Law governing Bureau of Meteorology must change to reflect climate crisis, says former chief

Exclusive: Rob Vertessy says there was a ‘baked-in cautiousness’ in the bureau about discussing climate change under the Coalition

A former chief executive of the Bureau of Meteorology says the 67-year-old law that underpins Australia’s weather agency needs to be updated to bring it in line with the modern-day climate crisis.

Dr Rob Vertessy, who left the bureau in 2016 after five years in charge, said the Meteorology Act 1955 should be revised to give the bureau “a broader environmental intelligence remit”.

“I do think [the act] is of an age that it isn’t really relevant to the challenges of a planetary crisis,” Vertessy said.

“The public interest would be better served if we mandated an agency to have a broader remit. Given what the country is facing, there should be more of an emphasis on that.”

Last week the bureau came under fire from former staff and scientists who claimed it had been “cowering in the corner” on the climate crisis – an allegation the agency rejected.

Former bureau scientists told Guardian Australia that almost a decade of Coalition governments had meant climate change had become politically sensitive within the organisation.

Vertessy led the agency through the government of Tony Abbott – a known climate change sceptic who once described climate science as “absolute crap”.

Vertessy told Guardian Australia there was a “baked-in cautiousness” in the BoM that was established in all government agencies under conservative governments.

This had reinforced a “policy paralysis problem” in responding to the climate crisis because the dominant public narrative “underrates both the urgency to act and the extent of change needed”.

“The consequence of this is that the public get a muted view of the climate situation from government agencies,” he said. “It is more grim and dangerous than most people realise and that’s problematic.”

Vertessy told Guardian Australia he had never been directed by a minister to “refrain from public commentary on climate change or even tone down my style” but there were “various cues that you get to calibrate your approach”.

“Nonetheless you do come to understand you can’t just go out there and keep creating heat in the media environment for the government, because that backfires on your agency,” he said.

“The best-case scenario then is you are frozen out and not consulted. The worst case is you are punished by being overlooked in future budgets. It is all very unspoken and, dare I say it, grey and shadowy.”

He said public servants “understand and accept that it is verboten [forbidden] to criticise government policies” but at the science-policy interface “there is some grey area when it comes to public comment”.

Reporting scientific facts was uncontentious, he said, but if doing that “invokes media and public criticism of government policies” then friction arises “and this is certainly common in the area of climate change”.

The Meteorology Act established the role of the bureau and its director but it predates concerns about climate change.

“It’s uncontentious that weather and forecasts is core business,” Vertessy said. “But there’s less formal direction when it comes to climate. When it comes to climate change, a mandate for being the voice for it is not reflected in the 1955 act.”

Email: sign up for our daily morning and afternoon email newsletters

App: download our free app and never miss the biggest stories

Social: follow us on YouTubeTikTokInstagramFacebook or Twitter

Podcast: listen to our daily episodes on Apple PodcastsSpotify or search "Full Story" in your favourite app

Instead, Vertessy said, governments, ministers and the bureau’s director of meteorology (which is the title of the chief executive) “have had degrees of discretion about whether [the bureau] is in that game or not”.

Vertessy said there had “probably been a greater appetite for senior officials to hold forth on climate change with progressive governments than conservative ones”.

“My sense is that the current government is more welcoming of expert opinion on climate change matters as it seeks to build community support for policy action,” he said.


Graham Readfearn

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Bureau of Meteorology was ‘cowering in the corner’ on climate crisis, former staff claim
Exclusive: Claims that discussing climate change at BoM ‘is basically banned’ come after allegations of a toxic workplace culture

Graham Readfearn

22, Oct, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
BoM boss apologises for rebranding debacle and says there are ‘significant learnings’ for bureau
Andrew Johnson tells Senate hearing ‘image rebrand’ followed research suggesting elderly and new immigrants were confused by term BoM

Graham Readfearn

28, Oct, 2022 @7:27 AM

Article image
Former weather bureau chief says agency debilitated by climate deniers' attacks
Rob Vertessy says attacks such as the claim the bureau was ‘fabricating temperature records’ are dangerous and wrong

Michael Slezak

21, Sep, 2017 @4:18 AM

Article image
Tony Abbott is a climate change 'villain', says Canadian author Naomi Klein
The writer, who is coming to Australia on a speaking tour, says she cannot tell where the coal industry ends and the federal government begins

Oliver Milman

16, Aug, 2015 @9:43 PM

Article image
Climate crisis will bring more and worse tropical cyclones to Australia’s east coast, study predicts
Research conducted jointly by IAG insurer and the US National Center for Atmospheric Research warns of ‘rapidly increasing risk’ from severe storms

Peter Hannam

14, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Tony Abbott says climate change is 'probably doing good'
Former Australian PM delivers speech in London comparing global warming action to ‘killing goats to appease volcano gods’

Karl Mathiesen for Climate Home in London

09, Oct, 2017 @8:06 PM

Article image
Tony Abbott adviser calls for Bureau of Meteorology 'warming' inquiry
Climate change sceptic Maurice Newman wants a government-funded review to ‘dispel suspicions of a warming bias’

Oliver Milman

01, Oct, 2014 @5:35 AM

Article image
Tony Abbott's climate change speech 'loopy', says Labor
Tanya Plibersek says Abbott’s speech to climate sceptics in London was ‘actually just weird stuff’

Katharine Murphy Political editor

10, Oct, 2017 @8:52 AM

Article image
Stripped bare: Australia's hidden climate crisis
An epidemic of land clearing is sabotaging efforts to address climate change. Farming communities are bitterly divided over the issue – but it also has global consequences

Anne Davies, Mike Bowers, Andy Ball and Nick Evershed

16, Oct, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Abbott considered investigation into 'exaggerated' Bureau of Meteorology temperature data
Documents show former PM was briefed on setting up a taskforce into whether the Bureau of Meteorology exaggerated records – as claimed in the Australian

Daniel Hurst Political correspondent

23, Sep, 2015 @11:51 PM