Independents say crossbencher staff cuts will ‘slow down’ Labor’s legislative agenda

United Australia Party joins criticism as Albanese cites ‘fairness and equity’ and says private discussions have been more ‘constructive’

Anthony Albanese is staring down the prospect of a “Senate strike” over cuts to parliamentary staff, suggesting crossbenchers are being more “constructive” in private.

The prime minister brushed off the controversy created by Labor’s decision to cut crossbench MPs and senators’ staffing allocation from eight to five each, despite the United Australia Party joining the ranks of those criticising the decision.

On Friday Labor revealed that crossbench parliamentarians will receive just one adviser in addition to four electorate office staff, down from four under the Morrison government, prompting One Nation and senators Jacqui Lambie and David Pocock to threaten government bills.

But despite emotions ranging from disappointment to rage, Pocock has signalled a Senate go-slow is more likely than a strike, saying he wants to remain “constructive” and will only withhold his vote when he can’t decide on the merits of legislation.

Albanese defended the cut, arguing that the increase to four extra staff was “very new” and “fairness and equity” meant crossbench MPs shouldn’t have twice the staff of government and opposition MPs.

“Labor wasn’t a part of those arrangements and aren’t aware of what their transaction details were,” he told reporters on Sunday evening.

Albanese noted assistant ministers only get two additional staff, arguing it was not “sustainable” for crossbench MPs to have more.

“But crossbench members, we’ve been conscious that they do need extra support,” he said. “They will receive an extra staff member in addition to their entitlement, and that staff member will be able to travel right around the country with their member of parliament.”

On the prospect of disruption in parliament, Albanese said that “the public comments from some of the crossbench members have not been echoed by the ones that I’ve spoken to one-on-one who want to be constructive”.

In an interview with ABC radio, Albanese suggested the increase under Morrison had been secret, noting “I didn’t know, and I can’t find any great record of any publicity” for crossbenchers having double the staff of backbench MPs.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning.

Albanese accused some crossbench MPs of “misconceptions” including “some [who] have said that we don’t want our electorate officers to have to do parliamentary work”.

“Well, the fact is that people who work as electorate officers often do parliamentary work.”

The finance minister, Katy Gallagher, said that through “respectful and constructive engagement” with the crossbench, the government hoped to avoid a “go slow or refusal to engage on legislation”.

She said a compromise to increase the allocation from one to two would be up to Albanese but “our starting point was four … is unsustainable”.

Ralph Babet, the newly elected senator for the United Australia Party in Victoria, told Guardian Australia that “cutting independent and minor party parliamentary staff allocation by 75% will make it very difficult for us to be able to do our jobs effectively”.

“The prime minister is essentially pumping the brakes on our ability to scrutinise the government and the legislation they may propose. We call on the prime minister to review his decision,” he said.

Earlier, Pocock told ABC News Breakfast it was a “such a disappointing start” that the government’s first interaction with the crossbench was cutting staff that allow them to represent their communities.

“The cynical take is that the PM knows how little sympathy people have for politicians and their staff, and so this is a way to actually minimise the crossbench [influence].”

Asked about the prospect of blocking government bills, Pocock replied: “I’m there to be constructive. I’ve said that publicly. I’ve made that known to the prime minister’s office.

“Having said that, talking to senators who have been in a similar position in the past, they’ve told me it will basically be impossible to be able to be across all the legislation.”

Pocock said while he would not want to see a deliberate delaying of legislation, if crossbenchers do not have the staff to get across all the legislation put before the Senate, “that’s clearly going to then slow down the government’s legislative agenda.”

Any disruption of the government’s Senate program would require cooperation from the Greens, who have also been critical of the staffing cut, and the Coalition, which has expressed limited sympathy.

On Monday the independent MP Zali Steggall said there was “nothing secret” about the staffing allocations, which were “on the record” in documents tabled in parliament.

“There were no deals and [House of Representatives] crossbench MPs and senators were all treated equally,” Steggall tweeted. “[The government] saying they didn’t know or realise is disingenuous.”

Steggall argued that, given the government’s staff of 463 (mostly ministerial advisers) were available to all MPs, Labor backbenchers had the equivalent of six additional staff each to access in other colleagues’ offices.

Steggall said the parliamentary library “doesn’t give advice on effect of proposed bills” and its “staff isn’t available out of hours and on short notice to respond to government bills”.


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australian politicians respond to US abortion decision – as it happened
This blog is now closed

Cait Kelly and Graham Readfearn (earlier)

26, Jun, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Ministers defend cut to crossbenchers’ advisers, despite fury of Jacqui Lambie and other independents
Lambie, Zali Steggall and David Pocock have attacked the Albanese government’s decision, saying they may not support legislation if they don’t have the resources to understand it

Paul Karp

26, Jun, 2022 @12:38 AM

Article image
Teal independents: who are they and how did they upend Australia’s election?
What does historic move of voters away from the two major parties mean for the future of Australian politics?

Calla Wahlquist

23, May, 2022 @8:59 AM

Article image
Teal MPs say capping superannuation at $3m might undermine confidence in saving for retirement
Despite this pushback, most crossbench MPs remain open to debate, and several independent senators have spoken in favour of curbing some super tax concessions to help budget repair

Paul Karp

24, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
David Pocock to use Senate balance of power to push for waiving of ACT’s public housing debt
Independent calls for $100m debt to be wiped as part of negotiations over Labor’s $10bn housing policy, which also faces Greens resistance

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

10, Aug, 2022 @4:44 AM

Article image
David Pocock under pressure to block Labor’s safeguard mechanism bill after fossil fuel poll
With 62% of Canberrans backing a ban on new coal and gas projects, Labor faces tough task convincing ACT senator

Paul Karp

08, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Listen, engage, show you care: how Greens and independents took local politics all the way to Canberra
Voters disenchanted with the cynical politics of the main parties were ripe for conversion – they just needed someone to knock on their door and listen

Tory Shepherd

28, May, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
What happens if there is a hung parliament: how would independents approach talks and what is non-negotiable?
Read the full responses from independent candidates and crossbench MPs surveyed

Christopher Knaus

12, May, 2022 @2:46 AM

Article image
Clare O’Neil suggests Labor may legislate fines after Optus data breach – as it happened
This blog is now closed

Stephanie Convery (now) and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

26, Sep, 2022 @9:08 AM

Article image
One Nation senators and David Pocock granted second adviser amid backlash over crossbench staff cuts
More senators and MPs due to meet Anthony Albanese next week after crossbenchers warned cuts could slow Labor’s legislative agenda

Paul Karp

22, Jul, 2022 @10:46 AM