Tony Burke vows to ‘fix’ parliament as crossbench demands reform

Greens and independent MPs want Dorothy Dixers banned and more input in question time after ‘farce’ of previous term

Labor’s Tony Burke has said he is “determined to fix” how parliament works as crossbench MPs submit long lists of demands to boost their voice and influence.

More crossbench questions in question time, abolishing Dorothy Dixers, and guaranteed debates and votes on private members’ bills are some of the most common requests from returning crossbench MPs.

The crossbench of seven will expand to at least 15 after the Greens gained seats in Brisbane and independents captured heartland Liberal seats. But Labor is still on track to form a narrow majority.

Burke, who is likely to become leader of the house in the 47th parliament, has already met the independent MP Helen Haines to discuss the ideas, many of which are drawn from an Australia Institute research paper to reform Australia’s democracy.

Haines was a member of the parliamentary committee which proposed reforms to question time in the last parliament, ideas that she said “went nowhere”.

She said Dorothy Dixers – prepared questions and answers – should be banned, along with those asking about “alternative approaches”, which are used to invite stump speeches bashing opposition policies.

“They’re a waste of space … and the general public hate them,” she said.

Haines wants a minimum of four crossbench questions in question time, a “proportional increase”, and one day of private members’ business a week.

The independent MP also wants a minimum notice period before the government puts its own bills to a vote, with a “genuine opportunity to have prior consultation and propose amendments”, including more crossbench input into committees.

Those and new rules preventing legislation being introduced and passed in the same sitting could result in “better legislation and a more effective way to work”, she said.

Haines said the requirement for an absolute majority to suspend standing orders should be changed to a simple majority: “We saw how that operated during Covid, we could well have had an integrity commission if not for that rule.”

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

Burke said: “The Australian people have made clear they want integrity in government and in the parliament itself.

“In the last term in particular the House of Representatives became a farce. I’m determined to fix that and I’m having conversations across the parliament to that end.”

The Greens leader, Adam Bandt, who will be joined by at least two more Greens MPs, for Griffith and Ryan, and potentially four, said: “MPs outside the government should have the right to have their issues progress through parliament.

“Private members should have the right to take their matters to a vote, that happened in 2010 in the power-sharing parliament and it led to some significant reforms.”

Bandt said in the last parliament Liberal backbenchers were “prepared to defect … to support debate on an anti-corruption commission” but the government had refused to allow a vote on the bill.

He said there was “a lot to be said” for removing the requirement for an absolute majority to suspend standing orders, noting that the crossbench had been “excluded from pairing arrangements” and pairs between the “old parties” made it difficult to reach that threshold.

Bandt said he wanted to end the practice of starting sitting days with the Lord’s prayer and to display First Nations flags in the chambers.

The incoming independent MP for North Sydney, Kylea Tink, said parliament should shift from “a staged show to what it was designed to, be a chamber for robust debate and discussion”.

“It’s about ensuring all communities are heard equally – whether you voted for someone sitting in government or not … just because one major party is in government, I don’t think that should kill consensus-seeking,” she said.

Tink said that, watching from the outside, question time was a “dissatisfying experience”, full of “jeering and yahooing”. “I didn’t feel like anything was addressing real questions people had,” she said.

The incoming independent MP for Goldstein, Zoe Daniel, said it was “important the parliamentary process evolves” to give newly elected independents a voice to represent their communities.

“If Anthony Albanese means what he says about inclusivity, he needs to reflect on how that should play out on the floor of parliament,” she said.

The independent MP for Warringah, Zali Steggall, said with one-third of Australians voting for independents or minor parties, the parliament has a “record-breaking crossbench”.

“The outcome of the election signals a move away from us v them, blue-team v red-team politics, and this has the potential to transform our political discourse, bring back respectful debate and make petty wedge politics a lesser force in the formation of policy.”

Contributor

Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Listen, engage, show you care: how Greens and independents took local politics all the way to Canberra
Voters disenchanted with the cynical politics of the main parties were ripe for conversion – they just needed someone to knock on their door and listen

Tory Shepherd

28, May, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Moderate Liberal MPs sign on to crossbench-led climate action group
Parliamentary Friends of Climate Action aims to serve as a safe place for climate policy, away from ‘partisan politics’

Amy Remeikis

09, Oct, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Greens' hot air balloon protest deflated by new flight restriction over parliament
Party vows to go ahead with climate protest in Canberra despite ‘unprecedented decision to block air traffic’

Paul Karp

13, Oct, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
What happens if there is a hung parliament: how would independents approach talks and what is non-negotiable?
Read the full responses from independent candidates and crossbench MPs surveyed

Christopher Knaus

12, May, 2022 @2:46 AM

Article image
Australian government gags debate to ram environmental law changes through lower house
The move outrages Labor, the Greens, crossbench MPs and conservationists with the legislation now headed to the Senate

Lisa Cox

03, Sep, 2020 @10:04 AM

Article image
Tony Burke shuts down push for radical changes to Labor's asylum-seeker policy
Party’s national conference will not adopt any position ‘that would start the drownings again’, manager of opposition business says

Gareth Hutchens with Australian Associated Press

09, Dec, 2018 @3:53 AM

Article image
Tony Burke promises crossbench ‘guaranteed respect’ in new parliament but says staff cuts to stay
Leader of the House also outlines changes to make sitting hours more family friendly

Paul Karp

20, Jul, 2022 @12:32 AM

Article image
The best way to Dutton-proof climate legislation is to get it into parliament and get it passed | Katharine Murphy
Labor, the Greens and the teals should be focusing on widening the footprint of support for climate action, rather than preserving product differentiation

Katharine Murphy

22, Jul, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
‘Naccflip’: National anti-corruption commission bill passes Senate after Greens backdown
Minor party resolves to support a crossbench amendment instead of Coalition on key appointment

Paul Karp

29, Nov, 2022 @8:22 AM

Article image
'No one can assume': who will independents back if there is a hung parliament?
Rebekha Sharkie and Zali Steggall have indicated they will support the Coalition but other election candidates are hedging their bets

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

30, Apr, 2019 @10:00 PM