Government and security company reach multimillion-dollar settlements with Manus Island guards

Multiple former employees of G4S who suffered physical or mental harm after 2014 riots have been compensated days into a predicted weeks-long trial

A private security company and the federal government have spent tens of millions of dollars settling legal claims brought by Manus Island guards who were left physically or mentally damaged from riots at the detention centre.

Three more claims were settled last week, meaning 15 former guards employed by G4S have now been compensated in relation to the February 2014 riots which claimed the life of the asylum seeker Reza Berati.

Seventy-seven people were injured in the riots at the Papua New Guinea centre, including a person who was shot in the buttock and another who suffered a fractured skull.

The former guards claimed that G4S and the government were responsible for “catastrophic” failures in relation to the riots, including by inadequately training staff and not making personal protective equipment available to them.

The Victorian supreme court heard evidence last week from former guards, including one who said his mental state deteriorated so dramatically after the riot that he was unable to work and then became homeless, forcing him to live in his car.

Another former guard, Kerry Clifton, who settled her claim in 2020 but was giving evidence during the trial relating to three former colleagues, said that in the days leading up to the riot it became clear it was “getting a bit heated” because detainees had been told they would not be settled in Australia.

Multiple men behind a fence in grainy footage near two sets of staircases
The aftermath of a riot on Manus Island in a still from the 2016 Australian documentary Chasing Asylum. Photograph: Chasing Asylum

“One day, one of them said to me … when they slit my throat, that very first drop of blood would be very precious to them,” she told the court.

Troy Rivers, another former guard who also settled his case prior to last week, said the chaotic and terrifying riots continued to cause him nightmares, and he required ongoing mental health support more than eight years later.

“It has affected my mental health, I’m not the same,” Rivers told the Guardian. “Even last night [I] woke up a few times screaming.

Troy Rivers
Troy Rivers is one of 15 former guards who have had legal claims against the federal government and company G4S settled. Photograph: Troy Rivers

“It’s a stain on Australia’s history.”

Kim Price, a partner at Arnold Thomas & Becker who represented the former guards, said that further details regarding the settlements – including the amount paid to individual guards – could not be released.

The settlements last week occurred only days into what was expected to be a weeks-long trial.

Price is also representing six more former guards.

“These further settlements reinforce the catastrophic and negligent failures by the commonwealth government and security firm G4S,” Price said.

Price is also taking legal action on behalf of two former guards against their previous law firms, Slater and Gordon and Maurice Blackburn, arguing that the firms were negligent in failing to commence proceedings on behalf of the guards within the six-year limitation.

“This means that these guards may not have the opportunity to seek compensation, even though their cases have merit,” Price said.

“These two individuals suffered intense trauma and have not worked since the riots.

“They are entitled to seek compensation for loss of earnings and pain and suffering, following the failures of the federal government and G4S to provide a safe workplace when riots took hold of the detention centre.”

Three more cases involving former guards are listed in Victoria’s supreme court next month.


Nino Bucci

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Manus Island: judge approves $70m compensation for detainees
Lawyers hope to have sum paid before offshore detention centre closes next month in what is Australia’s largest human rights class action settlement

Ben Doherty

06, Sep, 2017 @1:05 AM

Article image
Australian government and G4S settle lawsuit by staffer in Manus Island riots
Dozens of witnesses were due to give evidence about 2014 riots which security officer Grant Potter says left him with severe psychological injuries

Melissa Davey

02, Jun, 2020 @4:47 AM

Article image
Manus Island detainees rebel against guards after death of refugee
Inmates ‘kicked the officers and staff out in a serious way’ for a night of protest, says Iranian journalist Behrouz Boochani

Elle Hunt and Ben Doherty with agencies

25, Dec, 2016 @5:26 AM

Article image
Government to pay $70m damages to 1,905 Manus detainees in class action
Refugees and asylum seekers awarded $70m plus costs for physical and mental injuries suffered in detention centre

Ben Doherty and Calla Wahlquist

14, Jun, 2017 @2:48 AM

Article image
Where does the Coalition's re-election leave refugees on Manus and Nauru?
Labor’s promise to resettle some refugees in New Zealand had been a source of hope, now they fear languishing indefinitely

Michael McGowan

30, May, 2019 @10:08 PM

Article image
Australian government pays heavy penalty for Manus mistreatment | Richard Ackland
Irrespective of what Peter Dutton says, this has been a ground-breaking outcome, and Nauru could be Coalition’s next headache

Richard Ackland

16, Jun, 2017 @10:14 PM

Article image
Australian government and G4S hit with multiple lawsuits from Manus Island staff
Exclusive: At least four cases filed alleging security guards and managers were not provided with a safe workplace

Melissa Davey

27, Dec, 2018 @2:00 AM

Article image
Asylum seeker found dead on Manus Island
Circumstances of the man’s death are contested by other refugees on the island after his body was found in forest near the East Lorengau transit centre

Ben Doherty

07, Aug, 2017 @3:00 AM

Article image
Australian government downplayed risk of shots fired on Manus Island, analysis shows
Amnesty International has released expert analysis of photos and video from the Good Friday incident that directly contradicts the official account

Ben Doherty

15, May, 2017 @1:05 AM

Article image
Manus Island refugees seriously injured in machete attacks
Three separate robberies – two with machetes – likely to increase resistance among refugees to being forcibly removed from the closing detention centre

Ben Doherty

31, Jul, 2017 @3:56 AM