Australia ordered to negotiate with 122 Indonesians wrongly held in adult jails when they were children

The Indonesians launched a class action over being imprisoned as adult people smugglers on the basis of flawed medical evidence

The Australian government has been ordered to attempt to negotiate a settlement with more than 100 Indonesians who say they were wrongly imprisoned as adult people smugglers when they were children, on the basis of flawed medical evidence.

The 122 Indonesians launched a landmark class action against the federal government two years ago claiming wrongful detention between 2008 and 2011.

The children, some as young as 13, were held in immigration detention or adult jails using a deeply flawed wrist X-ray technique to estimate their ages.

Government policy required that minors be sent home rather than charged, but federal police relied on the X-ray technique to pursue the children as though they were adults.

Police had already been told the technique was unreliable and prone to error. The immigration department, by at least June 2010, also knew the method to be flawed, but did nothing to intervene to stop the prosecutions.

Many of the children were from impoverished regions of Indonesia and had been lured on to boats with vague promises of paid work, not realising they were to transport asylum seekers to Australia.

The Indonesians’ lawyers, Ken Cush & Associates, hope the case will give them substantial compensation for wrongful imprisonment. The commonwealth is defending the claim and has previously filed a defence rejecting most of the allegations.

Late last month, the federal court ordered the two parties enter mediation before a registrar until March 2023.

In the mediation, the two groups will exchange information on a confidential basis about each member of the class action. Ken Cush & Associates will also need to provide “particulars of the nature and quantum of each group member’s claims of loss and damage” by early next month.

The mediation could lead to a settlement between the parties. Should it fail, the commonwealth would need to retrieve and provide all of the documentary evidence it holds for the Indonesian children, and the matter would probably head to trial, probably sometime next year.

The lead plaintiff in the class action, Ali Jasmin, spent more than two years in a maximum-security prison but was released in 2012 and deported back to Indonesia due to doubts about his age. He is thought to have been just 13 at the time of his arrest. His conviction was overturned in 2017, a decision that has since prompted other convicted Indonesians to seek justice.

Earlier this year, the Guardian used a tranche of documents filed in a separate set of six appeals to show how federal police and senior figures in the then Labor government were told there were doubts about the accuracy of the X-ray technique to determine age well before some of the boys were jailed.

Internal records showed an investigating officer in some of the six cases had been involved in a remarkably similar prosecution eight years earlier, during which the court heard that using wrist X-ray evidence to determine age was open to error and “not an exact science”, and that the key reference tool on which it depended should be used with “judicious scepticism”.

Despite those concerns, police continued to rely on the wrist X-rays and used them to alter the dates of birth provided to them by the six children. The fictitious dates were placed on sworn documents used as the basis for the prosecutions.

Some of the six boys were held in maximum security prisons in WA for years before being released and sent home.

The six appeals were successful and the WA court of appeal found a “substantial miscarriage of justice” had occurred.

Two other Indonesians – Samsul Bahar and Anto – are also attempting to overturn their convictions. They had previously sought a referral from the then attorney general, Christian Porter, to allow them the chance for a fresh appeal, because they had previously exhausted their appeal rights on other, unrelated grounds.

Porter denied them the opportunity to appeal in 2020, saying they had no prospects of success, despite Jasmin’s conviction being overturned on the same grounds three years earlier.

The two boys, through Ken Cush & Associates, have since written to the new attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, asking him to use his mercy powers to allow their appeal and resolve the “mockery of justice” overseen by the last government.


Christopher Knaus

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Systemic failures at every step’: the Indonesian children Australia sent to adult jails for years
Six children jailed as adults for acting as crew on people-smuggling boats have had their convictions quashed. But Australian authorities had been told before they were jailed of doubts about the wrist X-ray technique used to prove they were over 18

Christopher Knaus and Ben Doherty

26, Apr, 2022 @3:16 AM

Article image
‘They were tiny’: the Indonesians still fighting their conviction as adults in Australia
Anto and Samsul Bahar were 15 when they were jailed in a maximum security facility in Western Australia

Christopher Knaus and Ben Doherty

29, Apr, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Christian Porter denied justice plea from Indonesians jailed in Australia when they were children
Former attorney general refused to refer cases to WA court of appeal, despite an earlier ruling finding a miscarriage of justice in a similar case

Christopher Knaus

27, Apr, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Australia to be investigated for jailing Indonesian children in adult prisons, lawyers say
Lawyers say more than 60 children suspected of people-smuggling convicted as adults

Christopher Knaus

07, Feb, 2018 @10:31 PM

Article image
Indonesian children jailed in Australia as adult people smugglers win court battle to clear their names
Six teens lured to crew boats from their impoverished villages repeatedly told officials they were children – 12 years on, a court has finally believed them

Christopher Knaus and Ben Doherty

26, Apr, 2022 @2:40 AM

Article image
Indonesian boys wrongly imprisoned by Australia ask attorney general for new appeal
Exclusive: Lawyers for two Indonesian children wrongly jailed for people smuggling ask Mark Dreyfus to refer case for appeal, calling Christian Porter’s ruling on the case a ‘mockery of justice’

Christopher Knaus and Ben Doherty

17, Aug, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Indonesians jailed for people-smuggling offences seek compensation
Australian lawyer representing the 55 people says they had been jailed as adults while still minors

Christopher Knaus

27, Jan, 2018 @5:21 AM

Article image
Expert warned against wrist X-rays used by AFP to prosecute children as adult people smugglers
Radiologist James Christie’s court evidence said technique had no scientific validity and was never intended to assess age

Christopher Knaus

03, May, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Australian government facing class action led by Indonesian boy wrongfully jailed in adult prison
The government solicitor argues most of the allegations are ‘scandalous and embarrassing’

Paul Karp

10, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
‘Red flags’ raised over scheme to allow families of Pacific Island workers to join them in Australia
Families who relocate under federal scheme would not have access to Medicare, or relocation or housing costs, making move unviable for many, experts warn

Jordyn Beazley

22, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM