get more rent assistance over time as rents increase”, which was “demonstrated by increases in average and median amounts CRA recipients have received over time”.

The Anglicare report noted that only one in three people on jobseeker and one in 10 on youth allowance were eligible for CRA, and only one in four people on income support payments received it.

CRA is also badly designed for those in share-houses, the report found, as it requires all recipients to be on the lease agreement and cuts out when rent is more than $280 a fortnight – about $20 less than the rent for the average share-house room in a major Australian city, excluding bills.

The report argued that advocacy on CRA should focus on expanding access to support – for example, removing the cut-in rate – not simply raising the amount available for those who are already eligible.

But Chambers said Anglicare’s primary concern was the inadequacy of welfare payments.

The treasurer, Jim Chalmers, has promised cost-of-living relief in the budget, and has come under pressure from Labor backbenchers, other politicians, advocates, academics, business leaders and its own economic inclusion committee to increase the rate of jobseeker across the board.

Chambers said she was concerned that the government might consider raising CRA “as a proxy way to raise jobseeker”, even though CRA does not help the vast majority of people on welfare payments or address “the fundamental issue that those [welfare] payments are too little”.

“It’s an inadequate way to address the poverty situation because it isn’t raising anyone out of rental stress,” Chambers said. “We’ve never spent more on CRA and yet housing has never been more unaffordable.”

The Anti-Poverty Centre wants to see jobseeker rates raised to the Henderson poverty line of $88 a day.

“Giving people an adequate welfare payment will alleviate all of these problems that we’re facing in our lives at a time when you’re most in need of having less stress,” O’Connell said.


Stephanie Convery

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australia’s rental affordability drops to worst levels in nearly a decade
New report shows average households are spending a third of income on rent while lower income families pay more than half their earnings

Mostafa Rachwani and Guardian staff

28, May, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Low-income tenants hardest hit as Australian rent rises outstrip assistance payments
House rentals have risen by an average of 13.8% in capital cities and 20.2% for all rentals in regions compared with a 4.5% increase in rent assistance

Stephanie Convery

26, Apr, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Australian renters face surging costs after end of national affordability scheme
‘It’s quite frightening,’ says a tenant who lost her rent subsidy. As debate stalls over the housing future fund, she’s not the only one who’s frustrated

Stephanie Convery

30, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Rental affordability worst ever seen for minimum wage earners, Anglicare says
In annual snapshot less than 1% of listings were affordable for renters earning minimum wage and only four rooms in share houses for those on jobseeker

Cait Kelly

26, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Refurbishing not demolishing Port Melbourne public housing estate could save Victoria $88m, study finds
A not-for-profit firm has found building could be added to Barak Beacon estate and residents wouldn’t be forced to relocate

Stephanie Convery

01, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Albanese government urged to increase rent assistance and childcare workers’ pay in budget
Labor downplays delivering on women’s taskforce wishlist all at once but promises to ‘build upon’ investments in future budgets

Paul Karp Chief political correspondent

18, Apr, 2023 @8:53 PM

Article image
Build to rent? The Melbourne apartments where a third of tenants are being kicked out or getting rent hikes
After only a year in their new Fitzroy homes, some tenants say they are being forced to leave with no explanation. Advocates say it shows there are still holes in rental laws

Cait Kelly Inequality reporter

11, Nov, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
Could rent controls ease Australia’s housing crisis?
Advocates say caps or freezes may help reduce pressure on renters but experts warn they are not a simple fix

Elias Visontay Urban affairs reporter

27, Jun, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
‘Housing in Australia is broken’: only 1.6% of private rentals are affordable for those on minimum wage
Anglicare’s annual snapshot calls for 50% rise in rent assistance payments, more social housing and changes to tax system

Stephanie Convery

27, Apr, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Victorians lodge record 5,400 challenges to rent increases over past 12 months
Consumer Affairs Victoria says it redirected extra staff to manage 120% rise in requests for rent increase reviews

Cait Kelly Inequality reporter

01, Nov, 2023 @6:41 AM