Alleged clergy abuse survivor wins right to appeal case to high court of Australia

NSW court of appeal had ruled case could not be heard because priest accused of abusing applicant when she was 14 had since died

A survivor of alleged clergy abuse has won the right to appeal to the high court against a decision to throw out her case because the alleged paedophile priest had died.

The high court on Friday agreed to hear an appeal from a woman, known only as GLJ, who alleges she was abused when she was 14 by Lismore priest Father Clarence Anderson.

Anderson died before she lodged civil action and the NSW court of appeal ruled that his death rendered the Catholic church unable to properly defend the claim or receive a fair trial.

The decision has had widespread ramifications for other cases of clergy abuse, where the priest or church member has died.

Guardian Australia revealed this week that the ruling had, according to five separate law firms, emboldened the church to take an aggressive approach to other cases where paedophile clergy have died, using it to pressure other survivors into accepting low-ball and “paltry” sums of compensation, or face having their case thrown out.

The lengthy delays in such cases – the child abuse royal commission said it took more than 22 years on average for survivors to come forward – means it is common for clergy to have died by the time a claim is brought.

Ken Cush & Associates, who represented GLJ, took the case to the high court on Friday, seeking special leave to appeal.

They said it was possible for the church to receive a fair trial, despite Anderson’s death, and asked the court to consider whether his unavailability was “sufficient to warrant a permanent stay”.

GLJ’s lawyers argued that extensive evidence about Anderson’s abuse of children was held by the church. It also had four other witnesses to testify to Anderson’s history of abuse.

They also argued that the decision subverted the intent of state and territory parliaments, which had removed the time limit on bringing civil cases after the royal commission. In doing so, they were emphatic in saying they wanted such cases to proceed to trial, regardless of any delay.

“The surprising conclusion of the court of appeal was that, notwithstanding the survival of comprehensive documentary evidence about Anderson’s clerical career and his laicisation, about his abuse of other children, and about the diocesan authorities’ knowledge of those matters at the relevant time, and notwithstanding the availability of the applicant and at least four other witnesses to testify to Anderson’s history of abuse, a fair trial could not be had,” GLJ’s lawyers wrote in their application to the high court.

“Central to the court of appeal’s conclusion was the proposition that because Anderson was unavailable to give factual instructions, and the Diocesan Trust had not been notified of the applicant’s claims before his death, a fair trial was impossible.

“That erroneous conclusion arose from the misapplication of authority – including of this Court – in an important, novel and highly sensitive context: namely, claims of institutional liability for historical sexual abuse, for which no limitation provision now applies.

“Across a range of areas, a claimant is entitled not only to proceed to but to succeed at trial, even though the person responsible for that claim is deceased, or is otherwise unavailable to give instructions.”

GLJ’s lawyers argued there was also “copious” amounts of evidence about Anderson and the church’s knowledge of his abuse. Records showed that the church knew Anderson was abusing other children years before GLJ, and continued to do so after being shuffled between parishes.

The high court will hear the appeal at a later date.

Contributor

Christopher Knaus

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Watershed moment’: Australian child abuse survivors finally have real access to justice
In the past, victims sought legal help only to be met with the further humiliation of unjust settlements. But the tide has begun to turn

Christopher Knaus

17, Sep, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Cardinal George Pell to find out if he's reached end of road to appeal child sexual abuse conviction
If high court decides on Wednesday not to hear an appeal, Pell’s sentence will stand

Melissa Davey

12, Nov, 2019 @5:17 AM

Article image
Abuse survivors in bid to seize Catholic properties after church fails to pay court costs
Three survivors who settled with Marist Brothers have taken action after church fails to follow court order to cover legal costs

Christopher Knaus

28, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
George Pell funeral: removing abuse victims’ ribbons is wrong, former church official says
Advocates furious the church keeps removing ribbons intended to give voice to survivors of clergy abuse

Christopher Knaus

30, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
‘Petty’: ribbons for abuse victims removed from Sydney church hosting Pell funeral
Campaigners have been tying coloured ribbons to fence of St Mary’s Cathedral ahead of Cardinal George Pell’s mass on Thursday 2 February

Christopher Knaus and Caitlin Cassidy

18, Jan, 2023 @6:22 AM

Article image
High court rejects Brisbane grammar abuse victim’s bid to reopen compensation claim
Other victims of paedophile who worked at the school say Queensland government ‘needs to make institutions look after victims morally’

Amanda Gearing

20, May, 2021 @9:07 AM

Article image
Victoria to abolish 'Ellis defence' that protects church assets from abuse victim claims
Legislation to facilitate compensation claims widely expected to pass

Melissa Davey

06, Mar, 2018 @3:50 AM

Article image
George Pell funeral: Tony Abbott praises cardinal as a ‘saint for our times’ and rails against child abuse charges
Former PM says the cardinal was ‘the greatest man I’ve ever known’, likening his treatment to a ‘modern-day crucifixion’

Christopher Knaus

02, Feb, 2023 @5:46 AM

Article image
Melbourne archbishop says he'd rather go to jail than report child abuse heard in confession
Denis Hart says ‘communication with God is of a higher order’ after child sex abuse inquiry calls for failure to report to become a criminal offence

Melissa Davey and agencies

14, Aug, 2017 @11:58 PM

Article image
Hobart archbishop says scale of abuse by Catholic clergy 'difficult' to understand
Julian Porteous tells royal commission blame lies with individual perpetrators but agrees there had been a massive failure in church leadership

Christopher Knaus

21, Feb, 2017 @1:57 AM