Refugee advocates ‘encouraged’ as Albanese government considers ways to reduce immigration detention backlog

Minister says people ‘should be living in the community’ if there are no security or safety concerns

The Albanese government is investigating alternatives to immigration detention, and considering the creation of a review panel to help clear the “intractable” caseload of people held for long periods.

Refugee and asylum seeker stakeholders report that the immigration minister, Andrew Giles, and the Department of Home Affairs have been “proactive” in consultations and there are already “encouraging” signs more people assessed as a low risk to the community are being released.

In comments to Guardian Australia, Giles recommitted to “risk-based immigration detention policies”, including that people should be living in the community if they do not pose a risk.

Giles met stakeholders in late July and early August, with a further briefing from the department revealing options under consideration included a review panel to reassess the more than 1,400 people in detention.

The alternatives to immigration detention included release on a visa, whether permanent or a bridging visa; community detention; and release on conditions, including reporting to the department.

Giles told Guardian Australia that the government “is committed to ensuring humane and risk-based immigration detention policies”.

“If there are no security or safety concerns, individuals should be living in the community until a durable solution is finalised,” he said.

“Since becoming minister I have met the Commonwealth Ombudsman, the UNHCR, the Australian Human Rights Commission and the Red Cross to discuss their crucial role in providing independent oversight of the immigration detention network.”

Giles cited Labor’s commitments in its national platform, which include that “indefinite or otherwise arbitrary is not acceptable and the length and conditions of detention, including the appropriateness of both the accommodation and the services provided, will be subject to regular review”.

The AHRC said it had met with Giles on 28 July and attended a departmental briefing on alternatives to held detention.

“The commission has long recommended that the Migration Act be amended to ensure that closed immigration detention (including alternative places of detention) is only used in circumstances where it is strictly necessary to manage unacceptable risks to the community and for the shortest period necessary.”

Hannah Dickinson, the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre’s principal solicitor, said these alternatives were “not novel” and were already in use.

“No revolution [is required],” she said.

Power said “solutions have to be found” and the Albanese government had “been proactive about what the answers might be”.

“There is a recognition that it’s counterproductive, that the outcome is nothing except the denial of freedom of people with no alternative available.

“The psychological impact of prolonged and indefinite detention are well known.”

Dickinson said the situation was “really serious”.

“A decade of deteriorating conditions and extraordinary time blowouts have resulted in deaths, unnecessary and in many cases unjustifiable detention.”

The system involved “a catch-22 that detention is making people so unwell the government is worried about then releasing them”, she said.

“We’ve been encouraged about the pragmatic, humane decision-making in releases from detention [since May]. It’s slow but encouraging – we’re optimistic.”

The ASRC is calling for detention to be a last resort not a mandatory starting point, as well as maximum detention times, a review of all current detainees, closure of the “unsustainable and inhumane” Christmas Island facility, and review of detention practices including the use of solitary confinement and restraints.

A brief to the incoming government revealed the average time spent in immigration detention was almost two years, with almost a third of those in detention for more than five years.

The department was struggling to deal with an “intractable caseload of individuals” who cannot be returned to their country of origin, it said.

Refugee and asylum seeker groups said the government was aware there was a crisis in detention and planned to fix risk assessment protocols that have seen numbers swell.

Paul Power, chief executive of the Refugee Council of Australia, said immigration detention was supposed to be “administrative, for the purpose of resolving your status” but had become progressively longer term due to the “significant number” of people who were refugees, stateless or could not be returned because their citizenship was not recognised by their country of birth.

Power blamed a series of changes to the Migration Act “lowering the threshold to be detained so that people who posed no significant risk to the community were swept into detention”.

“Nothing constructive is being gained by detention. If no resolution or removal to another country is possible, and people are not serious enough a risk to warrant this additional punishment, they should be released.”


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
David Pocock blasts Albanese government as it reauthorises Nauru offshore immigration detention
Labor also seeks to overturn court decision that forced it to release 100 people from onshore detention despite character concerns

Paul Karp

07, Feb, 2023 @7:44 AM

Article image
Albanese admits Coalition 'stopped the boats' and opposes detention time limit
Labor frontbencher denies plotting to replace Bill Shorten if party falters in byelections

Paul Karp

10, Jul, 2018 @9:57 AM

Article image
Albanese government to commit to multi-employer bargaining despite business concerns
Treasurer Jim Chalmers says ‘sufficient common ground’ has been reached at jobs summit although employer groups fear industry-wide strike action

Paul Karp

01, Sep, 2022 @4:07 AM

Article image
Anthony Albanese to push ‘family-first’ security treaty in address to Papua New Guinea parliament
Australian PM to call for ‘a swift conclusion to negotiations’ to treaty and say both countries should ‘work as equals with our fellow Pacific states’

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

11, Jan, 2023 @11:30 AM

Article image
Albanese government urged to end legal fight over power to deport Aboriginal people
Greens senator Lidia Thorpe calls on Labor to pull appeal launched by Morrison government, saying Indigenous people ‘cannot be aliens to this country’

Paul Karp

17, Jun, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Anthony Albanese labels Labor's Australians First ad a 'shocker'
Albanese appears to blame Bill Shorten for the ad, which was savaged as racist on social media, and which the Labor leader acknowledged was ‘a bad oversight’

Paul Karp

08, May, 2017 @1:54 AM

Article image
Anthony Albanese seeks legal advice over reports Scott Morrison secretly swore himself into ministry roles
Former prime minister’s senior cabinet colleagues say they were unaware he allegedly swore himself into three ministry positions

Josh Butler and Sarah Martin

15, Aug, 2022 @12:23 AM

Article image
Anthony Albanese accuses Peter Dutton of ‘dog-whistling’ after attack on Cop27 climate damage fund
PM says opposition leader’s claim that climate aid is ‘giving away’ Australians’ money boosts re-election chances of independents and Greens over Liberals

Katharine Murphy Political editor

21, Nov, 2022 @8:48 AM

Article image
Albanese warns of tough budget as Coalition promises ‘hand-to-hand combat’ over cost of living
Labor to introduce legislation to fulfil an election pledge to lower the price of medicines

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

06, Sep, 2022 @8:38 AM

Article image
Labor may accelerate industrial relations reforms to ‘get wages moving’, Anthony Albanese says
Prime minister tells National Press Club government could ‘potentially take further action’ if no consensus reached at jobs and skills summit

Paul Karp

29, Aug, 2022 @5:37 AM