Guardian Essential poll: most think RBA rate hikes an overreaction as shine comes off Albanese

Majority believe government at least partially to blame for rises but don’t assume Coalition would manage them better

A majority of voters believe the Reserve Bank of Australia has overreacted in jacking up interest rates to tame inflation, and people worry economic conditions will get worse over the next 12 months, according to the latest Guardian Essential poll.

The latest survey of 1,044 voters demonstrates cost-of-living pressure is starting to bite in the community after nine consecutive cash rate hikes.

The Albanese government is also in the frame. A majority of respondents (71%) think the federal government wears either some or a lot of culpability when it comes to rising interest rates. Only 16% of respondents feel the government bears hardly any responsibility for rising borrowing costs (13% of respondents are unsure).

Voter approval of Anthony Albanese has also come off last year’s post-election highs.

While the prime minister retains majority approval, last November 60% of respondents said they approved of the prime minister’s performance. That’s come down to 53% in the latest fortnightly survey. Voter disapproval has also crept up, with 34% unhappy, compared with 27% last November.

But people believe there are numerous external triggers for the RBA’s aggressive tightening in monetary policy.

Guardian Essential respondents identify high consumer prices (86% say prices have contributed a lot or a fair amount to rate rises), supply chain disruptions triggered by the pandemic (76%), an “overreaction” by the central bank (69%) and the war in Ukraine (59%) as significant inputs.

Voters are not identifying wages as a significant contributing factor. While there has been public debate about the potential risks of a wage-price spiral, only 38% of Guardian Essential poll respondents consider that a factor in the current interest rate hikes (48% say wages has hardly any or no impact).

While the strain of sustained high inflation is causing anxiety, voters haven’t defaulted to assuming the Coalition would do a better job of managing rising interest rates (29% of respondents say Labor will do a better job, 29% say Coalition and 42% say there’s no difference).

This is unusual because the Coalition often enjoys higher voter favourability in polls on metrics of economic management.

The Liberal leader, Peter Dutton, plans to put cost-of-living pressure front and centre of a looming byelection campaign in the Victorian seat of Aston triggered by the retirement of controversial former frontbencher Alan Tudge. The electorate of Aston is situated in commuter country in the eastern suburbs of Melbourne.

The latest poll suggests voter perceptions about who is best placed to manage rising interest rates differs depending on whether people are mortgage holders, property owners or renters.

Poll respondents with home loans say Labor is better than the Coalition at managing rates (33% to 28%, with 39% saying it makes no difference). Renters feel similarly (34% to 22%, with 44% saying it makes no difference), while people who own their homes outright believe the Coalition would do a better job (36% to 22%, with 42% saying it makes no difference).

Labor is also ahead of the Coalition when it comes to who voters trust to deliver cost-of-living relief (36% prefer Labor, 28% say Coalition and 36% say it makes no difference). Respondents with mortgages and renters again ranked Labor ahead of the Coalition on this metric, and homeowners put the Coalition ahead.

Labor is also continuing to exhibit higher voter satisfaction in areas of traditional policy strength – improving public services, managing climate change and reversing the trend towards insecure work.

The deterioration in people’s sense of financial security as we move into the first quarter of 2023 can be mapped by comparing sentiment in the latest fortnightly survey with sentiment a month after last year’s federal election.

A majority of respondents currently report they are either struggling a bit in the current environment (40%) or in difficulty to the point where paying regular bills has become a concern (12%). Last June, 31% reported struggling a bit and 7% identified bill paying as a regular concern.

Only 19% of respondents predict economic conditions will improve in the next 12 months (last June 32% of respondents expressed that optimism), and 56% say things will get worse (compared to 40% last June).

But the data does reveal two distinct experiences. Not everybody is battling in the high inflation environment. In the latest survey, 47% of respondents report feeling comfortable or secure. While just over half the sample, 51%, say rising interest rate has a negative impact on them, 17% report the impact as positive.

The RBA’s record run of rate hikes – combined with a public signal that there will be more to come – has triggered an unusual political backlash. The central bank governor, Philip Lowe, used two appearances before parliamentary committees in Canberra last week to defend the bank’s decision-making.

The treasurer, Jim Chalmers, while pointing to the independence of the RBA, has argued the bank and the governor need to be accountable for decision-making.


Katharine Murphy Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: Australians back jobseeker increase and look to budget for cost-of-living relief
Poll also suggests honeymoon glow has not worn off Anthony Albanese as support for Peter Dutton continues to slide

Paul Karp Chief political correspondent

01, May, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: Albanese approval rating dips in sign of gruelling political year ahead
Prime minister’s lowest result since last August doesn’t necessarily mean the end of government’s post-election honeymoon

Katharine Murphy Political editor

23, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Essential poll: three-quarters of voters believe cost-of-living crisis will worsen but majority give Albanese thumbs up
More than 60% also say they support the Indigenous voice to parliament, with the Liberal party at risk of alienating younger voters if it backs the Nationals’ position

Katharine Murphy Political editor

12, Dec, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: 70% of people want price caps on essential services such as energy
Most want more government intervention in ‘broken’ Australian economy with support also strong for windfall profits tax

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

22, Aug, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Sydney trains delayed due to ‘communication issue’ – as it happened
This blog is now closed.

Mostafa Rachwani and Amy Remeikis and Martin Farrer (earlier)

08, Mar, 2023 @7:44 AM

Article image
McKim calls for Lowe to stand down – as it happened
This blog is now closed

Josh Taylor and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

06, Sep, 2022 @8:46 AM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: Anthony Albanese heading to the holidays on a high note
Survey shows voter disapproval of Peter Dutton remains 10 points higher than for the prime minister

Katharine Murphy Political editor

28, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: two-thirds of voters back intervention in energy market as power prices soar
Survey after Jim Chalmers’ first budget suggests people pessimistic about economic outlook amid cost-of-living pressures

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

31, Oct, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Rising interest rates may be Labor’s kryptonite – but remember it never ended up killing Superman | Peter Lewis
Are the Reserve Bank’s decisions to keep hiking the cash rate damaging the Albanese government’s economic credentials?

Peter Lewis

21, Feb, 2023 @1:15 AM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: support for Aukus and Indigenous voice declines
Anthony Albanese improves in personal measures, including honesty and vision, despite waning support for major policies

Paul Karp Chief political correspondent

20, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM