Australia risks UN human rights blacklisting as states fail to meet prison obligations

Deadline to meet anti-torture treaty obligations is Friday, but governments have yet to install watchdogs

Australia risks being placed on a human rights blacklist alongside such countries as South Sudan and the Democratic Republic of the Congo by failing to meet its obligations in prison oversight under a UN anti-torture treaty.

The UN’s Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture (Opcat) was ratified under the Turnbull government in December 2017, but Australia has since requested two deadline extensions to meet its obligations.

The failure to meet the obligations by Friday means a UN subcommittee could place Australia on a non-compliance list, alongside 14 other countries.

Australia’s human rights commissioner, Lorraine Finlay, said such a failure could affect the country’s human rights credibility on the world stage.

“We voluntarily entered into this treaty,” she told Guardian Australia.

“We freely made promises around this treaty and if we’re not going to live up to those promises, that sends a really bad signal to the rest of the world about not only Australia’s approach to human rights, but Australia’s role in terms of the rules-based international system.”

A core part of the Opcat requires each jurisdiction to establish independent bodies – called national preventive mechanisms – to act as watchdogs that inspect prisons and other places of detention, such as youth justice facilities, police cells and mental health institutions. These bodies monitor human rights issues and make recommendations.

Human rights advocates have pointed to the abuse in youth detention centres, the over representation of First Nations people in the criminal justice system and deaths in custody, and the use of practices such as solitary confinement in prisons as examples of why scrutiny is vital.

But Australia’s three most populous states – New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland – are yet to designate their independent oversight bodies – and say they are unable to meet their Opcat obligations without federal government funding.

At a meeting of the nation’s attorneys general in December, the states and territories agreed to provide the federal government with the costings to establish oversight bodies.

Spokespeople for the Victorian and Queensland governments said discussions with the commonwealth were ongoing. A spokesperson for the NSW attorney general said the government had provided the commonwealth with anticipated funding requirement to set up the oversight body and was awaiting an outcome.

Tasmania, South Australia, Western Australia, the Northern Territory and the Australian Capital Territory have implemented interim or final measures to allow bodies to monitor conditions in places of detention.

Finlay said regardless of funding issues, all governments had a “basic obligation” to prevent human rights abuses of people in detention.

Alice Edwards, the UN special papporteur on torture, said watchdogs were not a “new phenomena”.

“We know, from the long history in the fight against torture, that these bodies – that visit spontaneously or regularly and are able to speak to detainees, are able to taste the food, are able to look at the conditions of the cells – are all geared towards preventing torture and other ill-treatment,” she said.

In October the UN subcommittee on the prevention of torture abandoned its trip to Australia after the NSW government blocked officials from inspecting its prisons. Queensland also refused access to mental health facilities but has since passed legislation that will allow UN officials to conduct visits.

The delegation had planned to conduct surprise visits to state, territory and commonwealth prisons facilities during its tour.

Under the treaty states and territories must allow the committee to visit places of detention. The subcommittee will meet next month to discuss resuming the visit.

The treaty was signed by Australia after the royal commission into juvenile detention in the NT, sparked by revelations of abuses at the Don Dale youth detention centre.


Adeshola Ore

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UN accuses Australia of ‘clear breach’ of human rights obligations as it suspends tour of detention facilities
New South Wales and Queensland have blocked access to some facilities with NSW corrections minister saying people can’t just ‘wander through at their leisure’

Tamsin Rose

23, Oct, 2022 @7:41 AM

Article image
Queensland’s plan to override human rights law ‘deeply concerning’, commissioner says
Scott McDougall alarmed at Palaszczuk government plan to make breach of bail an offence for children

Ben Smee

21, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Human Rights Act could be critical in divisive Queensland youth bail case
Palaszczuk government’s 2019 laws to be weighed against underlying principles of human rights

Ben Smee

14, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Failure to allow full UN prison inspections risks Australia’s international standing, experts say
Australia joins Azerbaijan, Rwanda and Ukraine among nations to fail to provide full access after ratifying agreement

Tamsin Rose

24, Oct, 2022 @7:35 AM

Article image
Queensland to change laws that prevented UN inspectors entering mental health wards
Annastacia Palaszczuk says the restrictions will be removed this year to comply with Opcat treaty

Eden Gillespie

26, Oct, 2022 @4:18 AM

Article image
NSW’s refusal to allow UN inspectors in prisons ‘raises questions’, human rights commissioner says
Lorraine Finlay says state government’s decision means Australia is ‘failing to live up to the promises it made to the world’

Tamsin Rose

17, Oct, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Queensland committee backs overriding human rights for new youth laws as striking ‘appropriate balance’
Changes ‘justified’ in light of public anxiety and despite some provisions being incompatible with rights act

Eden Gillespie

10, Mar, 2023 @3:10 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull warns NSW and Queensland of ‘company they’re keeping’ by blocking UN prison inspectors
Former prime minister disappointed by states’ decisions to not allow full access to UN subcommittee on prevention of torture

Tamsin Rose and Eden Gillespie

20, Oct, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Melbourne to hit 38C and western Sydney 35C as heatwave sweeps parts of Australia
Very warm weather conditions will extend across southern areas and linger until next week, Bureau of Meteorology says

Caitlin Cassidy and Sarah Collard

16, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Victorian government must overhaul bail laws to create ‘meaningful’ change, legal groups say
Advocates concerned after Daniel Andrews suggested looking at offence types rather than scrapping controversial 2018 changes

Benita Kolovos

09, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM