Australia’s child abuse redress scheme will be opened to prisoners in recognition of trauma’s impact

In response to damning review, government says program will become ‘more trauma informed and survivor focused’

The child abuse national redress scheme will be opened up to applicants who are behind bars, after experts criticised its failure to recognise the nexus between profound childhood trauma and offending.

The Australian and state and territory governments on Thursday belatedly released their final response to a damning review of the redress scheme, following delays by successive federal governments.

The response commits to an overhaul of the redress scheme to simplify its processes, ensure more sensitive and appropriate handling of abuse survivors and applications, and expand its eligibility criteria.

The changes remove the current barrier on prisoners applying for redress.

The current rules, which only allow prisoners to apply where the scheme operator deems there to be “exceptional circumstances”, have been frequently criticised by advocacy groups, who say they create classes of deserving and undeserving abuse survivors and fail to recognise the clear connection between long-lasting trauma and criminality.

The March 2021 review, conducted by the respected public servant Robyn Kruk, expressed “significant and immediate concern” about the restrictions.

“The review heard the restrictions on prisoners potentially deny individuals who were the subject of institutional child sexual abuse the opportunity to apply for redress,” Kruk wrote.

“The restrictions are confusing and poorly understood and appear to be deterring eligible applicants from applying. This has a differentially adverse impact on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander survivors.”

The government’s final response accepted the criticism and said it would expand the eligibility criteria.

“This change will give prisoners the choice to apply for redress while in gaol or wait to apply upon release from gaol, making the scheme more trauma informed and survivor focused,” the government’s response to the inquiry says.

“The Australian government is working with state and territory partners to ensure that people in gaol are adequately supported in applying to the scheme and to ensure appropriate survivor privacy and safety.”

It will also remove the current special assessment process designed for applicants with most serious criminal convictions, though it will remain for what the review describes as “particularly serious offences (such as homicide and sexual offences) or where there may be a risk to the integrity of the scheme”.

The changes will also allow former child migrants to make applications, regardless of whether they have citizenship or permanent residency status.

The current scheme prohibits non-citizens or those without permanent residency from applying.

“Former child migrants are a group of survivors known to be currently affected by the citizenship and residency criteria,” the government’s response says.

“All governments have agreed to consider other noncitizen and non-permanent resident groups in relation to this recommendation.”

Advocates largely welcomed the belated response to the review.

The Blue Knot Foundation’s president, Dr Cathy Kezelman, said changes to simplify and streamline the process must be acted upon without delay, and in a way that is informed by survivors.

“It is disturbing that we are five years into a 10-year scheme, and are still making substantive changes, and are only now responding to recommendations from the second-year review,” Kezelman said.

“The enhanced processing for survivors with criminal convictions, or who are incarcerated, acknowledges the possible relationship between the trauma of child sexual abuse and not only revictimisation, but also sometimes perpetration of a range of crimes.”

People with Disability Australia (PWDA) welcomed the changes and said the response was promising. PWDA president Nicole Lee said governments must act quickly to implement the changes.

Contributor

Christopher Knaus

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Backlog of claims in Australia’s child abuse redress scheme more than doubles in two years
Advocates concerned for the elderly, ill and dying renew calls for an urgent reset, streamlining processes while maintaining sensitivity

Christopher Knaus

03, Nov, 2022 @11:00 PM

Article image
Australia’s child abuse redress scheme case backlog almost doubles in 10 months
Influx comes after online application process simplified – but it is sparking calls for more funding to cut survivors’ wait times

Christopher Knaus

18, Oct, 2023 @12:14 AM

Article image
Legal advice says inquiry into child sex abuse can examine Nauru regime
Human rights groups contradict Coalition’s claim that responsibility for abuse lies with Nauraun government and say royal commission can look at abuse allegations

Ben Doherty and Paul Farrell

12, Aug, 2016 @2:29 AM

Article image
Dozens of child abuse claims remain from organisations refusing to sign on to national redress scheme
One organisation named by the government has labelled the redress scheme a ‘scam’

Michael McGowan

27, Nov, 2020 @7:00 PM

Article image
Federal government ‘dragging its heels’ on child abuse redress scheme
Victoria says the government is keeping survivors in the dark as they await further detail on how scheme would work

Christopher Knaus

23, Nov, 2016 @9:50 PM

Article image
Child sexual abuse redress scheme 'creates deserving and undeserving survivors'
Sex assault counsellors tell Senate inquiry that convicted criminals should not be excluded from compensation

Christopher Knaus

16, Feb, 2018 @2:03 AM

Article image
Child abuse redress scheme would exclude offshore detention victims, lawyers say
Exclusive: Turnbull government says compensation should not be available to those who are not citizens or permanent residents

Christopher Knaus

06, Feb, 2018 @8:13 PM

Article image
Catholic church signs up to redress scheme for child abuse victims
‘Survivors deserve justice and healing’, says spokesman

Melissa Davey

30, May, 2018 @6:37 AM

Article image
NSW and Victoria to join national child sexual abuse redress scheme
Malcolm Turnbull urges other states to join scheme recommended by child abuse royal commission

Christopher Knaus

08, Mar, 2018 @5:01 PM

Article image
Pleas for urgent reset of Australia’s child abuse redress scheme unanswered 18 months after damning review
Coalition committed to respond in ‘early 2022’ but failed to do so, while Labor has not issued a full response since taking office

Christopher Knaus

23, Sep, 2022 @12:00 AM