Voice to parliament no campaign to push for recognition of migrants as well as Indigenous people

Warren Mundine says no campaign will propose a new referendum on an acknowledgment in the preamble of the constitution

The no campaign in this year’s voice referendum will propose a symbolic constitutional recognition of both Indigenous people and migrants, instead of an Indigenous voice to parliament, Warren Mundine has revealed.

Mundine, a leading organiser of the no campaign, said it will run on a slogan of “recognise a better way”, proposing to insert an acknowledgment in the preamble of the constitution, via another referendum.

This approach was previously rejected by multiple rounds of consultation including the 2017 Uluru statement from the heart, which called for a voice to parliament.

With the yes campaign due to launch with a week of grassroots action from 20 February, the no campaign is gaining support from rightwing organisations Advance Australia and the Conservative Political Action Conference Australia for a campaign to launch in late February or early March.

On Sunday Mundine said he was bringing together opposition groups as head of Recognise a Better Way and the president of the Voice No Committee, of which former deputy prime minister John Anderson is also a member.

Mundine, a Yuin, Bundjalung and Gumbaynggirr man, was the national Labor president but quit the party in 2012, contesting the seat of Gilmore in 2019 for the Liberals.

In a sign the campaign will aim to pit culturally and linguistically diverse voters against the voice, Mundine said “we’re talking with the migrant community as well”.

“It’s about recognition of all the people who have come to Australia, who have been here first and how we built this great country of ours.”

Asked if this would include recognition of migrants in the constitution, Mundine said “migrants and refugees who have come here – recognise their story, about the circumstances of how they’ve come here and their contribution to Australia”.

“People have escaped from some horrific situations overseas, come to Australia and built an incredible life for themselves and their families.”

The Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia (Fecca) supports the Uluru statement from the heart and its call for the establishment of a First Nations voice protected by the constitution.

In 2015 nine culturally and linguistically diverse organisations, including Fecca, joined forces to declare their support for the recognition of Australia’s first peoples in the constitution and have never sought an equivalent constitutional change for multicultural communities.

Mundine rejected the suggestion that adding the migrant experience to the constitution was an attempt to set them against the advancement of First Nations rights.

“No, I see it as bringing people together,” he said.

“I believe that we can and will have another referendum,” he added, citing an earlier attempt by John Howard and Democrats senator Aden Ridgeway to add a preamble in 1999.

“Myself and many other people do want to have recognition in the constitution but we don’t believe [the voice to parliament] is the right way to do it.”

Howard and fellow former Liberal prime minister Tony Abbott have both backed recognition through symbolic words rather than a voice to parliament.

The opposition leader, Peter Dutton, has said he supports constitutional recognition but has demanded more details about the voice from the Albanese government.

Mundine argued that Indigenous Australians need “more than recognition”; they needed the government to tackle “strong social problems” in their communities.

Asked how a preamble would help, Mundine cited the “US constitution’s” rhetorical statement that “all men are created equal”, which the civil rights movement used to demand equal treatment. The statement is, in fact, contained in that country’s declaration of independence from Britain.

The Albanese government is seeking bipartisan support for the voice, inviting Dutton and the shadow Indigenous affairs minister, Julian Leeser, to attend the constitutional working group developing detail for the referendum early in February.

Earlier on Sunday the Nationals leader, David Littleproud, explained that his party opposes the voice because “another layer of bureaucracy will not fix [or] close the gap for Indigenous Australians”.

Littleproud told Sky News that bureaucrats should be sent to Indigenous communities “to come up with solutions to close the gap” rather than “sending Indigenous Australians to Canberra”.


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Voice to parliament yes campaign launches with pledge to take conversation to the people
Hundreds of advocates meet on Kaurna land in Adelaide to workshop referendum strategies

Tory Shepherd

23, Feb, 2023 @10:04 AM

Article image
Indigenous voice: no campaign event reinforced ‘racist stereotypes’, watchdog says
Gomeroi traditional owners fear more ‘divisive’ meetings after event attended by rightwing politicians attracted widespread condemnation

Sarah Collard, Josh Butler and Lorena Allam

04, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Coalition playing ‘spoiling game’ with Indigenous voice to parliament, Noel Pearson warns
First Nations leader concerned opposition’s calls for more details on referendum is a diversion that threatens chance for reconciliation

Lorena Allam Indigenous affairs editor

23, Jan, 2023 @2:15 AM

Article image
Shaquille O’Neal meets with PM in support of Indigenous voice to parliament
Anthony Albanese announces the NBA legend will be part of the effort to mobilise support in the lead-up to a referendum

Natasha May

27, Aug, 2022 @6:53 AM

Article image
Kerry O’Brien gives impassioned defence of Indigenous voice to parliament at hearing
Former ABC journalist tells joint select committee on voice wording that it is a ‘simple and unambitious and unthreatening’ proposal

Lorena Allam

14, Apr, 2023 @4:36 AM

Article image
NRL joins growing number of sporting codes backing Indigenous voice to parliament
Major Australian sporting organisations expected to play a significant role in the yes campaign, with AFL and Cricket Australia yet to announce a stance

Josh Butler and Mike Hytner

09, May, 2023 @4:48 AM

Article image
Marcia Langton attacks ‘relentless scare campaign’ waged by opponents of Indigenous voice
Comments from design group co-chair come after NT’s Country Liberal president announced resignation over party’s opposition to voice

Lorena Allam Indigenous affairs editor

13, Mar, 2023 @6:52 AM

Article image
PM, state and territory leaders formally back Indigenous voice to parliament with statement of intent
National cabinet officially signed on to commitment with Albanese saying priority is to secure a successful referendum in second half of this year

Lorena Allam and Sarah Collard

03, Feb, 2023 @2:50 AM

Article image
How would an Indigenous voice work and what are people saying about it?
In press conference with NBA superstar Shaquille O’Neal, PM reveals he has been talking with sporting figures about supporting campaign

Lorena Allam Indigenous affairs editor

27, Aug, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Referendum on Indigenous voice to parliament a ‘complete waste’ of money, Lidia Thorpe says
Greens senator wants treaty progress first while NT senator Jacinta Price says there’s ‘no way’ she can support Labor’s proposal

Sarah Collard

01, Sep, 2022 @7:26 AM