Labor told it must meet ‘fundamental test’ of character on poker machine reform

Party is under pressure on gambling measures after NSW Coalition announced cashless gaming scheme

The federal independent MP Andrew Wilkie has declared gambling reform as a “fundamental test” of character for Labor as pressure mounts on the party at the state and federal level to follow the New South Wales Coalition in committing to action on poker machines.

The Perrottet government has unveiled a $344m plan to switch the state to cashless poker machines over the next five years – a move that has been resisted by the state’s Labor leader, Chris Minns, who has only committed to a limited trial.

The prime minister, Anthony Albanese, refused to weigh in on the issue on Tuesday, saying it was a matter for the states, as advocates call for a federal intervention.

Wilkie said he planned to travel to Sydney before the March state election and would be “seeking opportunities to speak up”, a decade after the then prime minister Julia Gillard backed out of substantive changes in the space.

“I see poker machine reform at this state election as much more than just about poker machines. I see it as a fundamental test of the character of the major political parties and it’s a test that Mr Minns will fail if he doesn’t get on board,” Wilkie told Guardian Australia.

In question time on Tuesday the Tasmanian independent asked Albanese if he would seize the momentum for reform, to which the prime minister replied that everyone “knows the damage that problem gambling can cause”, but that it was a state responsibility.

“We recognise there is more work to do,” he said.

Wilkie wants to see the prime minister intervene and ask all premiers and chief ministers to “harmonise” harm minimisation methods or enact more forceful regulation, including using tax powers, the Corporations Act or money laundering laws.

On Monday Tim Costello, the Alliance for Gambling Reform’s chief advocate, called on Albanese to lead reform and to pressure Minns to match Perrottet’s plan to introduce mandatory cashless gaming.

Minns has backed a handful of the measures, including a ban on VIP signage outside venues, a statewide exclusion register and banning political donations from pubs and clubs.

But he has refused to commit to universal cashless gaming.

“I’m not saying we’re against it. If it works, we will do it but we want to make sure the technology is in place,” he said.

Senior NSW Labor figures have told the Guardian they were not opposed to dealing with problem gambling in some form, but felt they did not need to make a bigger commitment ahead of the election because it wasn’t a vote-winning issue.

“People are talking about education, the cost of living,” one ministerial hopeful said.

That attitude was dismissed as highly cynical and disappointing by federal independent MP Dai Le, who said Labor needed to do what was right, rather than what would win votes.

“That’s really not understanding the community that they seek to represent,” she said, while calling on federal Labor MPs from western Sydney to “develop a piece of policy that would assist their constituents”.

Gambling researcher Dr Charles Livingstone believes the federal government has many levers to pull if it is serious about protecting constituents in Labor’s western Sydney heartland, where problem gambling is rife.

He said the federal government could introduce and regulate a national pre-commitment system or could explore consumer protection frameworks, as it has for online gambling.

“If you’ve got a government which is concerned about social equity and is tolerating this sort of massive source of social inequity in its heartland, then you’ve got to start asking questions about where their hearts really lie,” he said.

Perrottet pushed the reforms through cabinet after a damning report from the NSW Crime Commission last year found billions of dollars of dirty money was cycling through poker machines each year.

In Victoria, similar allegations of money laundering were made during the Finkelstein royal commission into Crown Casino, after which the state government passed legislation that included a $1,000 daily cash limit at the venue.

The Victorian premier, Daniel Andrews, on Tuesday said he “wouldn’t rule out” further changes and said the government’s focus was the “small percentage of the community” that were problem gamblers.

The Victorian Coalition said it had no plans to match its NSW counterparts.


Tamsin Rose and Benita Kolovos

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Can poker machine reform save Dominic Perrottet from polls suggesting he’ll lose power in NSW?
After 12 years in power the Coalition has an uphill fight, say analysts, with a hung parliament a possibility

Michael McGowan

10, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Dominic Perrottet gambles on poker machine reform as a vote winner
Not long ago it would have been political suicide to adopt measures so strongly opposed by ClubsNSW – but time will tell how it plays out at the polls

Michael McGowan

06, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
NSW Labor promises to ban political donations from clubs amid fight over poker machines
Opposition leader Chris Minns pledges to reduce number of machines as Dominic Perrottet hits out at Bob Carr

Michael McGowan

16, Jan, 2023 @3:10 AM

Article image
NSW Labor’s moves on poker machine reform renew pressure on Dominic Perrottet, experts say
Call for detail on proposed cashless gaming scheme as questions raised about opposition’s pledge

Michael McGowan

16, Jan, 2023 @7:48 AM

Article image
NSW treasurer refuses to say if $1,000 a day pokies spending cap is too high as he ridicules Labor policy
Key independent MP calls for a $100 daily limit as Coalition comes under pressure to release details of its cashless gaming card

Michael McGowan

17, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
NSW Labor to join Dylan Alcott in public sector disability jobs drive if elected
Exclusive: Chris Minns will commit to target of 5.6% of public sector jobs held by people with disability through deal with former Australian of the year

Michael McGowan

23, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
NSW Labor criticised for directing preferences to Shooters party in key seats
Opposition says decision in regional electorates made to contain potential influence of One Nation’s Mark Latham

Michael McGowan

14, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Dominic Perrottet on poking the ClubsNSW beast: ‘I didn’t start with many friends’
The NSW premier explains why he put his career on the line as the days count down to the state election

Michael McGowan

19, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
NSW unions to declare start of new six-month campaign to remove Coalition government
Unions NSW to release survey results suggesting voters believe healthcare and transport are worsening

Tamsin Rose

14, Oct, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Horses, housing and LGBTQ+ rights: would-be NSW kingmakers outline demands
With a hung state parliament a real possibility, independents are listing the issues they want addressed to guarantee their support

Tamsin Rose

27, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM